People v. LootPeople v. Loot
- Reporters:
- , , , ,
- Before:
- Johnson
Opinion
.—Defendant Kendrick P. Loot appeals from the judgment following his conviction of attempted murder, assault with a firearm and shooting at an occupied motor vehicle. We affirm.
Facts and Proceedings Below *
I.-III. *
IV. It Was Misconduct for a Juror, During Trial, to Inquire About the Marital Status and “Availability” of the Prosecutor but the Misconduct Was Not Prejudicial.
On the second day of deliberations Juror No. 12 encountered Ms. Ward, a deputy public
The court held a hearing with Juror No. 12. She admitted asking Ward if Wright was married but denied asking if he was “available.” She also told the court she had not related this conversation to any of the other jurors and that it had not affected her deliberations in the case. She specifically affirmed she was basing her deliberations on the evidence and was not influenced by her questions about Wright or Ward’s answers.
The following day, defendant moved for a mistrial based on misconduct by Juror No. 12. The trial court denied the motion on the grounds there was no “serious misconduct” on the juror’s part and no evidence she was biased in favor of the prosecution.
That afternoon the jury reached its verdicts and was excused. Later in the day, when the prosecutor and defense counsel met with the court to discuss remaining matters, the prosecutor informed the court Juror No. 12 had slipped him a note giving him her name and telephone number and expressing the hope she had not embarrassed him. Defendant again moved for a mistrial and later for a new trial based on juror misconduct. The court denied both motions on the ground the contents of the note did not demonstrate defendant had been deprived of a fair and impartial jury.
When a party seeks a new trial based on juror misconduct, the trial court must determine from admissible evidence whether misconduct occurred and, if it did, whether the misconduct was prejudicial. (People v. Von Villas (1992) 11 Cal.App.4th 175, 255 [15 Cal.Rptr.2d 112].) Prejudice is presumed where there is misconduct. This presumption can be rebutted by a showing no prejudice actually occurred or by a reviewing court’s examination of the entire record to determine whether there is a reasonable probability of actual harm to the complaining party. (Id. at pp. 255-256.)
Defendant maintains Juror No. 12 was guilty of misconduct in discussing the prosecutor’s personal life during trial and in forming a bias in favor of the prosecution based on her attraction to the prosecutor.
It is misconduct for jurors to discuss “any subject connected with the trial” with nonjurors at any time. (
Clearly, a defendant has a constitutional right to trial by an impartial jury. (
Juror No. 12 admitted inquiring whether Mr. Wright was married although she denied asking if he was “available,” at least in those words. Defendant argues the juror’s interest in Wright went beyond just idle curiosity and “chit-chat” in the elevator: After
Although Juror No. 12 did commit misconduct in discussing the prosecutor’s personal life, the resulting presumption of prejudice was rebutted.
Among the factors to be considered when determining whether the presumption of prejudice has been rebutted are “the nature and seriousness of the misconduct, and the probability that actual prejudice may have ensued.”
(People
v.
Von Villas, supra,
11 Cal.App.4th at p. 256.) Juror No. 12’s encounter with Ms. Ward on the elevator was fleeting and there was no evidence she had discussed Mr. Wright’s “date-ability” with any one else. And, while her questions about Wright’s personal life were a technical violation of Penal Code
Therefore, we conclude, the trial court did not err in denying defendant’s motions for mistrial and new trial.
Disposition
The judgment is affirmed.
Woods, J., and Neal, J., concurred.
The petitions of both respondent and appellant for review by the Supreme Court were denied July 29, 1998.
Notes
See footnote, ante, page 694.