People v. SavantPeople v. Savant
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Farmer
delivered the opinion of the court:
John Savant, plaintiff in error, (hereafter called defendant,) was convicted in the circuit court of Franklin county of the murder of Fritz Heick and sentenced to be hanged. He has sued out this writ of error to review the judgment.
It is urged that the coux‘t erred in adxnitting testimony for the prosecution; in giving instructions for the People; in failing to give an instruction defining the crime of manslaughter ; in allowing the written dying declaration of deceased to be taken by the jury when they retired to consider their verdict; and that the jury was guilty of misconduct px-ejudicial to defendant.
It is not denied that defendant shot and killed Fritz Heick on Sunday morning, January 2, 1921, but it was claimed by defendant on the trial of the case that the killing was done in self-defense. Defendant’s brother, Albert Savant, is a merchant residing and doing business in the village of Valiex’, in Franklin county. He sold groceries and other merchandise. Pie owned the building he did business in, which faced the street on the south. The first floor was divided north and south into two rooms. The east room was occupied as a pool-rooxn and the west room as a store. The west half of the second story of the building was. divided into five or six rooms and was occupied by Albert and his faxnily as their residence. The kitchen was the north room, next south of it was the sitting room, and then three bed-rooms. The east part of the second floor was a miner’s hall. There was a passageway or hall between the living rooxns and the xniner’s hall, with doors opening from it into the living rooms. The staix-way leading to the living rooms was inside the rear of the building and led up into
Defendant testified on the trial, among other things, that he saw his wife “flirting with this boy” within twenty or thirty minutes after they arrived at his brother’s house the evening of December 31; that some time during the_ day on Saturday he was trying to rent a house from a man
The only corroboration of defendant’s testimony of misconduct between his wife and deceased was the testimony of Mrs. Albert Savant that while defendant’s wife was sitting in a rocking chair in the sitting room and deceased was playing cards in the same room with other parties the evening of December 31 she saw them nod at each other. The same witness testified she saw defendant leave the house just before the shooting and heard three or four shots, and immediately after the shooting she heard deceased crying and at once went to the warehouse; that deceased was lying on a sack of feed; that witness’ husband was there also and one or two others; that deceased said, “John shot me,” and the witness asked him what he shot him for; that deceased replied, “John said, you fooled me long enough;” that witness went back up-stairs to defendant’s bed-room; that his wife was lying on the bed, crying; that witness said, “John, what for you done that?” and he said, “They kidded me long enough.”
Charles LePere, who was one of the party at Albert Savant’s house the night of the arrival of defendant and his family, testified that he was at Savant’s store Sunday morning and started out to where deceased was; that before he reached there he heard from three to seven shots; that he saw Albert Savant, his wife and Dees go into the warehouse and he followed them; that Albert asked deceased what was the matter, and he said, “John shot me;” that when asked why he had done it he replied, “I don’t know.”
David Dees, who went to the warehouse immediately after hearing the shots, testified that deceased said, “John shot me,” and he thought he said without any cause.
Deceased was taken from Valier to a hospital at Christopher, where he was operated on, and died during the operation or a few minutes afterward.
John Shadowen, chief of police of Christopher, testified he saw deceased in the hospital before the operation and asked him how he was feeling; that deceased replied, “I feel awful bad; he has killed me;” that witness told him to brace up, maybe he would be all right, and deceased said, “No, he shot me four times; he killed me and did not give me a chance to say anything;” that he said John Savant shot him; that they had been good friends and never had any trouble; that they had no argument or words, and described how the shooting occurred in substantially the same language testified to by witness Paga. Shadowen wrote down the statement and had it typewritten. It was read over to deceased and signed by him and witnessed by Shadowen, Harry Owens and Albert Paga. The court admitted the statement as a dying declaration, which is as follows:
“I didn’t have no trouble at all. I went in the warehouse to get some corn. He [John Savant] followed me in. He told me, ‘You have fooled me long enough,’ and took
It is contended by counsel for defendant that the statements made by deceased in the warehouse immediately after the shooting were incompetent, and the testimony as to the dying declaration did not authorize the admission of the declaration in evidence. As to the statements of deceased in the warehouse immediately after the shooting, even if they were not competent as res gestee, as contended, their admission in evidence, in view of the conceded fact that defendant did shoot deceased, would not warrant a reversal of the judgment.
It is argued by defendant that the declaration made by the deceased in the hospital’ at Christopher was not made under the firm belief and moral conviction that death was impending and certain to follow almost immediately, without opportunity for repentance. The proof does not warrant that contention. It shows deceased was under the firm belief and conviction that his death was imminent and he had no hope of escaping the impending danger. To our minds it meets all the requirements necessary tp make the statement a dying declaration and competent testimony. North v. People, 139 Ill. 81; Dunn v. People, 172 id. 582.
There were axes and other tools in the warehouse where the shooting occurred, but no witness except Albert Savant, brother of defendant, testified‘to seeing any weapon near deceased when he was lying in the warehouse. Albert testified he saw a hatchet about fourteen or fifteen inches from deceased. Other witnesses who were in the warehouse immediately after the shooting testified they did not see a hatchet or any other instrument or weapon near him, and we are of opinion the jury were warranted to conclude from the evidence that the shooting was wholly unprovoked and unnecessary and was deliberate murder. The charge of alleged misconduct of deceased and defendant’s wife is too flimsy and unreasonable to justify serious consideration as any
Complaint is made of five instructions given on behalf of the People. Probably there are some slight inaccuracies in some of them, and some of them, perhaps, did not state all of the law on the question, but we are clear that there was not such error in them as to have prejudiced the rights of defendant or to require detailed discussion in this opinion. Twenty instructions were given on behalf of the People and twenty-nine on behalf of the defendant. Considered together they fairly state the law applicable to the theory of both the prosecution and defense, and defendant was not prejudiced by the giving of instructions.
No instruction was asked by either party or given by the court defining manslaughter, and it is contended this was error. The same contention was made in People v. Lucas, 244 Ill. 603, which was a murder case. This court said: “No such instructions having been asked by plaintiff in error, the court had a right to assume that plaintiff in error preferred to submit the case to the jury in such way that the jury would be compelled to find the defendants guilty of murder or not guilty. It was the right of plaintiff in error to submit that question to the jury and require the jury to pass on the question of his guilt or innocence of the crime of murder, and it was not the duty of the court to submit issues and questions to the jury which the parties by their action said they did not desire passed upon.” The same, in principle, is Dunn v. People, 109 Ill. 635.
It is further contended the jury were guilty of such misconduct as that the judgment should be reversed. In support of the motion for a new trial defendant filed several affidavits, one by Ben Westbrook that he was the owner of the restaurant where the jurors took their meals during the trial, and while at their meals some of the time they were attended by only one officer; that they mingled with other persons
The court permitted the jury to take vyith them to the jury room, when they retired to consider their verdict, the written statement offered in evidence as the dying declaration of the deceased, and this it is claimed was error sufficient to reverse the judgment. A written dying declaration admitted in evidence in Dunn v. People, 172 Ill. 582, was allowed to be taken by the jury when they retired to consider their verdict. Parts of the written statement were held incompetent by the trial court, who placed brackets around the incompetent parts and orally instructed the jury not to consider those parts of the dying declaration. Permitting the statement to be taken by the jury was held to be erroneous under the circumstances presented in that case, but there were also other serious errors on the trial pointed out in the opinion of this court. In Cooke v. People, 231 Ill. 9, a bill of particulars filed by the People was read to the jury by the State’s attorney and permitted to be taken by them
On account of the consequences to defendant we have given the record the best consideration we are capable of, and are firmly convinced that the jury were fully warranted in finding that the killing was murder, unattended by any mitigating circumstances, and the judgment is affirmed.
The clerk of this court is directed to enter judgment and an order fixing the period between nine o’clock in the forenoon and four o’clock in the afternoon of February 24, 1922, as the time when the original sentence of death entered in the circuit court of Franklin county shall be executed. A certified copy of such order shall be furnished by the clerk of this court to the sheriff of Franklin county.
Judgment affirmed.