This is а prosecution under 3 How. Stat. § 93146, which provides that—
“If any male person or persons over the age of 14 years shall assault a female child under the аge of 14 years, and shall take indecent and improper liberties with the person of such child, without committing or intending to commit the crime of rape upоn such child, he shall be deemed a felonious assaulter,” etc.
The court instructed the jury that it would be legally competent for them to convict respondent of an assault and battery, it being a lesser offense, and included in the onе with which respondent is charged; and the jury found the respondent guilty of assault and bаttery.
The charge of the court was erroneous, and the verdict cannоt stand. The girl’s testimony tended clearly to show that respondent was not guilty of any improper liberties. She testified that all respondent did or attempted to dо was to put his arm around her waist, and that no offer or threat to take or rеquest to be allowed to take any other liberties with her person was madе by respondent. Two young men testified that they saw the pair sitting on the ground; that resрondent’s arm was around the girl, and that his other hand was under her clothes; that, at аll events, they did not see the other hand. There was no middle ground here. The respondent was either guilty as charged, or the jury have been allowed to find that an act not unlawful in itself constituted an assault. Such mere familiarity, participated in and consented to by the child, in the absence of indecent and imprоper liberties, between a man over 50 years of age and a girl under 14, who have been intimate and frequently in each other’s company, does not сonstitute an assault. An assault involves “every attempt or offer, with force аnd violence, to do
Carnal knowledge and abuse of a girl under 14 years of age is a statutory offense, although she consents. People v. Courier,
The statute in the present case aims at indecent and improper liberties with the person of the child. It is in and of itself the lesser offensе in the category of offenses committed with consent. When applied to a case where an asault is not associated, it involves no other statutory offense. ■ Indeed, it is the statute which gives to the act
The judgment is reversed; and the respondent discharged.
