Perkins v. HadsellPerkins v. Hadsell
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Lawrence
delivered the opinion of the Court:
In 1860, plaintiff in error gave the following instrument to Robert M. Stout:
“ These presents witness between William Perkins, of Cincinnati, O., and Robert M. Stout of Clarksburg, Indiana, that the said Perkins now extends to the said Stout the privilege of selecting from his lands in Mason county, Illinois, of the following nos: An 80 acre lot for a home for himself and family, W. of S. W. -£, 24; W. £, H. W. i, 25; H. E. ¿ of 26 ; S. E. 1, 15 ; T. 1, H. R., 6 W.
“ Should he, the said Stout, take either one of the 80’s first described, he is to pay to the said Perkins seven hundred and twenty dollars for the same within the period of ten years, with 6 per cent, interest. Should he prefer taking his eighty out of one of the quarters last described, he is to have the same for six hundred and eighty-five dollars, with 10 per cent, interest till paid, he paying the annual tax on the eightyselected, with the privilege of taking none, no eighty, when this article is to be of no force; but if the said Stout make his selection as aforesaid, within six months, and go on to improve the same and pay for it according to this article, then said Perkins is to make out and deliver to him a good deed for the eighty selected. This 7th day of September, 1860.
“WM. PEEKIN’ S.
“ It is understood that Mr. Stout is to be charged no rent, should he leave the 80 after tilling it for a time.
“ W. PERKIN‘S,
“ROB’T M. STOUT.”
The present bill was filed against Perkins by Barbary Hadsell, as assignee of Stout, for a specific performance, and as no answer was filed, the only question is, whether the bill shows upon its face a case justifying the decree for a conveyance. The bill alleges that Stout, on the 1st of March, 1860, with the consent of Perkins, made his selection of an eighty acre tract at $720, which was then its full value; that he broke the land and made valuable improvements thereon; that in September, 1861, for a valuable consideration, he assigned the contract to one Case, who afterwards assigned to defendant in error, and that she has since been in possession, made valuable improvements, and put said land in a high state of cultivation. The bill further avers, that Stout, Case, and defendant in error have paid all the taxes on said land, and that defendant in error on the 29th of June, 1867, tendered to plaintiff in error the full amount due on said land, to wit: $1,016. A default was taken against the plaintiff in error, and the court, on the allegations of the bill, rendered a decree for a conveyance.
It is insisted, by the plaintiff in error, that the instrument above set forth, is not binding on him, for want of mutuality, or, in other words, that there is no consideration. There is no doubt but that Perkins, at any time before Stout accepted his proposition by selecting, entering upon and commencing to improve the land, might have withdrawn his offer. Up to
The case of Lowenson v. Butler, 1 Sch. and Lef. 15, cited by plaintiff in error, has often been overruled, as in the cases cited in 2 Pars, on Con. 290, and it was held by this court, in Farwell v. Lowther, 18 Ill. 255, and Esmay v. Gorton, ib. 483, that it was sufficient under the statute of frauds, if the writing is.signed by the party to be charged. It is true there must be an acceptance, and in this case it was manifested by the performance of all the conditions annexed to the promise.
The plaintiff in error also cites Boucher v. Van Buskirk, 2 A. K. Marsh. 345. That case was in some respects like the present, so far as concerns the provisions of the written instrument executed by Yan Buslcirk, but the court, after stating that the instrument itself created no obligation on the part of Boucher to buy the land, add, that reliance was placed upon his improvements, but that there was no evidence in the cause showing that any had been made. It seems to be implied, in what the court say, that if Boucher had made improvements which were not compensated by the use of the land, he would have been entitled to a conveyance. There is also one important difference between that case and the present, in regard to the instrument. There, Yan Buslcirk had given a lease for five years, and had given permission to Boucher, the lessee, to build a house. But Boucher was not bound by the lease, either to pay rent or taxes, or even to build the house. He simply had permission to build. In this case Stout, by the agreement, was to pay the taxes and improve the land, in case he accepted Perkins’ proposition. In that case the instrument was, in form, a lease, for which it did not appear that any consideration had been paid, even by making improvements. In this case,
The other case, Giger v. Green, 4 Gill, 472, cited by plaintiff in error, we do not consider applicable. One person-JáicL granted to another the right of digging ore on his laudato twenty-five cents per ton, the license not running for anyplr-ticular time, and the case simply holds the privilege Avis!’ revocable at pleasure. ’ - ■
It is also urged by plaintiff in error, that even if ‘Stout could enforce this contract, still, it was not assignable. On that point it is only necessary to say, that the instrument contains nothing that can be construed as forbidding an assignment, and if Stout acquired under it any right of property, then there is no reason why equity should not equally protect his assignee. The instrument may not have been assignable before Stout acquired a right of property under it by the expenditure of money in improvements, but it was assignable in equity after that time.
Decree affirmed.
Notes
See Hanen & White v. Wakefield, 39 Ill. 518.