People v. ManessPeople v. Maness
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Bilandic
Lead Opinion
delivered the opinion of the court:
This case involves the constitutionality of section 5.1 of the Wrongs to Children Act (
STATUTE
“A. A parent or step-parent who knowingly allows or permits an act of
B. Any person convicted of permitting the sexual abuse of a child shall be guilty of a Class A misdemeanor.”
Relevant to the facts of this case is the underlying provision of the criminal sexual abuse statute, section 12 — 15 of the Criminal Code of 1961, which provides that “[t]he accused commits criminal sexual abuse if he or she commits an act of sexual penetration or sexual conduct with a victim who was at least 13 years of age but under 17 years of age and the accused was less than 5 years older than the victim.”
In light of the different versions of
FACTS
On November 19, 1997, defendant, Kathy Maness, was charged in the circuit court of Randolph County with the offense of permitting the sexual abuse of a child. See
Lynlee Otten was born on October 28, 1983. Leonard Owens was born on February 25, 1979. They started dating each other in August 1996, and began having sexual intercourse in December 1996. Between December 1996, and approximately April 1997, when the pair terminated their relationship, Lynlee and Leonard had sexual intercourse 15 to 20 times.
At some point after the sexual relationship began, Lynlee told defendant, her mother, that she and Leonard were having sexual intercourse. Defendant confronted both Lynlee and Leonard about the sexual relationship, expressed her disapproval, and discussed the implications of sexual intercourse.
Defendant obtained birth control pills for Lynlee and allowed Leonard on numerous occasions to spend the night at the family home. Defendant was aware that, on some of these occasions, Leonard slept in Lynlee’s bedroom and had sexual intercourse with Lynlee. Defendant was also aware that, during the relevant time period, Leonard was 17 years old, and Lynlee was 13 years old. The record shows that Leonard pled guilty to criminal sexual abuse in connection with the facts of this case. See
According to an investigative report from the Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS), defendant stated that she did not know what steps to take to prevent the sexual relationship between Lynlee and Leonard. Defendant further stated that Leonard “was a nice boy and was better than most of the younger boys Lynlee was hanging around with,” and that “it was safer for Lynlee to be having sex with [Leonard] at home than [with] somebody else out of the home environment.” The DCFS report discloses that defendant “feels she has some control of the daughter’s sexual activities if it occurs in the home.”
Defendant filed a motion to dismiss the charge, arguing that
Following a hearing, the circuit court, in a verbal order, granted defendant’s motion to dismiss the charge. The transcript of the order reveals that the circuit court found that
The State appealed directly to this court. Because the circuit court declared
ANALYSIS
We review de novo a circuit court’s holding with respect to the constitutionality of a statute. Russell v. Department of Natural Resources, 183 Ill. 2d 434, 441 (1998). Statutes carry a strong presumption of constitutionality, and the party challenging the constitutionality of a statute bears the burden of rebutting this presumption. Russell, 183 Ill. 2d at 441. Here, that party is defendant, who for the reasons set forth below has met this burden.
A cornerstone of our jurisprudence is that no person shall be deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law. U.S. Const., amends. V, XIV; Ill. Const. 1970, art. I, § 2. Due process of law requires that the proscriptions of a criminal statute be clearly defined. City of Chicago v. Morales, 177 Ill. 2d 440, 448 (1997), aff’d, 527 U.S. 41, 144 L. Ed. 2d 67, 119 S. Ct. 1849 (1999). To satisfy the vagueness doctrine, a criminal statute must meet two requirements. First, the statute must provide a person of ordinary intelligence a reasonable opportunity to distinguish between lawful and unlawful conduct so that he or she may act accordingly. Russell, 183 Ill. 2d at 442; Morales, 177 Ill. 2d at 449. “ ‘No one may be required at peril of life, liberty or property to speculate as to the meaning of penal statutes. All are entitled to be informed as to what the State commands or forbids.’ ” Morales, 177 Ill. 2d at 450, quoting Lanzetta v. New Jersey, 306 U.S. 451, 453, 83 L. Ed. 888, 890, 59 S. Ct. 618, 619 (1939). Thus, a statute is unconstitutionally vague “if its terms are so indefinite that ‘persons of common intelligence must necessarily guess at its meaning and differ as to its application.’ ” Fagiano v. Police Board, 98 Ill. 2d 277, 282 (1983), quoting Polyvend, Inc. v. Puckorius, 77 Ill. 2d 287, 299-300 (1979).
Second, the statute must adequately define the offense in order to prevent arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement. Russell, 183 Ill. 2d at 442; Morales, 177 Ill. 2d at 449. The statute must provide explicit standards to regulate the discretion of governmental authorities who apply the law. Russell, 183 Ill. 2d at 442; Morales, 177 Ill. 2d at 456. If the legislature fails to provide minimal guidelines to govern law enforcement, a criminal law “may permit ‘a standardless sweep [that] allows policemen, prosecutors, and juries to pursue their personal predilections.’ ” Kolender v. Lawson, 461 U.S. 352, 358, 75 L. Ed. 2d 903, 909, 103 S. Ct. 1855, 1858 (1983), quoting Smith v. Goguen, 415 U.S. 566, 575, 39 L. Ed. 2d 605, 613, 94 S. Ct. 1242, 1248 (1974).
We recognize that defendant obtained birth control pills for her daughter and allowed her daughter’s boyfriend to spend the night at the family home. Defendant was aware that at times her daughter and her daughter’s boyfriend slept together in her daughter’s bedroom and had sexual intercourse with each other. Defendant, however, stated that she did not know what steps to take to prevent the sexual relationship between her daughter and her daughter’s boyfriend, and that she felt she had more control over her daughter’s sexual activities if they occurred in the home.
Furthermore,
We note that, in reviewing whether a statute is vague, a court may also consider the legislative purpose and the evil that the statute is designed to remedy. People v. R.G., 131 Ill. 2d 328, 361 (1989). The legislative history is silent as to the purposes underlying the need for
The dissent states that the “majority has not cited any authority for the proposition that a ‘reasonableness’ standard renders a criminal statute unconstitutionally vague, and I see no basis for reaching that conclusion with respect to
The dissent further contends that there “are numerous instances in which application of the statute would be proper,” and then purports to give an example. 191 Ill. 2d at 490 (Harrison, C.J., dissenting, joined by Miller and McMorrow, JJ.). The dissent’s reasoning is flawed. The legal test for whether a statute withstands a vagueness challenge is well settled. To satisfy the vagueness doctrine, a criminal statute must provide both fair warning of the prohibited conduct and explicit guidelines for those who must apply the law. See, e.g., Morales, 177 Ill. 2d at 449.
The dissent also concludes that defendant took “no steps” to prevent the abuse. 191 Ill. 2d at 491 (Harrison, C.J., dissenting, joined by Miller and McMorrow, JJ.). The record reveals otherwise. Defendant confronted her daughter and her daughter’s boyfriend about the sexual relationship, expressed her disapproval, and discussed the implications of sexual intercourse. What the dissent really appears to be saying is that defendant did not do enough. However, neither
CONCLUSION
We hold that
Affirmed.
Dissenting Opinion
dissenting:
Whether a party has acted reasonably will necessarily depend on the facts and circumstances of each particular case. What action is reasonable under the circumstances is not always easy to assess. Experience has shown, however, that when dealing with diverse and unpredictable situations, a “reasonableness” standard is the best measure for judging human conduct. Accordingly, the “reasonable man” standard has become a fundamental part of our jurisprudence. We constantly call upon citizens and law enforcement officials to follow and apply this standard. Again, examples are easy to summon. “Reasonableness” plays a pivotal role in assessing the legality of police stops. People v. Gonzalez, 184 Ill. 2d 402, 422-24 (1998). It is integral to the law of self-defense (People v. Morgan, 187 Ill. 2d 500, 533 (1999)) and the law governing trade secrets (
The majority has not cited any authority for the proposition that a “reasonableness” standard renders a criminal statute unconstitutionally vague, and I see no basis for reaching that conclusion with respect to
Because there are valid applications for the statute and because the law does not involve first amendment rights, the determination as to whether the statute is constitutionally infirm must be made in the factual context of this particular case. Russell v. Department of Natural Resources, 183 Ill. 2d 434, 442 (1998). Maness does not have standing to argue that the statute might be vague as applied to someone else. See People v. Jihan, 127 Ill. 2d 379, 385 (1989). A defendant may be prosecuted under a statute without violating her due process rights if her conduct clearly falls within the statutory proscription even though the statute may be vague as to other conduct. People v. Anderson, 148 Ill. 2d 15, 28 (1992).
What Maness is alleged to have done in this case clearly falls within the prohibitions of
Maness’ contention that she was uncertain as to the law’s application is unpersuasive.
There is likewise no merit to Maness’ contention that the statute is invalid because it unduly infringes on a parent’s right to raise her child. Under the fourteenth amendment, parents have a “fundamental liberty interest *** in the care, custody, and management of their child[ren,]” with which the government may not interfere unduly. Santosky v. Kramer, 455 U.S. 745, 753-54, 71 L. Ed. 2d 599, 606, 102 S. Ct. 1388, 1394-95 (1982). Parental autonomy, however, is not absolute. See Lehman v. Stephens, 148 Ill. App. 3d 538, 547 (1986). In matters concerning child abuse and neglect, a parent’s rights yield to the state’s interest in protecting its children. American Federation of State, County & Municipal Employees v. Department of Central Management Services, 173 Ill. 2d 299, 319 (1996).
The right to be a parent does not encompass the right to abuse one’s child or to allow one’s child to be abused. If Maness had knowingly allowed Owens to inject her daughter with heroin and provided the couple with a place in her home where the drugs could be injected, there would be no question that Maness could be prosecuted for child endangerment (
For the foregoing reasons, the judgment of the circuit court should be reversed and the cause should be remanded for further proceedings. I therefore dissent.
JUSTICES MILLER and McMORROW join in this dissent.