People v. HernandezPeople v. Hernandez
- Reporters:
- ,
In December 2005, having served six years of the seven-year determinate term imposed upon his conviction of burglary in the second degree, defendant was granted conditional release and began to serve an administratively-imposed mandatory five-year term of postrelease supervision. Thereafter, in People v Sparber (10 NY3d 457 [2008]) and Matter of Garner v New York State Dept. of Correctional Servs. (10 NY3d 358 [2008]) the Court of Appeals held that a PRS term is only valid if judicially
The court clearly acted under the authority granted to it by the Legislature when it enacted
We further reject defendant‘s claim that double jeopardy and due process protections rendered his resentencing unconstitutional. Defendant concedes that his resentencing would have been constitutional had it occurred while he was still serving his prison sentence, but argues that the resentencing violated his legitimate expectation of finality since the PRS term imposed by the Department of Correctional Services (DOCS) was a nullity, since he had completed the only lawfully-imposed portion of his sentence, and since the People‘s time to seek corrective action by way of an appeal or
Clearly, defendant understood that PRS was a component of his sentence, as he had actually served three years of PRS at the time of resentencing. The fact that DOCS-imposed PRS is a nullity does not render it irrelevant to a defendant‘s expectation of finality. Here, defendant did not merely “expect” to be subject to PRS; he was actually serving such a term, albeit one that was improperly imposed by DOCS instead of the sentencing court. Furthermore, defendant could not have had a legitimate expectation in the finality of a sentence that is manifestly contrary to law. As noted, both the Court of Appeals and the Legislature have determined that failure to impose PRS is a defect that is correctable, notwithstanding the expiration of the