People v. HeinenPeople v. Heinen
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Stone
delivered the opinion of the court:
Plaintiffs in error, John Heinen and Thomas Talbert, were indicted in the criminal court of Cook county, together with Raymond Curley, Ben Heim, Jacob Jacobs and Harry McDonald, on the charge of robbery of Guy E. Reburn on May 15, 1920. As the other co-defendants were not apprehended plaintiffs in error were the only defendants tried.
The evidence for the State,—that is, the testimony of Reburn, his wife, Vesta Reburn, and her mother, Anna Andrews,—showed that some time after midnight on May 15, 1920, while Reburn was opening his garage for the purpose of putting away his automobile upon the return of himself, his wife and her mother from a social gathering, he and his
The defense relied upon was previous good character of the plaintiffs in error and an alibi. The evidence on the matter of the previous good character was not contested by the State. In support of the defense of alibi of Talbert the defense offered the testimony of William Simpson, assistant business agent for the Truck-drivers’ Union, who testified
The principal controverted question on the trial of the case was as to the identity of the plaintiffs in error. On his direct examination Reburn testified positively as to the identification of both plaintiffs in error. On cross-examination, however, and again on re-direct, he stated that there was a doubt in his mind as to whether or not he could identify Heinen. He stated on cross-examination he had not known either of the men, and had never seen them, that he knew of, until the night in question. On re-direct he stated he was not sure that Heinen was the man who struck him; that he was not positive that Heinen was at the garage that ‘night; that he had a doubt in his mind as to whether he could see the face of the man who struck him. Vesta Re-burn, the wife of the complaining witness, positively identified Heinen as being the man who took her rings, as did Mrs. Andrews.
After the verdict of the jury, which found the plaintiffs in error guilty of robbery and also found that they were
Upon motion to vacate the judgment a further hearing of evidence was had, and there was offered in evidence before the‘court, without objection on the part of the State, two letters written to the State’s attorney,—one from the complaining witness, Reburn, and one from his wife, Vesta Reburn, and her mother, Anna Andrews. In Reburn’s letter he wrote: “I am writing to you with considerable misgivings of the propriety of this course of action and also under the compunction
None of the above cases are exactly on all-fours with the case at bar. Here the prosecuting witnesses, three in number, have written letters to the State’s attorney sayiug, in effect, that they are convinced they should not have identified the plaintiffs in error and that they would not do so on a rehearing. While this appears by letter on motion to vacate the judgment and not by affidavit on motion for a new trial, and does not come strictly within the rule relating to the introduction of such matters into the record, no objection was made by the State to the admission or genuineness of the letters and no contradiction offered of their probative force. In fact, there is nothing, either in the record of the case or the argument for the People, which negatives either the genuineness of these letters, their sufficiency as ground for a new trial, or diligence on the part of plaintiffs in error in presenting the same. Where there is diligence, and the new matter does not conflict with the rulé concerning cumulative evidence, and is such as to strengthen the conviction that justice has not been done, a new trial should be granted. (People v. Cotell, 298 Ill. 207; People v. Wright, 287 id. 580; Wilder v. Greenlee, 49 id. 253.) The letters offered here were those of the only witnesses upon whose testimony the identification of plaintiffs in error rested. If they be taken as genuine,— and we have no reason to doubt that point,—they tend to show that on another trial these witnesses would not identify plaintiffs in error, or if they did, such identification would be materially affected by the letters. The evidence for the State does not stand uncontradicted, particularly as to Talbert, who offered corroborative evidence of an alibi. While not offered
As this case must be tried again it is advisable to consider some of the other objections raised on the record.
Counsel complain of People’s instruction No. 9, pertaining to the defense of alibi, in that it does not correctly state the law and disparages that defense by the language: “The court instructs the jury that in this case what is known as an alibi,—that is, that the defendants were at another place at the time it is claimed the offense was committed,—is in part relied upon by the defendants.” The argument is that this instruction gave the jury to understand that the defendants did not have full faith in their defense of alibi. While this instruction might have been more clearly drawn, it is not so erroneous in the respect complained of as would require reversal,
It is also urged that the instruction is not the law for the reason that it states, “you are to consider all the evidence in the case touching the question of alibi introduced by the defense as well as that introduced by the prosecution, and the reasonable doubt the jury is permitted to entertain must be as to the guilt of the accused on the whole evidence.” Plaintiffs in error contend that if the defense of alibi is sufficient to raise a reasonable doubt of the defendants’ guilt, then it was error to say that such doubt should arise on the whole evidence. The rule, as stated in People v. Blair, 266 Ill. 70, and numerous other cases in this State, is, that proof of alibi is sufficient to warrant an acquittal if it raises a reasonable doubt of the defendant’s guilt. Whether or not any evidence raises a reasonable doubt in the minds of the jury, whatever may be the nature of the proof, the rule has always been that such evidence must be considered in connection with all of the evidence in the case. If there is no evidence in the case tending to weaken it, then it is that evidence, alone, which raises the reasonable doubt. But whether or not a reasonable doubt is raised by proof of any character depends upon whether or not that proof is affected by other evidence in the case. This has always been the rule, and, indeed, it could not well be otherwise. The instruction was not open to this objection.
Other instructions were objected to, but upon consideration of the instructions as a series we are of the opinion that such objections are not well founded.
Other objections raised by plaintiffs in error are not such as will likely recur on a re-trial of the case.
For the reasons herein given, the judgment is reversed and the cause remanded.
n Reversed, and remanded.