People v. GriffinPeople v. Griffin
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Kluczynski
delivered the opinion of the court.
Defendant, with Bernard Joseph Boliaux, was tried by the court on a charge of burglary and found guilty. From this finding he appeals. He contends that the court admitted improper and prejudicial testimony and that the proof was not sufficient to justify a finding of guilty.
Louis Price, the manager of the laundry, on Saturday, June 10, 1962 at 4:00 p. m., locked the front door, returned about midnight to cheek up and upon opening the door noticed papers scattered over the front office. He heard a banging noise from the plant further in so he went out, locking the front door. As he went down
The Pilgrim Laundry building was a one-story building with a small wooden structure atop part of the roof. Immediately north was the Superb Cleaners building, almost a full story higher than the Pilgrim building. The third building, separated from Superb Cleaners by a passageway, was a one-story building occupied by a restaurant. The fourth was a three-story building containing the Atlas Silk Screen Company at 1733 Milwaukee Avenue.
Ann Stolarz, bookkeeper and cashier, worked Saturday until 4:00 p. m. Before leaving she prepared a list of currency derived from payment of laundry accounts and placed them in an envelope. (The one identified by Price.) The currency consisted of three $10 bills, twenty $5 bills, thirty-four $1 bills, and fifteen cents in coins, a total of $164.15. Before she left, Price removed three $10 bills and five $1 bills, a total of $35 from the envelope. Price then placed the note in the envelope. She saw the envelope with fifteen cents on the desk on Monday. The slip of paper or note was on the floor near the basket.
Officer Cy Martin testified that he works with a Herman shepherd dog. In the early morning of June 10, Price approached him, and he went to the laundry
Defendant contends that the court allowed testimony of the actions of the dog over his objections which was prejudicial and improper. Although the court overruled defendant’s objection at the time Walchuk testified of the actions of the dog, the court subsequently and before cross-examination, reversed his ruling and struck out the questioned evidence and later references to canine activity were suppressed, the court remarking:
“Now, this case is not complicated, if you leave the dogs out. The officers did nothing here a good officer wouldn’t do if he had a dog along or not.”
Reliance is had on the case of People v. Pfanschmidt, 262 Ill 411, 104 NE 804 (1914). In that case, the following of a trail by a bloodhound, leading to circumstantial evidence
In the cause before us the court acted properly. Since the case was tried by the court, there is a presumption that he considered only competent evidence in reaching his decision. People v. Richardson, 17 Ill2d 253, 261, 161 NE2d 268 (1959); People v. Grabowski, 12 Ill2d 462, 467, 147 NE2d 49 (1957); People v. Knapp, 15 Ill2d 450, 455, 155 NE2d 565 (1959).
Defendant, next, contends that the evidence was insufficient to support a guilty finding. This court will not reverse a judgment of conviction on the ground that the evidence is insufficient to sustain the finding of guilty unless there is a reasonable and well founded doubt of the guilt of the accused and the finding is palpably contrary to the weight of the evidence. People v. Lobb, 17 Ill2d 287, 294, 161 NE2d 325 (1959); People v. Prohaska, 8 Ill2d 579, 589, 134 NE2d 799 (1957). The credibility and weight to be given to the testimony is a question for the trial court, and this court will not substitute its judgment for that of the trial court. People v. Clark, 30 Ill2d 216, 219, 195 NE2d 631 (1964); People v. McCreary, 29 Ill2d 295, 194 NE2d 233 (1964); People v. Dillon, 24 Ill2d 122, 180 NE2d 503 (1962); People v. Hayes, 20 Ill2d 319 323, 169 NE2d 760 (1960).
The indictment charged defendant and Boliaux with having committed the offense of burglary on June 10, 1962 in that they, without authority, knowingly entered a building, to wit: the laundry of Pilgrim Laundry, Inc., a corporation, with the intent to commit therein, a theft. Although the evidence is circumstantial, it was
In addition to this proof there was the possession by defendant on his person of keys that fit an automobile parked near the burglarized premises and the fact that he told the police he arrived in the vicinity by bus or streetcar. These were incriminating admissions, allowing an inference of guilt. People v. Richardson, 21 Ill2d 435, 439, 172 NE2d 801 (1961).
Defendant finally contends that no evidence was offered that Pilgrim Laundry, Inc. was the owner of the money, and this must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt, citing People v. Walker, 7 Ill2d 158, 161, 130 NE2d (1955). The testimony indicated that the money was proceeds of the accounts of Pilgrim Laundry, Inc. checked and registered by its bookkeeper and cashier and reposed in the corporation’s property, a
“Ch 38. 19-1. A person commits burglary when, without authority, he knowingly enters into . . . a building . . . with intent to commit therein a felony or theft.
“Ch 38. 16-1. A person commits theft when he knowingly obtains or exerts unauthorized control over property of the owner.
“Ch 38. 15-2. Owner means a person, other than the offender, who has possession of or any other interest in the property involved.
“Ch 38. 15-8. . . . the phrase ‘obtains or exerts control’ over property includes but is not limited to the taking, carrying away . . . or possession of property.”
In People v. Figgers, 23 Ill2d 516, 519, 179 NE2d 626 (1962) the court held that the crime of burglary is complete upon the breaking and entering with intent to steal, and it is not essential to allege or prove that anything was taken. The court then continued with: “the allegations that property of Western Medical was stolen were not material to the charge of burglary and may be treated as surplusage. . . . The further contention of defendant that the prosecution failed to prove an intent to steal the property of Western Medical finds its answer in the recent case of People v. Johnson, 20 Ill2d 336, 169 NE2d 776. The evidence here, as in the cited case, shows that defendant intended
In another recent case, People v. Foster, 30 Ill2d 106, 195 NE2d 700 decided in January 1964, the court therein held that a variance as to the ownership of the property (taken) and the value thereof is not material in a burglary prosecution, citing the Figgers case.
We cannot say as a matter of law that the evidence here is insufficient to support the conviction of the defendant. The judgment of the Criminal Court is affirmed.
Affirmed.
MURPHY, P. J. and BURMAN, J., concur.Supplemental Opinion
Defendant’s petition for rehearing says: “The Plaintiff in Error raises for the first time in the reviewing court that the indictment for burglary is defective in failing to allege the address of the building burglarized, to wit: a laundry of the Pilgrim Laundry, Inc., a corporation. A motion to arrest judgment was denied.”
This point is raised for the first time in the petition for rehearing. It is not included as a reason for reversal among the Points and Authorities in defendant’s brief.
Our Appellate Court Rule 5(k) adopts Rule 39 of the Supreme Court which in Part IV, 2nd paragraph reads as follows:
“No alleged error or point not contained in the brief shall be raised afterwards, either by reply brief or in oral or printed argument, or on petition for rehearing.”
Because of this the point will not be reviewed. It is the only ground raised in the petition for rehearing. Therefore, the petition for rehearing is denied.