People v. GibsonPeople v. Gibson
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Deusen
delivered the opinion of the court:
After a trial by jury, the defendant, Theodore Gibson, was found guilty of the unlawful use of a credit card in violation of section 8(i) of the Illinois Credit Card Act (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1979, ch. 121½, par. 608(i)). Prior to sentencing, the defendant informed the court that he wished to plead guilty to a pending charge of forgery. After accepting the defendant’s guilty plea, the court sentenced him to concurrent terms of probation for one year plus 30 days in the Du Page County jail. This sentence was for both offenses, the unlawful use of a credit card and the forgery. The defendant appeals from his conviction of the unlawful use of a credit card.
The defendant’s conviction stems from his attempt to purchase two
On appeal, the defendant’s sole contention is that the statutory section under which he was convicted (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1979, ch. 121½, par. 608(i)) contains no penalty provision and consequently is a nullity. Accordingly, he asserts that his conviction for the unlawful use of a credit card must be vacated.
We note initially that neither party has directed us to a case on point, and our independent research has not discovered any. Apparently, the issue raised on review presents this court with a case of first impression in Illinois.
In relevant part, section 8 of the Illinois Credit Card Act provides:
“A person who, with intent to defraud either the issuer, or a person providing money, goods, property, services or anything else of value, or any other person, (i) uses, for the purposes of obtaining money, goods, property, services or anything else of value a credit card obtained or retained in violation of this Act or without the cardholder’s consent, or a credit card which he knows is counterfeited, or forged, or expired, or revoked, or (ii) obtains money, goods, property, services or anything else of value by representing without the consent of the cardholder that he is the holder of a specified card or by representing that he is the holder of a card and such card has not in fact been issued, is guilty of a Class A misdemeanor if the value of all money, goods, property, services and other things of value obtained in violation of this Section does not exceed $150 in any 6-month period; and is guilty of a Class 4 felony if such value exceeds $150 in any 6-month period.” (Emphasis added.) Ill. Rev. Stat. 1979, ch. 121)2, par. 608.
It is clear that the statute in question describes two forms of prohibited conduct. The conduct proscribed in section 8(i) involves the mere use of a credit card, regardless of whether goods or property are actually obtained, whereas the conduct prohibited in section 8(ii) pertains
The thrust or gravamen of the defendant’s argument on appeal is that the penalty provision contained in section 8 of the Illinois Credit Card Act applies only in the event that goods are actually “obtained” by the unlawful use of a credit card. The defendant contends that the statute was intended to penalize only conduct resulting in the actual obtaining of goods. In support of this contention, he emphasizes that, in setting forth the misdemeanor penalty, the penalty provision refers solely to the value of goods “obtained” and does not expressly include the value of goods sought to be obtained, but not actually obtained by the use of a credit card. The defendant correctly states the proposition of law that a statute containing prohibitive language without also providing for a penalty is a nullity. People v. Kimmons (1979), 79 Ill. App. 3d 601, 602; People v. Natoli (1979), 70 Ill. App. 3d 131, 140; People v. Graf (1968), 93 Ill. App. 2d 43, 48, 50.
We view the task before us as one involving the construction or the interpretation of the statute at issue. Certain well-established principles exist to guide us in this endeavor. The prime consideration or cardinal rule in construing a statutory enactment is to ascertain and give effect to the intent of the legislature. (People v. Bratcher (1976), 63 Ill. 2d 534, 543; People ex rel. Barrett v. Anderson (1947), 398 Ill. 480, 485-86; People v. Floom (1977), 52 Ill. App. 3d 971, 974; Bee Jay’s Truck Stop, Inc. v. Department of Revenue (1977), 52 Ill. App. 3d 90,94, cert, denied (1978), 435 U.S. 970,56 L. Ed. 2d 61,98 S. Ct. 1610.) While the legislative intent is sought primarily from the language used in the statute (Bee Jay’s Truck Stop, Inc. v. Department of Revenue), we may also look to the statutory objective and the evils sought to be remedied (People ex rel. Barrett v. Anderson, at 486; People v. Hubble (1980), 81 Ill. App. 3d 560, 563; People v. Floom, at 975; People v. Spencer (1971), 131 Ill. App. 2d 551, 553) and then arrive at a common-sense construction though it may qualify the
While courts are generally cautious about adding words to a statute, they will read into the meaning of a statutory provision a qualifying or expanding expression plainly implied by the general context of the enactment, which has been palpably omitted and which is essential to prevent the legislative purpose from failing in one of its important aspects. (People ex rel. Barrett v. Anderson, at 485; R.E. Joos Excavating Co. v. Pollution Control Board (1978), 58 Ill. App. 3d 309, 313.) Furthermore, the omission or addition of words in a new statute does not necessarily indicate a legislative intent to change the effect of a prior statute, and a change of construction occurs only when the intent of the legislature or the language used in the new statute plainly requires it. (People v. Nunn (1979), 77 Ill. 2d 243, 249.) Lastly, while it is the rule that penal statutes are to be strictly construed in favor of the defendant, the courts will not construe them so rigidly as to defeat the legislative intent. People v. Bratcher, at 543.
We begin our analysis by noting that the Illinois Credit Card Act (Act) (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1979, ch. 121/2, par. 601 et seq.) is a comprehensive statute governing the wrongful use or disposition of credit cards. Our reading of the Act reveals that the legislature sought to proscribe and punish a wide variety of unlawful conduct which has recently occurred with the increased use of and reliance on credit cards. We note that both section 8 of the Act and the former section 17 — 1(e)(1) of the Code set forth two distinct offenses: (1) the use of a credit card for the purpose of obtaining goods, regardless of whether the goods are obtained, and (2) the actual obtaining of such goods by misrepresenting that one is a valid holder of a credit card. We believe section 8(i) indicates that the legislature foresaw the situation, as in the case at bar, in which a person would be thwarted in his attempt to obtain retail merchandise by using a credit card without the cardholder’s consent. In this regard, the legislative purpose behind section 8(i) is consistent with that underlying former section 17 — 1(e)(1) of the Code, which proscribed any attempt to obtain property by the use of a credit card without the cardholder’s consent or permission.
While we recognize, as the defendant points out, that the penalty provision of section 8 employs the word “obtained” and does not expressly refer to the value of goods attempted or sought to be obtained, we are not persuaded that the legislature intended to limit the application
Applying the rules of statutory construction previously set forth, we determine that, while the statute in question is inartfully, imprecisely, and incompletely phrased, the clear intendment of the legislature was that the penalty provision of section 8 should apply to situations where, as here, the accused was unsuccessful in his attempt to purchase goods or property by the unlawful use of a credit card. We are compelled to conclude that the failure to include additional language such as “sought to be obtained” or “attempted to be obtained” or words of similar import was a legislative oversight, inadvertent omission, or mistake, particularly given the fact that both types of offense proscribed in section 8 are included as part of a single sentence along with the penalty provision. We further believe that, although the legislature inadvertently failed to include this additional language, such words are contained in the statute by fair implication. Accordingly, we determine that the words inadvertently omitted may be supplied to effectuate the legislative purpose. (Cf. People v. Spencer (1971), 131 Ill. App. 2d 551, 553.) We note also that some significance may be attached to the fact that section 8 has previously been considered on appeal in People v. Koonce (1978), 65 Ill. App. 3d 86, 87 and People v. Heinz (1980), 87 Ill. App. 3d 1, 2. In both cases, as in this case, the defendant was not successful in obtaining any money, goods or anything else of value, and yet the issue prescribed here was neither raised nor considered on appeal.
For the reasons set forth above, the judgment of the trial court is affirmed.
Affirmed.
HOPF and REINHARD, JJ., concur.