People v. RogersPeople v. Rogers
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Kane
Appeals (1) from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Lamont, J.), rendered November 21, 2000 in Albany County, upon a verdict convicting defendant of the crimes of rape in the first degree and sodomy in the first degree, and (2) by permission, from an order of said court (McNamara, J.), entered May 12, 2003 in Albany County, which denied defendant’s motion pursuant to
In April 1999, defendant was arraigned on a two-count indictment charging him with crimes related to a sexual assault. A superceding indictment charged defendant with two counts each of rape and sodomy, by force or while the victim was incapable of consent by virtue of being physically helpless. Prior to the September 2000 trial, defendant twice moved to dismiss the indictment on speedy trial grounds, each time unsuccessfully. The jury found defendant guilty of rape and sodomy while the victim was incapable of consent, but acquitted on the forcible rape and sodomy charges. Supreme Court sentenced defendant to consecutive sentences of 25 years in prison for each count. Defendant filed a
Defendant was not denied his right to a speedy trial (see US Const 6th, 14th Amends;
In evaluating an alleged
Supreme Court properly denied defendant’s
A report giving the results of testing on the victim’s blood was improperly admitted as a business record. Unlike People v Cratsley (86 NY2d 81, 90 [1995]), where an IQ report was generated by a developmental disabilities organization’s outside consultant to classify an individual for placement or treatment, thus supplying “indicia of reliability characteristic of a business record” (id. at 91; see Rodriguez v Triborough Bridge & Tunnel Auth., 276 AD2d 769, 770 [2000], appeal dismissed 96 NY2d 814 [2001]), the report here was requested by and prepared for law enforcement for the purpose of prosecution. Although the report was generated by a private lab that conducted the tests and such tests by outside labs are regularly relied upon by the State Police because they do not perform such testing themselves, papers or reports from other entities do not qualify as business records merely because they are regularly filed with the State Police’s records (see People v Cratsley, supra at 90). Documents prepared for litigation lack the indicia of reliability necessary to invoke the business records exception to the hearsay rule.
Defendant’s 6th Amendment right to cross-examine witnesses was violated by admission of the blood test report. Defendant had the right to cross-examine witnesses regarding the authenticity of the sample for foundation purposes. He also had the right, pursuant to the Confrontation Clause, to cross-examine regarding the testing methodology (see US Const 6th Amend; Crawford v Washington, — US —, 124 S Ct 1354 [2004]). Because the test was initiated by the prosecution and generated by the desire to discover evidence against defendant, the results were testimonial (see Crawford v Washington, supra). The test result established the victim’s blood alcohol content at the time the blood was drawn and was the basis of expert testimony extrapolating her blood alcohol content at the time of the al
Based on our remittal of this matter, we will briefly address defendant’s other contentions which may arise again in further proceedings. A sexual assault nurse examiner conducted a physical examination of the victim. Supreme Court did not abuse its discretion in permitting this witness’s testimony, based on her training and experience, that the victim’s injuries were consistent with a forcible sexual encounter and not consistent with consensual sex (see People v Morehouse, 5 AD3d 925, 928-929 [2004]; People v Munroe, 307 AD2d 588, 591 [2003], lv denied 100 NY2d 644 [2003]). The court properly limited defense counsel’s cross-examination of the nurse examiner because he failed to make a valid offer of proof (see People v White, 261 AD2d 653, 656 [1999], lv denied 93 NY2d 1029 [1999]); it also permitted the defense to present related evidence later in the trial when a proper basis was established.
The victim’s hospital records were properly admitted into evidence. Although statements made by the victim to medical personnel were hearsay, such statements are admissible under the business records exception {see
The bottle containing Invigorate was properly admitted into evidence. While Invigorate was a legal, over-the-counter product at the time, a chemist and toxicologist established that Invigorate contains base ingredients similar to the date-rape drug GHB and the body can convert Invigorate to GHB. Testimony established that the victim had very little recollection of the night after having a drink with defendant, she did not act as she normally did when intoxicated, she was barely able to walk and mostly incoherent, she was still groggy late the next morning, amnesiac experiences under these situations are
Cardona, P.J., Mercure and Rose, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is reversed, on the law, and matter remitted to the Supreme Court for a new trial. Ordered that the order is affirmed.
Notes
Two motions were pending for a combined period in excess of 9V2 months prior to determination. While these periods were lengthy, one set of defendant’s motion papers with exhibits was 485 pages and contained hundreds of case citations.