People v. ProsserPeople v. Prosser
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Burnett
Defendant was convicted of “making, drawing, uttering and delivering a check for the payment of money on a bank, without having sufficient funds in or *456 credit thereat with intent to defraud,” and he has appealed from the judgment. The only defense was insanity, and it is not disputed that the evidence upon that issue is abundantly sufficient to support the implied finding of the jury against appellant, but it is contended that the trial court committed prejudicial error in admitting in evidence a certain purported discharge from the hospital for the insane at Stockton and in refusing to give certain proposed instructions in reference to the invalidity of such discharge and the effect of defendant’s commitment to the asylum. The defendant was adjudged insane upon two different occasions. The first time was in 1915, when he was committed by the superior court of Alameda County to Agnews, whence he escaped after six or seven months. On September 24, 1919, he wás again examined and committed to Agnews by the superior court “of San Francisco, and after escaping and being recaptured he was transferred to the Stockton asylum on March 16, 1920. On June 6th, following, he was paroled and leave of absence granted, the parole providing that he “must be returned every thirty days for renewal.” The parole was regularly extended to September 6th, but before this date he broke his parole, of which the police and asylum authorities were notified. On February 16, 1921, he was discharged from the hospital as “not insane.” Defendant had not been there nor had he been seen by the physicians since June 6, 1920, and the last complete examination that they made of him was on March 20, 1920. On March 24, 1921, the check was passed, upon which the indictment was based.
The only other rejected instruction worthy of notice was based upon the theory that if the defendant had been committed as insane to the hospital at Agnews and was afterward transferred to the one at Stockton and then paroled and afterward escaped, and that the only evidence of his discharge was one purporting to have been made after such escape and while he was not in the custody “of the said state hospital or any state hospital for some time previous,
*460
and if there is no evidence of any adjudication by a superior court of the state of California that defendant is sane, then you must find at the time that defendant was alleged to have defrauded George Buthenuth, as alleged in the indictment herein, that he was insane.” But it is manifest that this instruction is also based upon the erroneous theory that the commitment to the hospital was conclusive evidence that appellant was insane at the time and that his insanity continued until he was regularly discharged by the hospital or adjudicated to be sane.
Appellant’s counsel deserves commendation for the zeal and ability with which, without compensation, he has represented his client, but we are satisfied that justice has been done in the case and that no prejudicial error has been shown.
The judgment is affirmed.
Hart, J., and Finch, P. J., concurred.