People v. ParkerPeople v. Parker
- Reporters:
- , ,
— Appeal by defendant from a judgment of the Supreme Court, Kings County (Spodek, J.), rendered September 16, 1981, convicting him of murder in the second degree, robbery in the first degree and criminal possession of a weapon in the second degree, upon a jury verdict, and imposing sentence. Judgment modified, on the law, by reversing defendant’s convictions of murder in the second degree and robbery in the first degree, and the sentences rendered thereon, and those counts of the indictment are dismissed. As so modified, judgment affirmed. The defendant was indicted for, inter alia, intentional murder, felony murder, and robbery as a result of an incident occurring at about 1:00 a.m. on August 27,1980 at a park located at Kingston *1064and Atlantic Avenues in Brooklyn. That evening, Brian Calder, Calvin Calder, Tyrone Hampton, Kenny Brown, Anthony Lee and a few other youths were playing basketball at the park. During the course of one of the games, an argument ensued between Anthony and Brian. When Brian walked away from Anthony, the latter followed him and called him names. Whereupon, Brian slapped Anthony in the face. Anthony then ran from the park, indicating that he was going to get his gun. After Anthony left the park, Brian also left, but in the opposite direction. He did not return to the park that night, although Calvin, Tyrone and Kenny stayed on. A few minutes later, Calvin also left the park. As he was leaving, he saw Anthony, Anthony’s brother Scott, and defendant. Calvin heard defendant say “Is that him?” The three youths looked at Calvin, but then proceeded into the park. When Anthony got inside the park, he asked Kenny where Brian was. When he learned that Brian had gone home already, Anthony said that he was going to “take it out” on Kenny and Tyrone. Whereupon Anthony started to punch Tyrone and Kenny. The defendant and Scott joined in the fight. During the fight, defendant took a .25 caliber pistol out of his pocket and smacked Kenny in the head with the side of the gun’s barrel. The blow did not leave any mark on Kenny’s face. Then Kenny fled from the park. Meanwhile, Tyrone was still in the park, sitting on the ground. People’s witness Michael Young, who had come into the park just prior to the fight, testified that he observed Anthony take Tyrone’s sneakers off and throw them across nearby train tracks. Kenny Brown, however, testified that Anthony and Scott each took off one of Tyrone’s sneakers. Scott gave the sneaker he had taken off to Anthony. He observed Anthony take the sneakers and run with them. According to Michael Young, just before Anthony removed Tyrone’s sneakers, he remarked “[ylou’re going home barefooted tonight”. Defendant who had been standing nearby holding the gun to Tyrone’s head then said to Tyrone: “Do you see this man, do you see this, you tell your home boys that I’m not playing”. Young observed defendant hit Tyrone with the barrel of the gun, at which point, a shot went off, hitting Tyrone in the temple. On cross-examination, Young testified: “I know he didn’t have his hand on the trigger.” At the trial, the jury acquitted the defendant of the count of the indictment charging him with intentional murder but found him guilty of felony murder (see