People v. GilmanPeople v. Gilman
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Simkins
delivered the opinion of the court:
On August 4, 1972, defendant, Edward Dean Gilman, was charged by a criminal complaint with violating Ill. Rev. Stat. 1971, ch. 38, sec. 31 — 1, which states that a person commits the offense of resisting or obstructing a peace officer when he “knowingly resists or obstructs the performance by one known to the person to be a peace officer of any authorized act within his official capacity * # At the conclusion of the State’s evidence the trial court on November 20, 1972 granted defendant’s oral motion to dismiss the complaint for failure to charge an offense in that the complaint did not state that the arresting officers were performing an “authorized act within their official capacity.” This is an appeal by the State pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 604(a) from the trial court’s dismissal of that complaint.
Count 2 of the complaint contained the following language:
“* * * [defendant] committed the offense of Resisting Arrest, in violation of Chapter 38, Section 31 — 1, Ill. Rev. Stat, 1971, in that he resisted the efforts of one known by him to be a police officer, to-wit: Officer C. Boland of the City of Decatur Police Department and Officer P. Moore of the City of Decatur Police Department when they attempted to put him under arrest, in that he fought with them and wrestle [sic wrestled] with them and tried to get away from then [sic them] and had to be subdued by them.”
The sole issue on this appeal is whether this complaint sufficiently stated the offense charged.
Defendant contends that by not asserting in the complaint that the arresting officers were performing “an authorized act within their official capacity,” the State failed to allege an essential element of the offense, and the trial court correctly dismissed the complaint. This argument evolves around defendant’s interpretation of Ill. Rev. Stat. 1971, ch, 38, sec. 7 — 7 which states:
“(a) A person is not authorized to use force to resist an arrest which he knows is being made either by a peace officer or by a private person summoned and directed by a peace officer to make the arrest, even if he believes that the arrest is unlawful and the arrest in fact is unlawful.”
Most basically, by allowing allegations of an illegal arrest to be a defense in a section 31 — 1 action would, indeed, have an adverse effect on the public tranquility by encouraging violence and failing to provide adequate protection for the law enforcement officials of our State. The provisions’ of section 33 — 1, when read with the provisions of section 7— 7 do not, in our view, grant to any individual, during the course of an
The defendant in the instant case was informed of the correct statutory provision under which he was being prosecuted. Most importantly, he was informed of the nature and basic elements of the offense in that the complaint alleged that an arrest was made, that defendant knew the arresting individuals to be police officers, and that specific described acts of resistance were performed. Since an officer is endowed with authority to make an arrest, the arrest is authorized at least to the extent that one may not use force to resist regardless of the legality or illegality of that arrest. Furthermore, the act of arrest is by its very nature within the officers’ official capacity. Therefore, the allegation in a section 31 — 1 complaint that the arresting officer is performing ‘an authorized act within his official capacity’ is unnecessary when the complaint states, as in the instant case, that an arrest has been made by persons known to defendant to be police officers.
For the reasons herein stated the complaint sufficiently charged the offense of resisting arrest. The order of the trial court dismissing the complaint is reversed and the cause is remanded for further proceedings not inconsistent with the views herein expressed.
Judgment reversed.
SMITH, P. J., and KASSERMAN, J., concur.