People v. LeonardPeople v. Leonard
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Cooke
An individual who has been issued a “persona non grata” letter by a State University president, that banishes the individual from that part of the university campus normally “open to the public”, may not be convicted of trespassing for entering the campus when no proof is adduced to show that the banishment order was lawful. To sustain the burden of showing the order’s lawfulness, the People must demonstrate that, given the nature and purpose of the property, the particular exercise of the power to exclude had a legitimate basis. The purpose would not be legitimate if, for example, its enforcement unduly infringed upon an independent statutory or constitutional right of the defendant to be present on the property.
Defendant was an enrolled student at the State University of New York at Binghamton (SUNY-Binghamton) from time to time over the past 10 years. On February 23, 1981, when defendant was no longer a student, the president of SUNY-Binghamton issued an order banishing him from campus by declaring him “persona non grata”. This letter informed defendant that he would be subject to arrest if he returned to the campus.
SUNY-Binghamton law enforcement personnel discovered defendant at the Campus Pub on October 23, 1981. The Pub is located in the University Union building on the SUNY-Binghamton campus. Defendant was arrested and charged by information with criminal trespass in the third degree (
A nonjury trial was held in Vestal Town Court on October 19, 1982. Prior to trial, defendant and the People stipulated that: in February, 1981, defendant received a letter from SUNY-Binghamton’s president declaring him “persona non grata”; defendant was not a student, faculty member, or employee at the school at that time; notwithstanding this warning, defendant was present on the campus in October, 1981; and “[a]t all times pertinent to this case, the State University of New York at Binghamton, the University Union building, and the Campus Pub were
This court now reverses.
A prosecution for criminal trespass in the third degree may be maintained against a person who “knowingly enters or remains unlawfully in a building or upon real property” (
At the outset, we reject defendant’s claim that SUNY-Binghamton is not generally empowered to exclude persons from the university campus. Article 129-A of the Education Law governs the regulation of college campuses and other college property used for educational purposes. Beyond a mere grant of power, it requires “[t]he trustees or other governing board of every college chartered by the regents or incorporated by special act of the legislature” to
Pursuant to this statutory directive, the Board of Trustees of the State University of New York promulgated rules intended to “prevent abuse of the rights of others and to maintain * * * public order appropriate to a college or university campus” (
There is also no merit to defendant’s argument that any order of exclusion would be unlawful, as violative of due process, absent the holding of a hearing prior to its issuance. Although the campus at SUNY-Binghamton may be open generally for the enjoyment of the public, defendant, who concededly is not a student or employee at the campus, has identified no “property” or “liberty” interest in being present on campus grounds that he could be lawfully deprived of only after being accorded a hearing (cf. Board of Curators, Univ. of Mo. v Horowitz, 435 US 78, 82-84; Board of Regents v Roth, 408 US 564, 568-572). Indeed, defendant claims only that the issuance of a “persona non grata” letter unlawfully inhibits his constitutional right to
That SUNY-Binghamton may enjoy the general right to exclude persons from its campus and that it may do so in some cases without first holding a hearing is not determinative of this appeal, however. It is a wholly different question whether the People have satisfied their burden of proving every element of the charged offense. The required proof in this case includes the component that the particular order of exclusion was lawful and, hence, that defendant’s defiance of that order, after notice, would subject him to criminal liability for trespass.
In this case, defendant and the People stipulated that the SUNY-Binghamton campus was at all times “open to the public” within the meaning of
Although, as administrators of SUNY-Bing-hamton have broad power and great flexibility in maintaining order and securing the safety of others on the school campus (see People v Meadow, 101 Misc 2d 203), that power is not absolute. The power to exclude does not sanction orders based “directly or indirectly” on “the race, creed, color, national origin, sex, or disability or marital status” of the person sought to be excluded (see
To satisfy its burden of proof with respect to the element of the crime that a “lawful order not to enter” the property issued, the People must demonstrate that the particular order of exclusion had a legitimate basis and that, considering the nature and use of the subject property, its enforcement did not unlawfully inhibit or circumscribe the defendant from engaging in constitutionally or statutorily protected conduct. When, as in this case, the subject property is publicly owned and maintained, the People may not satisfy their burden of proof on this issue by relying on a presumption that the public official authorized to maintain order on campus discharged his or her responsibility, in the particular instance, in a lawful manner (see People v Session, 34 NY2d 254, 256; People v Richetti, 302 NY 290, 298). A “mandatory” or “conclusive” presumption, which operates to require the finder of fact to hold against the defendant in the absence of some showing by the defendant to the contrary, may never be applied in a criminal case with respect to one of the elements of the crime being prosecuted. Shifting the burden of production or persuasion to the defendant under such circumstances would impermissibly relieve the People of their burden of proving every element of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt (see Sandstrom v Montana, 442 US 510, 514-524; People v Leyva, 38 NY2d 160, 165, 167; McCormick, Evidence [2d ed], § 346, p 831; see, generally, Matter of Winship, 397 US 358, 364).
In the instant case, the People offered no evidence at trial to demonstrate that the issuance of the particular “persona non grata” letter to defendant, banishing him from the SUNY-Binghamton campus, was lawful. There is no evidence in the record thát would indicate that the order to remain off the property had a legitimate purpose, ration
Accordingly, the order of the County Court should be reversed, the conviction vacated, and the information dismissed.
Judges Jasen, Wachtler, Meyer, Simons and Kaye concur; Judge Jones taking no part.Order reversed, etc.