Pickel v. McCawleyPickel v. McCawley
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Cooley
Defendants filed an answer in which they admitted the existence of the restrictions, but denied the other allegations of plaintiffs’ petition. Defendants also filed a cross-petition asking the court to enforce the restrictions and to perpetually enjoin the plaintiffs from violating the terms of the restrictions for the remainder of the term of twenty years as provided in the covenant.
At a trial of the cause the circuit court entered a judgment and decree for plaintiffs’ decreeing the restriction agreement to be null and void. The court denied the relief prayed for in defendants’ answer. From this judgment and decree the defendants appeal.
The evidence in the case warrants the finding that during the year 1923 negroes commenced to move into property on Cook Avenue, east of Vandeventer Avenue. Immediately west of Vandeventer is a colored section of the city. The owners of property east of Vandeventer, especially on Cook and Finney avenues, becoming alarmed at the fact that negroes were moving into their neighborhood and were coming east of Vandeventer Avenue, called a meeting of the property owners. At this meeting the question was discussed as to the advisability of entering into agreements restricting the neighborhood against negroes. Numerous meetings were held and the property owners urged to sign the agreements. The forms were obtained from the St. Louis Real Estate Exchange and these contain the usual provisions found in similar restriction agreements. Solicitors were appointed and evidently made a house to house canvass and attempted to obtain signatures. At a following meeting these solicitors would report as to their success
The circuit court in its judgment and decree found in part as follows:
“The court doth further find that said paper or instrument in writing, so far as the same attempts to impose restrictions or limitations on the use, occupation, enjoyment, sale, alienation (voluntary or by operation of law), and/or encumbrance by the plaintiffs or by their respective heirs, assigns or grantees or by any other person who might thereafter derive or hold title to said real estate hereinbefore described, or any part thereof, which belongs to the plaintiffs, is a cloud upon the title of the plaintiffs to the real estate hereinbefore described, and the said paper or instrument in writing was and is null and void and of no force and effect for the following reasons, to-wit:
“Because the court doth find that the signature of plaintiff Emma Pickel, in that she signed same under the representation and inducement and with the understanding that all property owners in the neighborhood and district proposed to be restricted, and particularly on Finney Avenue between Krumm Avenue and Grand Avenue, in St. Louis, Missouri, should and would also sign said paper, or a similar paper or papers, that were circulated for signatures of property owners, before the same would be recorded or become binding on those who did sign such paper or papers, and that all property owners in said neighborhood and district did not sign such paper or papers, even on the north side of Finney Avenue, in said block No. 3737 of the city of St. Louis, and
“Because the court doth further find that since the attempt to restrict the said neighborhood and district and the signing of said paper or instrument in writing by said Emma Pickel the whole neighborhood and district has come to be and now is used, occupied and enjoyed by colored people, and has completely changed, so that it is now impracticable and impossible to restrict the neighborhood and district as a desirable place of residence for persons of the Caucasian race and to carry the intention of restricting the neighborhood and district against its use or occupancy by colored people, including the north side of Finney Avenue, in said block No. 3737.”
The Circuit Court also found that the instrument bearing plaintiff Emma Pickel‘s signature was materially altered and changed after Emma Pickel had signed the same. That the alteration was made without her consent or knowledge, rendering the instrument null and void.
Defendants’ assignment of errors is as follows:
“1. The court erred in finding for plaintiffs on the evidence and in dismissing defendants’ cross-petition.
“2. The court erred in admitting testimony of the contents of the alleged prior written covenant in the absence of a sufficient showing that such instrument was either lost or destroyed, and also
in the absence of any showing of any search or diligence to procure same, and without even a notice to produce. “3. The court erred in refusing to admit the testimony of the witness Katherine Jones to the effect that the plaintiff Emma Pickel told the witness that the covenant would be binding upon her if she signed it and said nothing to witness about it being necessary to procure the signatures of 100 per cent of the property owners.”
We are disposing of the assignment of errors in reverse order. In the third assignment defendants contended that the court erred in rejecting testimony offered by defendants, which, if true, tended to prove that plaintiff Emma Pickel, made statements prior to the trial inconsistent with her testimony. This being an equitable proceeding we will dispose of the case and consider the evidence as though it had been admitted in the circuit court. [Lindhorst v. Orphan Asylum, 231 Mo. 1. c. 389; Vining v. Ramage, 319 Mo. 65, 3 S. W. (2d) 1. c. 722, and cases cited.] The offer of proof is as follows:
”Mr. O‘Malley: We offer to prove by this witness that she did have a conversation with Mrs. Pickel and that Mrs. Pickel told her that these covenants would be binding on her if she signed it, and that Mrs. Pickel, at that time, said nothing about it being necessary to procure 100 per cent of the property owners to sign the covenant before the same would be binding or would be recorded.
”Mr. Sibley: I object to that on the grounds stated.
”The Court: Sustained.”
There is no merit in defendants’ second assignment of error. Plaintiffs in their petition specifically charge that plaintiff Emma Pickel signed a written covenant which included the territory on both sides of Finney Avenue within the proposed restricted area. That afterwards some member of the association induced her to sign a second covenant representing to her that the first had been lost or destroyed. This was sufficient notice to defendants that the alleged prior covenant would be brought in question. [22 C. J. 1060, and cases cited.] There was testimony in the record of a prior covenant. A number of witnesses testified they had signed a second covenant on the representation that the first had been lost. One witness testified that the first had been mutilated. Under these circumstances the trial court did not err in admitting testimony tending to prove the boundaries contained in the first covenant. Again the existence or non-existence of a prior covenant is not a vital question in the case. [22 C. J. 1060, sec. 1359.]
The first assignment of error of defendants is that the court erred in finding for plaintiffs on the merits of the case. In considering
The court‘s finding that the signature of Emma Pickel was obtained under the representation and inducement and with the understanding that all property owners, in the neighborhood proposed to be restricted, should sign the restriction agreement, or one similar thereto, before it became binding on those who did sign, is supported by an overwhelming weight of the testimony and also by the surrounding circumstances. So convincing are the circumstances on that point that we deem it necessary to call attention to only a few salient facts which are inconsistent with any other theory. For instance, when a meeting was called to devise means to protect the neighborhood against negro invasion it was attended by owners of property from both sides of Cook and Finney avenues between Vandeventer and Grand avenues. Not one word of testimony do we find in the record that it was proposed or planned at this meeting or any other meeting to protect only the one-half block here in question. On the contrary the defendants’ own testimony establishes the fact that restriction agreements were circulated for the obtaining of the signatures of the property owners in the entire district mentioned. Also that the general talk at these meetings was with reference to protecting the entire neighborhood against negro inhabitants. The president of the association lived on Cook Avenue. Other officers were from different parts of the district. If only the one-half block in question was to be protected, what interest did the president of the association have in such a plan? The majority of those in attendance at these meetings seemed to be property owners on Cook and Finney avenues, other than those in the one-half block in question. What interest could these property owners have to protect at these meetings, except, to try to have the entire neighborhood restricted? Defendants’ witness, Mrs. Katherine Jones, testified that Mrs. Pickel solicited her to sign, and she did sign, the covenant. Mrs. Jones lived, at that time, on the south side of Finney Avenue. What became of the covenant signed by Mrs. Jones? Her name is not on the one here in question. Again, what interest did Mrs. Pickel have on the south side of Finney Avenue? Why should Mrs. Jones sign the covenant at Mrs. Pickel‘s request if only the one-half block here in question constitutes a restricted zone within itself? There is no escape from the conclusion that it was planned and understood at these meetings to have the entire district on both sides of Cook and Finney avenues within one restricted zone, and if that could not be done, then those who signed should not be bound. Subsequent events also strongly support this theory. When the officers in their desperate efforts failed to obtain sufficient signatures to block the stampede of negroes
The very object and purpose of the covenant have been defeated. In fact the conditions in the neighborhood and within the proposed restricted area were changed so radically prior to the time the covenants were recorded that the essential object of the covenants were then totally destroyed. Negroes were at liberty to buy and did purchase and occupy many homes on both Cook and Finney avenues within the proposed restricted district. There is no valid reason why the restrictions should be saddled upon plaintiffs in this case. They are living under the very conditions and surroundings against which the proposed covenant was to protect them.
We hold that under the evidence in this case there was such a radical change of conditions within the proposed restricted zone, after the attempt to restrict the district and before the time of the trial, as to entirely defeat the main purpose of the covenant. The covenant, therefore, should no longer be binding or enforced. [Rombauer v. Compton Heights Christian Church, 328 Mo. 1, 40 S. W. (2d) 1. c. 552, 553; 32 C. J. 212, sec. 328, also page 213, sec. 331 and cases cited; Koehler v. Rowland, 205 S. W. 1. c. 221.] Defendants cite Pierce v. St. Louis Union Trust Co., 278 S. W. 398, as authority for their position. That case, however, is inapplicable to the facts in the case at bar. The basis of the opinion in the Pierce case, supra, may be gathered from a short quotation which we think is the essence of the whole case. At page 408 the court says: “But notwithstanding the assaults of commercial business upon the surrounding neighborhood, the evidence as a whole rather tends to show that Vandeventer Place itself has successfully withstood the advance of the commercial army, and has so far maintained its exclusive character as a single family residential district of the highest class.” The Pierce case and the Rombauer case supra, recognize the rule that when the purpose and the object of the restriction have
What we have said renders it unnecessary to consider the other ground upon which the lower court rendered its decree in plaintiffs’ favor. Our finding, on the merits, is in accord with the learned chancellor who tried the case in the circuit court. It is, therefore, immaterial whether the lower court was right or wrong in holding that there had been a material alteration of the instrument or covenant after it had been signed by plaintiff Emma Pickel.
The judgment, nisi, is accordingly affirmed. Cooley and Fitzsimmons, CC., concur.
PER CURIAM:—The foregoing opinion by Westhues, C., is adopted as the opinion of the court. All of the judges concur.
On Motion for Rehearing.
PER CURIAM:—In their motion for a rehearing defendants seem to be alarmed that our opinion in this case nullifies other restrictive zones not here in controversy. We affirmed the judgment of the circuit court. That judgment is binding only on those parties that were named as plaintiffs and defendants.
In our opinion we found that the entire district and neighborhood mentioned is now completely settled by negroes. The defendants challenge that statement as being incorrect and not supported by the testimony. In the first part of the opinion, when speaking of the neighborhood, we made reference to “both sides of Cook and Finney avenues in the two blocks between Vandeventer and Grand avenues.” What the writer intended to say was between Vandeventer and Spring Avenue and not Grand Avenue. Krum Avenue is immediately east of Vandeventer and Spring is immediately east
We have carefully considered the motion for rehearing. Our conclusion is that the judgment of the circuit court on the merits of the case was correct.
The motion for rehearing is therefore overruled. All concur.