People v. PfeifferPeople v. Pfeiffer
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Vickers
Lead Opinion
delivered the opinion of the court:
John Pfeiffer, plaintiff in error, was indicted, tried and convicted in the criminal court of Cook county of forgery. He has sued out a writ of error from this court to obtain a review of the record.
The only error insisted upon in this court is, that, conceding all of the facts testified to by the witnesses for the People, they do not make a case of forgery.
The undisputed facts established by the evidence are as follows: On the 16th of November, 1901, the premises known as 882 West Monroe street, in the city of Chicago, were owned in fee simple by Ernest G. Troy, Harry L. Troy, and their mother, Emeline Troy. Emeline Troy afterwards quit-claimed her interest in the property to the two sons. At the time referred to there was an encumbrance upon the property for $1000, held by Anna M. Blodgett.
In the case of Goodwin v. People, 228 Ill. 154, we had occasion to quote a number of common law definitions of the offense of forgery, and from these authorities it was held that in order to constitute forgery the three following elements must exist: (1) There must be a false writing or alteration of an instrument; (2) the instruments as made must be apparently capable of defrauding; (3) there must be an intent to defraud. The definition of forgery found in paragraph 105 of our Criminal Code is, in substance, the common law definition extended to take in some instruments which were not known to the common law. There is under our statute no distinction between making, altering or counterfeiting an instrument with intent to prejudice, and in uttering, publishing and passing as true and genuine any such forged instrument with an intent to damage or defraud, knowing the same to be false, altered, forged or counterfeited. Every person who is guilty either of making and forging or uttering and passing or attempting to
It is conceded on behalf of the State that plaintiff in error is not guilty of falsely making and forging the notes in question, but it is strenuously contended that the delivery of the notes to the Chicago Title and Trust Company constituted an uttering and passing of such notes, and therefore a forgery under our statute if such notes were, in fact, forgeries and known to be such by plaintiff in error. It is contended by the defendants in error that these notes were, in fact, false; that they purported on their face to have been made on the 16th of November, 1901, when, in fact, they were made in June, 1903, and that the uttering and passing of such notes by plaintiff in error, knowing that the notes were not what they purported to be, constitute the offense of forgery, and some authorities, mainly from English courts and writers, are cited which seem to support that view. The case of Regina v. Ritson, 1 L. R. C. C. 200, is the strongest of these authorities in support of the State’s contention. The facts in that case are as follows: “In January, 1868, R., the owner, borrowed from G. £730, giving him an equitable mortgage and deposit of title deeds. In May of the same year R. went into bankruptcy. G. came into possession of the land by deed from R. and the trustee in bankruptcy. Subsequently the son of R. commenced an action of- trespass against G., he holding a deed from R. which purported to be executed in March, two months prior to the deed to G. The deed had, in fact, been executed after the execution of the deed to G.” On behalf of the prisoner it was contended that the deed could not be a forgery because it was really executed by the parties by whom it purported to be made. On behalf of the prosecution it was contended that it was a forgery because it was a false deed fraudulently made. The case was argued before the judges en banc, and the separate opinion of each judge holds it to be forgery. The following quotation from the
This case, and others in line with it, apparently make no distinction between an instrument which is forged and counterfeited and the genuine instrument which the maker is induced to execute through the fraud and misrepresentation of another. All of the American and some of the later English cases on the subject, so far as we are advised, with the single exception of State v. Shurtleff, 18 Me. 368, agree that it is not forgery to procure the signing of an instrument by the party purporting to be bound by it by fraudulent representations, or by falsely reading it in his hearing, where he is illiterate. (Regina v. Collins, 2 Mood. & R. 461; Regina v. Chadwick, id. 545; Hill v. State, 1 Yerg. 75; Commonwealth v. Sankey, 22 Pa. St. 390.) In the case last above cited the defendant wrote a note, payable to himself, for $141, and got an illiterate man to sign it by falsely and fraudulently pretending that it was for $41, only. In disposing of this case, Black, Chief Justice, speaking for the court, said: “The act was a forgery according to all the text writers on criminal law, from Coke to Wharton. But their doctrine is not sustained by the ancient English cases and is opposed by the modern ones. Only
The case of Putnam v. Sullivan, 4 Mass. 45, supports the Pennsylvania case above quoted from, as does also
The judgment of the criminal court of Cook county is reversed. T , ,
T , Judgment reversed.
Dissenting Opinion
dissenting:
The crime of forgery may be committed by passing as true and genuine, with intent to defraud, an instrument in writing which is known to the person passing the same not to be what it purports upon its face to be. The crime of forgery was committed in this case by passing the duplicate notes as the original notes with intent to defraud, and it cannot be said the crime of forgery was not committed because the duplicate notes were signed by the Troys. It was not the causing of the duplicate notes to be made, but passing them as the originals with intent to defraud, which constituted the crime of forgery. Gregory v. State, 26 Ohio St. 510; Commonwealth v. Foster, 114 Mass. 320; State v. Shurtleff, 18 Me. 368; Regina v. Ritson, 1 L. R. C. C. 200; Luttrell v State, 85 Tenn. 323; State v. Farwell, 82 Iowa, 556; Edwards v. State, 108 S. W. Rep. 673.