People v. GreenePeople v. Greene
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Atlas
OPINION OF THE COURT
Jeffrey Atlas, J.Defendant was charged, by information, with prostitution (
The accusatory instrument states: “Deponent, Police Officer Steven D’Antonio, Shield #14420, states that at the above time and place the defendant did approach and engage the deponent in conversation and did agree to commit an unlawful sexual act with the deponent for a fee, to wit: to be naked, to manipulate her genitals and to allow the deponent to orgasim [sic].”
The defendant argues that the information is defective because the acts which the defendant agreed to perform would not, if performed by her, constitute “sexual conduct with another” as that phrase is used in
*41Since defendant’s argument assumes that the proposed acts of the defendant would constitute “sexual conduct” if performed by her, the issue before me is solely whether, in this case, the proposed sexual conduct of the defendant was to be performed “with another” as that phrase is used in
Article 230 of the Penal Law does not define the phrase “with another” (nor, for that matter, the phrase “sexual conduct”). However, an appropriate definition can be obtained by construing the section (
It is clear that the Legislature did not intend
More significantly, were the phrase “sexual conduct with another person” to be interpreted as proscribing agreements calling for sexual conduct to be performed for another person, as well as with another person,
The defendant is accused of having agreed only to perform an autoerotic exhibition for another. However, auto-*42erotic exhibitions, performed for a fee before an audience (albeit an audience of one), may certainly be “performances” as that term has been traditionally defined and as it is specifically defined in section 235.00 of the Penal Law.2
It is clear that
Notes
. See People v Costello, 90 Misc 2d 431.
. Webster’s Dictionary defines “performance” as an exhibition of skill or talent and as a show (Webster’s New Twentieth Century Dictionary [2d ed, 1977]); subdivision 3 of section 235 of the Penal Law defines a “performance” as any play, motion picture, dance or other exhibition performed before an audience.
. Article 235 of the Penal Law carefully defines the word “obscene” to conform to the constitutional requirements expressed in Miller v California (413 US 15). (See Hechtman, Practice Commentary, McKinney’s Cons Laws of NY, Book 39,
. See People v Ferber, 52 NY2d 674, 678-679.
. See Matter of Lorie C., 49 NY2d 161, 171.
. See People v Costello, 90 Misc 2d 431, supra.