People v. FormanPeople v. Forman
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Grunergans
OPINION OF THE COURT
Louise Gruner-Gans, J.On June 24, 1988, defendant Milton Forman was excluded from his home by the terms of a temporary order of protection issued pursuant to
“(a) to stay away from the home, school, business or place of employment of the family or household member or of any designated witness;
“(b) to permit a parent to visit the child at stated periods * * *
“(c) to abstain from offensive conduct against the child or against the family or household member or against any person to whom custody of the child is awarded;
“(d) to refrain from acts of commission or omission that tend to make the home not a proper place for the family or household member.”
The statute, since amended by Laws of 1988 (ch 702), does not specify a standard or list criteria on the basis of which a court is to determine whether a temporary order of protection should issue.
Defendant Milton Forman and complainant Barbara For-man are husband and wife. Immediately prior to his arrest, defendant and his wife were staying in separate cooperative apartments, each jointly owned by them, in the same apartment building in Manhattan. The larger of the two apartments was the couple’s marital home, while the smaller served as the wife’s office. As a consequence of severe marital conflict between them, the wife was temporarily sleeping in her office, but had access to the larger apartment during the day. The defendant husband continued to occupy and sleep in the larger apartment.
Defendant was arrested on June 24, 1988 and charged with assault in the third degree (
At his arraignment on June 24, 1988, defendant was represented by counsel, and with the consent of the People was released on his own recognizance. At the arraignment, the People requested, and the court issued, a temporary order of protection, effective until July 17, 1988, unless further extended by the court. No argument was heard, or testimony presented, either in support of or in opposition to the issuance of the TOP. The temporary order of protection, issued on the officially prescribed form used for this purpose in the Criminal Court for the City of New York (“Form no. 2 [Family Offense-Temporary Order of Protection]”), directed defendant as follows: (a) to stay away from the home, school, business or place of employment of Barbara Forman; (c) to abstain from offensive conduct against Barbara Forman; and (d) to refrain from acts of omission or commission that tend to make the home not a proper place for Barbara Forman.
The effect of this temporary order of protection was to exclude the defendant from both of the couple’s apartments, since one was arguably the complainant’s home and the other her office.
On June 26, 1988, two days after defendant’s arrest, Bar
On July 13, 1988, defendant and his counsel appeared in Part AP 3 of this court and orally requested that the TOP be modified to allow the defendant access to one of the two apartments. The application was denied with leave to renew in writing. A new TOP was issued, without a hearing, on the same terms as previously, and made effective until August 1, 1988, unless extended by the court. On July 15, 1988, by order to show cause returnable on July 26, 1988, defendant moved to vacate the TOP as based on insufficient evidence and issued in violation of due process of law. Additionally, and alternatively, defendant moved for a hearing pursuant to
On July 20, 1988, the defendant’s written motion was disposed of by stipulation. The People and the defendant agreed in writing that a hearing would be held to determine defendant’s claim “that an Order of Protection should not have been issued in this case and that the police do not have probable cause to arrest me [the defendant] for violation of that Order of Protection.” On July 26, 1988 the stipulation was approved by the Presiding Judge and the hearing was scheduled for August 1, 1988.
The hearing was held before this court. Consistent with the stipulation, testimony was limited to the question whether there was sufficient evidence to justify the issuance of a TOP as of June 24, 1988, and whether there was a current basis for its continuation. Although called for by the stipulation, no evidence was taken at the hearing to determine whether there was probable cause to arrest the defendant for violation of the TOP. Instead, with the defendant’s consent, the People filed a “Superseding Amendment” to the information charging the defendant with criminal contempt in the second degree (
At the conclusion of the hearing, on August 4, 1988, this court orally ruled that the evidence supported the issuance of the initial TOP on June 24, 1988, and issued a new temporary order of protection excluding defendant from only one of the two apartments owned by him jointly with his wife. Decision was reserved on all issues of law. The parties agreed that defendant’s constitutional challenge to
By an order, without opinion, dated April 28, 1989, this court withdrew its August 4, 1988 oral decision that there was on June 24, 1988 a sufficient basis for the issuance of a TOP; adhered to its decision to issue a new temporary order of protection; denied defendant’s motion to vacate the June 24, 1988 temporary order of protection on constitutional grounds; and dismissed the charge of criminal contempt in the second degree (
SCOPE OF HEARING HELD TO REVIEW ISSUANCE OF TOP
The stipulation pursuant to which the hearing before this court was held was based on a fundamental misconception. The TOP of June 24, 1988 was issued as a condition of defendant’s release on his own recognizance. (
The issue properly presented at the hearing held before this
The complainant Barbara Forman testified credibly that on June 24, 1988 the defendant punched her in the mouth, knocking out one of her front teeth, that the defendant had a history of violent conduct, including specifically, an incident in May 1987 during which defendant shoved her into a wall injuring her elbow, and an altercation in October 1987 when defendant knocked complainant to the floor, causing her to break an ankle, forced her to walk on the broken ankle and then threw books at her. The complainant wife had previously initiated and then abandoned a family offense proceeding in the Family Court (Family Ct Act art 8) and for a time had a temporary order of protection from that court. Defendant presented no witnesses at the hearing, and did not persuasively impeach complainant’s credibility through cross-examination. Complainant also swore to the allegations of the “Superseding Amendment” to the information that two days after the initial TOP was issued by the Criminal Court, the defendant telephoned her and told her that he had a gun and was coming to see her. All this evidence established that there was a substantial danger of intimidation or injury to the complainant and supported the issuance of a new TOP on August 4, 1988. This court adheres to its initial determination on this point.
STANDING AND MOOTNESS
Before defendant’s constitutional attack on
The People also assert that this controversy has become moot, because the temporary order of protection of June 24, 1988 has since been continued or replaced by subsequent orders.
The court agrees with the defendant that he has standing to maintain his constitutional defenses, and that he has presented a live dispute appropriate for adjudication.
In determining whether defendant has standing to raise his constitutional challenge, it must be shown that his “personal or property rights will be directly and specifically affected.” (Matter of Abrams v New York City Tr. Auth., 48 AD2d 69, 70 [1975], affd 39 NY2d 990 [1976].) In order to have standing to challenge a statute as unconstitutional, a defendant must demonstrate actual or threatened injury to a protected right (see, Duke Power Co. v Carolina Envtl. Study Group, 438 US 59 [1978]; People v Parker, 41 NY2d 21 [1976]; Matter of Donohue v Cornelius, 17 NY2d 390, 397 [1966]; People v Merolla, 9 NY2d 62 [1961]), and that he has been aggrieved by the unconstitutional feature of the statute (see, Ulster County Ct. v Allen, 442 US 140 [1979]; Oriental Blvd. Co. v Heller, 27 NY2d 212 [1970], appeal dismissed 401 US 986 [1971]; People v Beakes Dairy Co., 222 NY 416 [1918]).
Defendant’s liberty and property interests were and are restricted by each of the various temporary orders of protection issued against him. He presently faces criminal prosecution, now based in part on his violation of the order which he claims to be unconstitutional. Each of the temporary orders of protection restrict defendant’s liberty to go where he pleases— he may not go to the home, business or place of employment of his wife, as well as his associational liberty in relation to his wife. (Griswold v Connecticut, 381 US 479, 486 [1965]; Cooper v Morin, 49 NY2d 69, 80 [1979], cert denied sub nom. Lombard v Cooper, 446 US 984 [1980].) The orders also exclude him from real property in which defendant otherwise shares ownership and a right to possession. (People v Garland, 69 NY2d 144 [1987].)
Although the temporary order of June 24, 1988 is no longer in effect, the controversy surrounding its issuance is not moot. Defendant currently faces prosecution for the violation of the order of June 24. In addition, the temporary nature of short-term orders may not be used to insulate them from legal challenge. A case will not be treated as moot where the problem presented is capable of repetition, typically evades review, and is novel and substantial. (Matter of Hearst Corp. v Clyne, 50 NY2d 707, 714-715 [1980].) The temporary order of protection issued in this case fits this pattern. Each year thousands of relatively short-lived temporary orders of protection, restricting the liberty and property of the accused, are and will be issued by the Criminal Courts of the City of New York. Since as a matter of practice a new TOP is issued on each adjourned date in a criminal proceeding, there is no opportunity to litigate a challenge to any one such order while it is still in effect. Moreover, habeas corpus is not available to review these TOPs where the defendant is not incarcerated. (People ex rel. Wilder v Markley, 26 NY2d 648 [1970]; People ex rel. Sutton v Glick, 38 AD2d 513 [1st Dept 1971]; People ex rel. Uqdah v New York State Bd. of Parole, 108 AD2d 888 [2d Dept 1985].) Last but not least, the question of the process that is due before or after such an order may be issued is a substantial one.
EXISTING PROCEDURES AND CRITERIA FOR THE ISSUANCE OF TEMPORARY ORDERS OF PROTECTION
According to defendant,
Defendant’s constitutional arguments must be assessed in
There is surprisingly little authority concerning the nature of a defendant’s opportunity to be heard pursuant to
At arraignment, in addition to the presentation of an accusatory instrument, defendant’s NYSID sheet and the report of the Criminal Justice Agency, a hearing on an initial application for bail or recognizance pursuant to
Following arraignment, numerous courts have held, relying on
The standard for the issuance of a temporary order of protection, while not provided by statute, may be derived from the common law as it is embodied in case law. (Cf., People ex rel. Shaw v Lombard, 95 Misc 2d 664 [Monroe County Ct 1978].) In the absence of a statutory standard,
defendant’s constitutional challenge
(a) Right to a prior evidentiary hearing
Defendant claims that pursuant to the Fourteenth Amendment to the US Constitution an evidentiary hearing must be held before a TOP excluding a defendant from the home may issue. Although this claim was previously considered in People v Faieta (109 Misc 2d 841 [Dist Ct, Nassau County 1981], supra) and People v Derisi (110 Misc 2d 718 [Dist Ct, Suffolk County 1981], supra), a fuller discussion of the issues is appropriate to show why under current constitutional authority and the procedural safeguards provided by New York law defendant’s claim must be rejected.
Whenever State action deprives a citizen of his or her liberty or property due process requires that he or she be afforded the opportunity for a hearing. (Schall v Martin, 467 US 253 [1984]; Matthews v Eldridge, 424 US 319, 335 [1976]; Gerstein v Pugh, 420 US 103, 114 [1975]; Matter of Jones v Berman, 37 NY2d 42, 55 [1975]; Sharrock v Dell Buick-Cadillac, 45 NY2d 152, 163 [1978].) The hearing must be provided ” ‘at a meaningful time and in a meaningful manner.’ ” (Matthews v Eldridge, supra, at 333, quoting Armstrong v Manzo, 380 US 545, 552 [1965].) Only in extraordinary situations may the hearing be postponed until after the deprivation has occurred. (Baddie v Connecticut, 401 US 371, 379 [1971];
Certain factors have consistently been considered in evaluating the adequacy of procedures both under Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment and under the Fourth Amendment. Even where not formally designated as such, the factors outlined in Matthews v Eldridge (supra, at 335) are those most consistently relied upon: “First, the private interest that will be affected by the official action; second, the risk of an erroneous deprivation of such interest through the procedures used, and the probable value, if any, of additional or substitute procedural safeguards; and finally, the Government’s interest, including the function involved and the fiscal and administrative burdens that the additional or substitute procedural requirements would entail.” (Compare, Gerstein v Pugh, 420 US 103, 113-114, 120-123 [1975], supra; Schall v Martin, 467 US 253, 263-268, 274 [1984], supra; Cleveland Bd. of Educ. v Loudermill, 470 US 532, 542-543 [1985].)
Applying those factors to the instant case, we turn first to the private interest affected. A temporary order of protection excluding defendant from the home is not an adjudication of title, and is not to be mistaken for a legal order of eviction pursuant to RPAPL article 7. Nevertheless, the interest affected here is the defendant’s use and enjoyment of his property interest in the home he owns jointly with his wife. (People v Garland, 69 NY2d 144 [1987].) Beyond its value as property, a person’s special interest in his/her home as an enclave of personal security and privacy has repeatedly been recognized under the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments. (See, Griswold v Connecticut, 381 US 479, 486 [1965], supra; Stanley v Georgia, 394 US 557, 566 [1969]; Payton v New York, 445 US 573, 588-590, 601 [1980].) Being suddenly deprived of one’s home, even temporarily, is a traumatic experience.
Clearly, the property interest of the defendant affected by exclusion from the home pursuant to a temporary order of protection is a substantial one. Before defendant may be
The State’s interest in the issuance of temporary orders of protection pursuant to
The risk of error in determining whether a TOP excluding a defendant from the home should be issued is clearly greater when the determination is based only on the documents and arguments of counsel available to the court at arraignment rather than on the testimony of live witnesses subject to cross-examination. The adversary process would better assist the court in making the crucial assessment of the complainant’s credibility, the extent of any injuries suffered and threats made, and the defendant’s history of violent behaviour toward the complainant and others.
Despite the strength of defendant’s constitutional interest, and the evident if unquantifiable risk of error, the emergency nature of the decision, as well as the practical difficulties inherent in convening an immediate evidentiary hearing, mitigate against the imposition of such hearings as constitutionally required before a TOP may first be issued at arraignment.2
The United States Supreme Court and the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit have held that in the initial phase of criminal proceedings, the need for expeditious assumption of judicial control following a defendant’s arrest outweighs the need to minimize risk of error through adversary procedures. (Gerstein v Pugh, 420 US 103, 119-123 [1975], supra; Williams v Ward, 845 F2d 374 [2d Cir 1988]; cf., Morrissey v Brewer, 408 US 471, 484-487 [1972], supra.) Since in New York the probable cause hearing is combined with the determination of pretrial release (Williams v Ward, supra, at
Gerstein v Pugh (supra at 122, n 23) held that while a judicial probable cause determination was required to be made promptly following a defendant’s arrest, the probable cause hearing required by the Fourth Amendment need not be an adversary one, in part, because such hearings would “exacerbate the problem of pretrial delay.” In Williams v Ward, (supra), the Second Circuit ruled that pretrial detention of defendants of up to 72 hours without any intermediate probable cause hearing was constitutionally permissible under the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments in light of the totality of processes afforded a defendant at arraignment in the New York City Criminal Court. These processes included a determination of probable cause, a determination of bail or recognizance and an opportunity for a final disposition, all with the assistance of counsel. The court concluded that the introduction of an earlier intermediate probable cause hearing in addition to the existing procedures would unduly burden the State’s ability to expedite arraignments for all defendants, and would be detrimental to defendants as a class. (Williams v Ward, 845 F2d, supra, at 386-389.)
The requirements of due process do entitle defendant to a prompt evidentiary hearing after the temporary order of protection excluding defendant from the home has been issued. (Barry v Barchi, 443 US 55 [1979], supra; Fuentes v Shevin, 407 US 67 [1972], supra; Jones v Berman, 37 NY2d 42 [1975], supra.) The importance of defendant’s interest in his home, the severity of the deprivation imposed through exclusion from the home, and, typically, the need to resolve conflicting issues of fact and credibility as to the underlying family conflict, require that a trial type hearing be provided. Presentation of witnesses and cross-examination are the most suitable means for assessment of veracity and credibility. (Matthews v Eldridge, 424 US, supra, at 343-344.)
The fact that defendant will ultimately have a full trial of the underlying charges against him “does not obviate the prompt hearing requirement” (People v Derisi, 110 Misc 2d 718 [Dist Ct, Suffolk County 1981], supra, citing Fuentes v Shevin, 407 US 67 [1972], supra). The time frames of the speedy trial requirements (
Schall v Martin (supra) also supports this court’s, conclusion. In Schall, the United States Supreme Court held that a New York Family Court procedure which permitted pretrial detention of juvenile offenders on the basis of a minimal initial detention hearing strikingly similar to the procedure for determining bail or recognizance in New York criminal cases, and which was followed by a prompt adversary evidentiary hearing, satisfied due process requirements.
The fact that the court, when issuing a TOP, is not statutorily mandated to state its findings of fact and conclusions of law on the record does not impair the constitutionality of
(b) Inadequacy of Standard
According to defendant, the absence of a standard or of criteria for the issuance of a temporary order of protection makes the application of
The absence of criteria or factors which the court must consider in making its determination was held not to impair the constitutionality of the statutes at issue in United States v Salerno (supra), Schall v Martin (supra) and People ex rel. Wayburn v Schupf (supra). However, articulated statutory criteria enhance “the responsible exercise of * * * discretion”. (People v Beige, 41 NY2d 60, 62 [1976].) This court notes that subsequent to the entry of the TOP complained of here, effective November 1, 1988,
DISMISSAL OF CRIMINAL CONTEMPT CHARGES
As noted earlier, defendant here has also been charged with criminal contempt in the second degree (
Violation of this provision of the temporary order of protection cannot support a charge of criminal contempt. As a rule, the order of a court, no matter how erroneous, must be obeyed unless the issuing court lacks jurisdiction or the order is void on its face. (Ketchum v Edwards, 153 NY 534, 539 [1897]; State of New York v Congress of Racial Equality, 92 AD2d 815, 817 [1st Dept 1983].) It is equally well settled that to support a charge of criminal contempt there must be a clearly expressed and definite order of the court (Ketchum v Edwards, 153 NY 534 [1897], supra; Matter of Holtzman v Beatty, 97 AD2d 79 [2d Dept 1983]), and the contemnor must know of the order. (Matter of Holtzman v Beatty, supra.)
Although these precedents were established with respect to judicial contempt (
The elements of the two forms of contempt are essentially the same, despite the procedural differences which exist between judicial contempt and penal contempt proceedings. (See, Donnino, Practice Commentaries, McKinney’s Cons Laws of NY, Book 39,
The court concludes that a prosecution for criminal contempt under the Penal Law is subject to the same requirement of clarity and precision as a contempt proceeding under the Judiciary Law. When measured against that standard, the portion of the temporary order of protection directing defendant Forman to “refrain from offensive conduct” must be held not subject to enforcement or sanction pursuant to
When the Legislature promulgated
Accordingly, defendant Milton Forman cannot be prosecuted for criminal contempt in the second degree (
Notes
. At the hearing the court found that the People had actually supported the continuation of the TOP excluding defendant from his home by a preponderance of the evidence. However, the court does not determine in this case whether a finding of a danger of intimidation or injury to complainant need only have reasonable factual support in the record, as in the case of other determinations relating to bail or recognizance (People ex rel. Klein v Krueger, 25 NY 497, 501 [1969]), or, whether a higher evidentiary standard is required under the Fourteenth Amendment to support defendant’s continued exclusion from his home. Although initially raised in defendant’s moving papers, this issue was never briefed by defendant.
. In Bellamy v Judges & Justices (41 AD2d 196 [1st Dept 1973], affd without opn 32 NY2d 886, remittitur amended 33 NY2d 632 [1973]), the Court of Appeals considered and rejected the contention that CPL article 500 violated due process of law. Although the court in Bellamy published no opinion, a search of the record shows that one of the claims presented was that as a matter of due process bail or release could only be determined after an adversary evidentiary hearing. Although in some circumstances the unanimous affirmance without opinion by the Court of Appeals of an Appellate Division upholding the constitutionality of a statute is presumed to constitute precedent on the constitutional issues raised by the appeal (Matter of Koppelman v Sunset Wine Co., 180 Misc 812 [Sup Ct, Kings County 1943]; People ex rel. Shinitsky v Hunt, 178 Misc 960 [Sup Ct, Erie County 1942]), the multiplicity of constitutional questions raised in Bellamy does not permit reliance on that ruling as to any single procedural due process claim presented.
. Despite these improvements, some of the new statutory language is extremely confusing. The first sentence of the new