People v. KirbyPeople v. Kirby
- Reporters:
- , ,
— Order entered February 2, 1982 in Su*849preme Court, New York County (Rothwax, J.) (112 Mise 2d 906), granting defendants’ motion and dismissing the indictment charging the defendants with murder in the second degree, attempted murder in the second degree and assault in the first degree, unanimously reversed, on the law and the facts, the motion denied, and the indictment reinstated. On January 12, 1979 a gypsy cab driver was murdered. Timothy Kirby was arrested and tried in March of 1980 on a January, 1979 indictment charging the above crimes. That trial resulted in a mistrial because the jurors could not agree upon a verdict. In July of 1980 Freddie Franklin was arrested on an unrelated charge and on October 31, 1980 a New York County Grand Jury returned a superseding indictment accusing both men of these crimes. The jurors in the first trial retired to deliberate on March 25,1980 and the following day a mistrial was declared — with the consent of the defense — because the jury was hopelessly deadlocked. With the court’s permission the attorneys questioned and learned from the jurors that they had stood 10 to 2 for conviction. A second trial of both defendants began on February 26,1981, and on March 29 another mistrial was declared, on consent of the defense, this jury also being unable to agree upon a verdict. This time the jurors were split 8 to 3 for acquittal of Franklin, and 6 to 6 in the case of Kirby. A third trial on the indictment (second for Franklin) began in October of 1981, but this, too, ended in a jury deadlock and a mistrial, on November 13,1981. The jurors on this panel stated that they had been 10 to 2 in favor of convicting both men. A month later the defendants moved in .Criminal Term, Part 50, to dismiss the indictment on the grounds that continued prosecution would subject them to double jeopardy, would constitute cruel and unusual punishment and would not be in the interests of justice. (US Const, 5th, 8th, 14th Arndts;