People v. ForbesPeople v. Forbes
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Egan
delivered the opinion of the court:
A jury convicted the defendant, Lisa Forbes, of the murder of James Bankston (James); the judge sentenced her to imprisonment for 25 years. The defendant was 20 years old at the time of trial. She began going with James when she was 15 years old. They had a child, Mercedes, who was two years old at the time of James’ death. The relationship ended, and the defendant filed a paternity suit against James. She was awarded $5,800; she filed a lien on James’ home. On December 15, 1985, she left her home in Milwaukee and went to James’ home in Chicago, where he was living with his wife, Yvette. The defendant stabbed James to death with a butcher knife. Her first contention is that she was not proved guilty of murder beyond a reasonable doubt.
. Yvette Bankston testified that at the time of the killing she shared an upstairs apartment with James and her two children. James’ sister, Cloteina Bankston, lived in the first-floor apartment with her son, Amanuel. The defendant had called earlier in the week and spoke with James while Yvette listened on the extension phone. The defendant told him that she wanted to get married and that she “didn’t want the house.” James told the defendant that he didn’t want to marry her and that he loved someone else. The defendant said that she “hated” James and their baby; that if she couldn’t have him no one would; and that she was going to put the baby up for adoption. The defendant also said she was coming to Chicago to visit James.
On the morning of the stabbing, Yvette answered the defendant’s telephone call. The defendant asked to talk with James, and Yvette told her that he was not home. The doorbell rang on two occasions, but Yvette and James did not answer it. Amanuel, James’ nephew, came
Amanuel Bankston testified that after Yvette gave the tea to James and returned to the kitchen, Amanuel looked down the hallway toward the living room. He saw the defendant putting on her coat. He then heard James yell, “Baby, baby, help me, she is trying to kill me.” Amanuel ran to the living room, where he saw the defendant strike James across the chest with the knife and then plunge it into his arm. The defendant stood up, looked at Amanuel and “spun” the knife toward him. Amanuel dodged the knife and ran to the kitchen to call the police. When he returned to the living room, he helped Yvette hold the front door where the defendant was trapped. He said that after the stabbing the defendant appeared “calm, like nothing had happened.”
Felicia Nickols testified that she was in the kitchen with Yvette and Amanuel when she also heard James scream, “Baby, baby, help me. She is trying to kill me.” Felicia ran to the living room, where she saw James, who was yelling, “She stabbed me, she stabbed me. Why?”
Chicago police officer John McCann testified that on December 15, he spoke with the defendant at the Area 3 police station about 3 p.m.
Assistant State’s Attorney Giróte testified that he read the defendant her Miranda warnings and that the defendant said that she understood them. Giróte wrote down what she told him. She told Giróte that on December 15 she took a bus from Milwaukee to Chicago because she wanted to talk with James about child support for Mercedes. The relationship between James and the defendant had ended about two years before. She went to James’ house and rang the bell but got no answer. At this time she was “mad because [James] knew [she] was coming and also [she] knew somebody was home and they would not answer the door and it was cold outside.” The defendant walked to a nearby Jewel food store where she bought the butcher knife that she later used to kill James. She sat on the steps with her two-year-old daughter Mercedes until Yvette let her in. She again said that she was “mad at this point because of the runaround [she] was getting.” After she entered the house she had a conversation with James while he was sitting on a couch with his feet up on a table. When she got up to leave, James was still sitting on the couch drinking tea. She started to leave, but then “something went click because [she] was so mad”; she reached into her bag, pulled out the knife and started stabbing James. She did not remember how many times she stabbed him. James did not have anything in his hands but a cup of tea.
James died from two stab wounds and five cutting wounds. The stab wounds were to his chest and shoulder, and the cutting wounds were to his left chest, left arm, left hand and left ankle.
The defendant was a high school graduate and was employed as a data processor. She testified that during her relationship with James he provided some financial support for Mercedes and visited her often. In spring of 1984 she filed a paternity suit seeking child support from James. Even after she filed the suit James continued to visit her and Mercedes. In September of 1985 she filed a lien on James’ house but she did not tell James that she had filed the lien. He continued to visit her, and he was cordial during the visits. She moved to Milwaukee because
On December 15 she took the bus to Chicago with her daughter and arrived at James’ house in the morning. Nobody answered the bell. She thought she saw someone looking out the first-floor window and again rang the doorbell but no one answered. She walked to a pay phone and called James. Yvette answered and told her that James was not at home and that she did not know when he would be home. The defendant then went to Jewel food store where she bought a butcher knife and some other things and returned to James’ home. She bought the knife because she was “scared” of James. She said that “it was a combination of things, going to the house and seeing somebody peek out of the window and not answer the door.”
She again rang the doorbell, and Yvette answered. Yvette told her that James was not at home, and the defendant said she would wait on the porch. Eventually, Yvette opened the door and let her in. She sat and talked with James in the living room of his apartment. They discussed the lien, among other things, and began to argue. She decided to leave. When she asked who Yvette was, James said Yvette was his “old lady.” She then made a sarcastic remark about Yvette, and James threw a cup of tea in her face while he was sitting on the couch. As a result her vision became blurred when her soft contact lenses absorbed the fluid. She hit James in the face with the baby’s bag. James then called to Yvette to “come get this bitch.” She saw people running down the hallway. She then took her knife out of her bag, unwrapped the plastic wrapping and started stabbing James. James had never struck her or pushed her at any time, and she saw nothing in his hand at the time of the stabbing other than the cup of tea.
It is our judgment that the State’s case against the defendant was overwhelming. The undisputed evidence discloses that there was a dispute between the defendant and James about support payments for the child; that she left Milwaukee to come to James’ home and that she bought a butcher knife. Three witnesses testified that they heard James cry out for help; he said that the defendant was trying to kill him. James was stabbed twice and cut five times, once in the ankle. Witnesses saw her withdrawing the knife from James’ arm; she had already stabbed him in the chest. One witness actually saw her strike James across the chest and then plunge the knife into his arm. In her statement she admitted that she was mad when she entered the apartment
The defendant next contends that the court erred in denying her motion to suppress the statement she made to the assistant State’s Attorney. At the hearing on the motion to suppress, Officer James O’Marrah testified that he gave the defendant Miranda warnings when he arrested her around 12:15 p.m. She said that she understood. She did not respond when he asked what had happened. He noticed bloodstains on her hand, but he did not see any cuts. The police decided to let Mercedes remain in the custody of relatives of James.
Officer McCann and Assistant State’s Attorney Giróte also testified on the motion to suppress. McCann questioned the defendant at about 3 p.m. He also advised the defendant of her rights; she said she understood and agreed to answer questions. The questioning session lasted about 20 minutes during which time technicians from the crime detection laboratory took photographs of her and samples of the blood which were still on her hands. He observed scratches on her hands and asked if she wanted medical treatment. She said that it was not necessary at that time. At the conclusion of the questioning and after the crime detection laboratory technicians were finished, the defendant was allowed to wash her hands at about 3:30 p.m. He was present when the defendant was questioned by Assistant State’s Attorney Giróte at 5:50 p.m. that same day. She made no complaints at any time. She was calm, coherent, never asked for an attorney and did not refuse to talk. After the statement she made to Giróte, she was allowed to telephone her mother at about 7 p.m. and was taken to a hospital for medical treatment. She did not receive any food while at the police station.
Assistant State’s Attorney Giróte first spoke with McCann after arriving at the station and then questioned the defendant in the presence of McCann and his partner. Giróte read the defendant her Miranda rights; she stated that she understood them and agreed to talk
The defendant testified that she did not remember if the police read her rights when she was arrested. She asked if she could take her child but was refused, and she asked for an attorney. At the police station she asked if she could use the bathroom and make a phone call. She was not given any food and her hands were cut and bleeding. She was taken to another police station; she asked the detectives about her child and if she could use the telephone and bathroom. They told her she could not do so at that time. She also told them that she wanted an attorney and that she did not want to make a statement. The detectives left the room for short periods on several occasions and then returned to ask her again to make a statement. She finally agreed to answer questions when she realized that she would only be allowed to use the telephone and bathroom and to find out about her child after she cooperated with them. After talking to the detectives, arrangements were made for her child to be picked up; after signing the statement, she was allowed to call her mother and was taken to a hospital. She said she gave a statement only because the police kept coming into the interviewing room and asking her to do so and because she was worried about her daughter. She said that she told the police the truth; she denied giving the statement that Giróte identified.
At the time he denied the motion to suppress, the judge said that the issue was essentially that of credibility of the witnesses and that he was resolving the conflict in testimony in favor of the police officers and the assistant State’s Attorney. He specifically found that the defendant was given the Miranda warnings during the ride to the police station; that she was allowed to place a telephone call before she gave the statement; and that she was allowed to use the washroom at approximately 3:30 p.m., which was before she gave the statements. The judge concluded that under the totality of the circumstances he found that the statement was freely and voluntarily given and that the defendant knowingly and intelligently waived her right to remain silent and her right to an attorney.
The defendant’s argument is twofold: first, she maintains that her silence after receiving Miranda warnings for the first time amounted to an assertion of her right to remain silent and that that
The defendant’s second argument is that the totality of the circumstances necessarily leads to the conclusion that the statement was not voluntarily made by the defendant. On this point, she makes the threshold argument that we should ignore the previous pronouncements of the Illinois Supreme Court that the trial court’s finding of voluntariness of a statement will not be reversed unless it is against the manifest weight of the evidence. (See People v. Prim (1972), 53 Ill. 2d 62, 289 N.E.2d 601.) She maintains that the rule of the Illinois Supreme Court is in direct contradiction to Federal law and that we should subject the evidence to a de novo review. This precise argument had been made and rejected in People v. Abernathy (1989), 189 Ill. App. 3d 292, 545 N.E.2d 201, and People v. Fisher (1988), 169 Ill. App. 3d 915, 523 N.E.2d 1119. As an intermediate court of review we are bound to follow the law as enunciated by our supreme court, which has spoken in People v. Clark (1986), 114 Ill. 2d 450, 501 N.E.2d 123, and has reaffirmed the rule of Prim that the trial court’s finding that a statement was voluntary will not be disturbed unless the finding is contrary to the manifest weight of the evidence.
We need not repeat the testimony of the witnesses, including the defendant, who testified on the motion to suppress. It is enough to say that we agree with the trial judge that the issue centered on the credibility of the witnesses. The defendant’s testimony that she asked for a lawyer, that she was denied the use of the washroom or the telephone and that she was denied medical treatment was contradicted by the testimony of other witnesses. We cannot say that the trial judge was unjustified in relying on the testimony of the State’s witnesses. In turn, we cannot say that his decision determining that the statements were made voluntarily was against the manifest weight of the evidence.
The defendant next contends that the judge erred in denying her motion to discharge the jury venire because of remarks made by a
“Ladies and gentlemen, you just heard the last juror mention concerning the murder of his uncle in New Jersey, the sentence, etc. The laws of New Jersey are substantially different than they are in Illinois.
And secondarily, I would remind you that you are not to concern yourselves with the sentencing. Your total responsibility is to determine whether or not the State has proven any or all of these counts or charges, if you will, against the defendant beyond a reasonable doubt.
If you do, it is your responsibility to sign a verdict of guilty. If you find that the State had not proven the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt of any or all of these charges, as to those charges so found, it is your responsibility to sign a verdict of not guilty. Any sentencing, in the event there is a finding of guilty, will be the responsibility of the court pursuant to statute outside your presence in these proceedings.
Would the statements of the last juror affect any of your ability to be fair and impartial? Any one at all? No one.”
The defendant does not cite any case in support of her argument. We doubt that one exists that would justify a reversal of conviction on this ground. We believe the judge acted promptly and correctly and exercised his discretion soundly.
The defendant next maintains that the jury was erroneously instructed on the offense of voluntary manslaughter. The State agrees that the jury was erroneously instructed based on the holding of the supreme court in People v. Reddick (1988), 123 Ill. 2d 184, 526 N.E.2d 141. The State maintains, however, that Reddick should be given only prospective application. In People v. Brooks (1988), 175 Ill. App. 3d 136, 529 N.E.2d 732, the First District Appellate Court held that Reddick is to be applied retrospectively. The
Other cases decided after Reddick have held that the instruction constituted harmless error. (See People v. Nunn (1989), 184 Ill. App. 3d 253, 541 N.E.2d 182; People v. Carter (1988), 177 Ill. App. 3d 593, 532 N.E.2d 531. Cf. People v. Skipper (1988), 177 Ill. App. 3d 684, 533 N.E.2d 44 (improper instruction on elements of aggravated battery held to be harmless error in view of the quantum of proof).) In People v. Fierer (1988), 124 Ill. 2d 176, 529 N.E.2d 972, the court held that, in order for an alleged error in instructions to be considered harmless, it must be demonstrated that the result of a trial would not have been different if the proper instruction had been given. (124 Ill. 2d at 187.) In our judgment the erroneous instruction constituted harmless error.
We need not repeat our discussion of the evidence in response to the defendant’s argument that the evidence was insufficient to convict. We will repeat our observation that the evidence was overwhelming. It has been demonstrated to us that the jury verdict would not have been different if a proper instruction had been given. Indeed, we have serious doubts that the evidence supported the giving of the voluntary manslaughter instructions, which were given over the State’s objection. Cf. People v. Everette (1990), 141 Ill. 2d 147 (evidence insufficient to support the giving of a self-defense instruction).
Before the defendant testified, the State made an oral motion in limine that she be barred from establishing any conversation she had with James unless the defense could “show some exception to hearsay.” Colloquy ensued during which the defense did not specify the contents of the conversations it would seek to introduce. The judge recognized
“At this point all I can suggest is I do not know what her testimony is going to be. We may have to have numerous side bars then because I cannot make a ruling at this point. My reasonable cut-off will be the three-hour conversation and thereafter. If you attempt to introduce anything therein after you have laid your foundation, I will be glad to take a look at it.”
The defendant now contends that statements made to her by James were admissible for the purpose of showing her state of mind and that the judge erred in restricting her proof. It is the general rule that a defendant claiming self-defense in response to homicide charges may show specific acts of violence and threats by the deceased. Such evidence is admissible to show the circumstances confronting the defendant, the extent of his apparent danger, and the motive by which he is influenced. (People v. Hoddenbach (1983), 116 Ill. App. 3d 57, 452 N.E.2d 32.) Assuming that the defendant had established self-defense, exclusion of testimony of threats made by the deceased would be error; and we believe restricting proof of threats, otherwise admissible and not cumulative, .to the three-day period before the stabbing would be an abuse of discretion. But we believe no error occurred because the defendant was able to establish proof of all threats she wished to introduce. We, therefore, need not decide whether the defendant presented even slight evidence of self-defense.
During her direct examination her testimony was restricted to a certain degree, but during cross-examination she was asked about the telephone conversation she had with James three days before the stabbing and the threats he made to her at that time. She said that was not the first time he said he would kill her if she touched his house. She also said she was afraid because of the threats he had made in the past. On redirect the following occurred:
“[DEFENSE ATTORNEY]: [The assistant State’s Attorney] asked you about threats that James Bankston made. Did these threats occur after the non-support case was filed?
A. Yes.
Q. These threats would occur when you would see him?
A. Or talk to him on the phone.
Q. What was the nature of these threats?
A. Just that, you know, he wanted me to drop the lawsuit and I wouldn’t and to just leave him alone about the money and not to file a lien against the house and that if I didn’t that he would make my life miserable, that the house was just about the only thing he had, and if I made him lose it, he would kill me. He would make me regret that I ever met him. Just the same.
Q. Do you have more to sayl
A. No.” (Emphasis added.)
We judge, therefore, that the court’s in limine ruling in no way prejudiced the defendant.
The defendant next contends that prejudicial error occurred during the State’s closing argument. The defendant did not object to the remarks during the trial and the generalized statement in the post-trial motion that the defendant was “denied a fair trial by the State’s closing and rebuttal arguments” was insufficient to preserve the remarks for review. (People v. Camp (1984), 128 Ill. App. 3d 223, 470 N.E.2d 540.) The defendant has therefore waived the issue. (People v. Enoch (1988), 122 Ill. 2d 176, 522 N.E.2d 1124.) Even if we were to assume that the question had been properly preserved, we hold that no prejudicial error occurred.
The prosecutor said that if a man was on trial the jury would not condone a man doing the acts that the defendant did and would not hesitate to sign a guilty verdict. That argument should not have been made, but, considering the quantum of the evidence against the defendant, its effect was harmless. At another point, the State’s Attorney said the following:
“Well, I suggest to you she got up there and told a story of lies. You can’t coach lies. Only the truth comes through. You can’t coach lies. It was a mass of contradictions.”
The defendant argues that that argument was a suggestion that the defendant’s attorney was engaging in trickery or other improper conduct. We have examined the entire argument of the prosecutor and conclude that it was an isolated passage which, when considering the entire argument, is susceptible of a meaning other than that suggested by the defendant. Consequently, we find no error. See People v. Phillips (1989), 127 Ill. 2d 499, 538 N.E.2d 500.
The defendant last contends that the victim-impact statements were improperly admitted. The defendant concedes that the recent supreme court decision in People v. Felella (1989), 131 Ill. 2d 525,
For these reasons, the judgment of the circuit court is affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.
McNAMARA and RAKOWSKI, JJ., concur.