People v. HoltenPeople v. Holten
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Farmer
delivered the opinion of the court:
This is a suit in equity against Frank Holten and the sureties on his official bonds as city treasurer of East St. Louis and as ex-officio collector of the town of East St. Louis for a failure to turn over and account for taxes collected by Holten as such officer.
Holten was duly elected treasurer of the city of East St. Louis for the years 1910 and 1911. The town and city of East St. Louis are co-extensive and the city treasurer of said city was ex-officio collector of taxes for the town of East St. Louis. In 1912 separate suits were brought on Holten’s two official bonds,—one at law and one in equity. Both suits were brought in the name of the People of the State of Illinois by five tax-payers for the use of all tax-payers in the town of East St. Louis and the city of East St. Louis. A demurrer was sustained to the declaration in the action at law and the suit dismissed, from which judgment an appeal was prosecuted to this court, resulting in a reversal of the judgment of the circuit court. (People v. Holten, 259 Ill. 219.) Upon the re-docketing of that suit in the circuit court of St. Clair county it was transferred to chancery and consolidated with the other suit in chancery then pending in that court. Thereafter an amended bill and a second amended bill were filed in the consolidated case. The second amended bill alleged Holten, as such officer, collected the taxes for the years 1909 and 1910; that in addition to his salary and compensation as such officer in the year 1910 he deducted from the taxes collected that year two per cent, amounting to $10,296.44, and paid of that amount to the city $1989.83 but retained $8306.61; that from the taxes collected in the year 1911 he
Holten filed a separate answer to the bill; also the town of East St. Louis and the city of East St. Louis filed answers, and the other defendants joined in an answer. All of the answers were substantially the same, and denied the right of the tax-payers mentioned in the bill to maintain and prosecute the suit, and denied that Holten failed to discharge his duties as collector to the injury of the tax-payers, the town of East St. Louis and the city of East St. Louis. The answers denied that the settlement and compromise of the claims against Holten as collector, and the judgments entered by agreement upon his bonds, were fraudulent or the result of a plan to divert arid dispose of money due or authorized to be recovered against Holten and his sureties.
It appears that for a number of years previous treasurers and collectors had charged and retained two per cent commissions on taxes collected in addition to their salary and compensation - fixed. The bonds had been signed by bankers and others, and the bringing of the suits against Holten on his bonds attracted attention and caused comment. Henry D. Sexton, president of one of the banks of East St. Louis and who had signed the bonds of a number of other collectors besides Holten, called the then mayor’s attention to the matter and suggested the bringing of suits
After replications filed the cause was referred to a special master to take and report the testimony, together with his conclusions of law and fact. The master found Holten had collected and retained from a two per cent commission on the taxes received, in addition to his salary and compensation, the sums of money alleged in the second amended bill. The master further reported that the proof did not sustain the charge that-the judgments by agreement rendered on the Holten bonds for $925 and $975, respectively, were the result of a fraudulent scheme of the parties to that agreement, and that there was no fraud and collusion between said parties for the bringing and settling of the twenty-four suits. The master further reported that the tax-payers mentioned in the bill of complaint were not aggrieved persons of the
Two principal questions are presented for determination: (1) Were the tax-payers named in the bill authorized to bring and prosecute the suit; and (2) assuming, as reported by the master, that the evidence did not support the charge of fraud and corruption in the settlement of the liability on the two bonds of Holten for a much smaller sum than was legally due, had the town and city of East St. Louis authority and power to make the settlement and compromise and are the judgments rendered pursuant thereto valid and binding as settlements of the entire liability. •
This suit does not purport to be brought by authority of any statute conferring upon a tax-payer the right to bring an action at law in such case. The legal right and title to the money sought to be recovered by this action is not in the tax-payer complainants. (People v. Holten, supra.) This is a bill in chancery in the name of the People by five tax-payers, on behalf of themselves and all other tax-payers interested in the fund. The right of a tax-payer to maintain a bill in equity in behalf of himself and all other tax-payers against a public officer for misappropriating public funds was considered by this court in the case of Jones v. O’Connell, 266 Ill. 443, and it was held that such
It is true, in the Jones case the suit was against the officer, only, but we can see no reason, in principle, why, if such an action may be maintained against the officer,- it may not also be maintained against him and his sureties. We do not understand it to be controverted that Holten kept and retained for his own use, from the taxes collected by him, the amounts claimed in the bill in addition to his salary and compensation, and the master so found. If those charged with the duty of protecting and conserving the public money fail or refuse to act in such cases for the benefit of the tax-payers, from whom the money was collected and who have an interest in its proper appropriation, the tax-payers may resort to equity to redress the wrong. It certainly cannot be that in such cases the taxpayers are helpless.
The right of a municipality to compromise a claim which is not doubtful, for less than the full amount due, was passed upon by this court in People v. Parker, 231 Ill. 478. In that case Parker, the town collector of the town of. Alton, had retained two per cent commission on taxes collected by him, to the amount of $1045.52. The People, for the use of the town, sued and recovered a judgment against him for that amount. The cause was appealed to the Appellate Court, where the judgment was affirmed, and a further appeal was prosecuted to this court. While the appeal was pending in this court, at the annual town meeting of the town of Alton a resolution was adopted authorizing the supervisor, on payment of $25 by Parker, to satisfy the judgment of record. Parker paid the $25, the supervisor satisfied the judgment and appellants dismissed their appeal in this court. Plaintiffs in the suit entered a motion in the circuit court to set aside the satisfaction of the judgment, which was ordered done, and the case again came to this court. This court held that the town meeting and
Some other questions are discussed in the briefs, but the two questions referred to and treated were the material questions passed upon by the court, and we do not deem it advisable to discuss other questions.
For the errors indicated the decree is reversed and the cause remanded.
D Reversed and remanded.