People v. NoblePeople v. Noble
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Lesinski
Defendant appeals his conviction for escape from prison contrary to
Defendant’s first allegation of error is that he was not arrested and arraigned promptly after being captured and returned to prison. After formal charges were brought, he was promptly arraigned, so there is no question of a violation of
*302
Defendant’s second contention is that it was error to deny his motion for mistrial after the arresting officer testified that he placed defendant under arrest for “strong-armed robbery”. The trial judge :prbpe‘rly warned the jury to disregard this reference to another crime not relevant to the escape. Defendant argues that this warning by the judge merely “reemphasized” the error. To follow this liné’ of- reasoning, there would have to be a mistrial every time a witness misspoke, since no’ error could ever be cured by instructions. Such is obviously not the law. An unresponsive answer by a witness can generally be ‘cured by proper instructions. People v. Kelsey (1942), 303 Mich 715.
’ Deféndant next maintains that his record - of conviction was not properly introduced in evidence as a “business record”, so that the prosecution failed to prove that he was properly confined at the time of the ‘escape: However, it is not necessary to introduce the certificate of confinement as a business record, since
Finally, defendant protests that he only fled the prison work camp in desperation to avoid homosexual attacks by other prisoners. The problem of homosexuality in the prisons is serious and perplexing, and never more so than in a case such as this where such activity is forced upon a young man against his will. However, the answer to the problem is not the judicial sanctioning of escapes. While we have no reason to doubt the sincerity of this defendant, it is easy to visualize a rash of escapes, all rationalized by unverifiable tales of sexual assault. The solution must rather come from some kind of penological reform.
Two legal theories are offered to support defendant’s claim that his departure from the prison work camp should not be punished as an escape. First, he argues that he did not have the specific intent to escape. A reading of the escape statute,
Affirmed.
All concurred.
Notes
The Court is aware of People v. Hernandez (1968), 15 Mich App 141, which by a’ decision of 2 to 1 considers a delay in arrest a violation of due process. This panel does not agree with the holding of that case and will not follow it until the ruling of that case is determined feontrolling in similni- cases by the Michigan Supreme Court.
“Any person, being imprisoned in a prison of this state for any term, who * * * shall leave said prison without being discharged from said prison by due process of law, * * * glxall be guilty of a felony.”