People v. SantowPeople v. Santow
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Carter
delivered the opinion of the court:
Plaintiffs in error, Jake Santow and M. Weinberg, were indicted, tried and found guilty in the circuit court of Stephenson county of attempting to obtain money by means of the confidence game and were sentenced to the penitentiary. This writ of error was then sued out.
Joe Warsawsky operated a junk business in Freeport, Illinois, under the name Freeport Iron and Metal Company, not incorporated. October 4, 1918, plaintiffs in error came
The evidence shows that this identical car of rags was originally billed from Chicago by the Chicago Metal Refining Company to B. Goodman at Marengo and was receipted for by Santow under the name of J. Steinberg; that he also paid the freight and demurrage on the car; that Santow was the son of one of the owners interested in the original consignor company. A fictitious name was given by plaintiffs in error in receipting for the car, and the same fictitious name was given at the time the rags were sold to Warsawsky. The testimony shows that the plaintiff in error Weinberg at the time of the sale stated to Warsawsky that the other plaintiff in error was his son, and that the reason he was selling everything out was that his boy would soon be called to war,—expected to be called in two or three weeks,—and that he had to get rid of everything before the son went, and he gave his name to Warsawsky as M. Steinberg. The check made by Warsawsky at the time the bill of lading was presented was made to M. Steinberg and- likewise the draft that was given by the Stephenson County Bank, and the evidence shows without dispute that the plaintiffs in error gave these samé names to other persons with whom they were communicating at or about the time of this transaction, while their names, as shown by the record, are M. Weinberg and Jake Santow, and there is nothing in the record to show that the two plaintiffs in error are in any way related.
Counsel argues that the evidence is entirely consistent with the theory that the transaction was a mere business one, in which both parties were dealing at arm’s length on an equal footing; that at the most the only thing the evidence proves is that plaintiffs in error misrepresented their ■goods and that the evidence fails utterly to show that Warsawsky reposed any confidence in plaintiffs in error or that either party
This conclusion makes it unnecessary to consider or decide certain other questions raised in the case. We deem it proper, however, to state that under the reasoning of this court
The circuit court erred in not setting aside the verdict for want of sufficient evidence. The judgment of that court is therefore reversed.
Judgment reversed.