People v. ElliottPeople v. Elliott
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Cartwright
delivered the opinion of the court:
Michael Elliott and Otho Jennings, plaintiffs in error, and James Howe and Richard Smith, were indicted in the circuit court of Macon county for selling intoxicating liquor in the town of Decatur, alleged to be anti-saloon territory. There were seventy-one counts in the indictment, the first seventy being for the unlawful sale of intoxicating liquor and the seventy-first for keeping a place where intoxicating liquor was unlawfully sold. James Howe and Richard Smith were not apprehended, but Michael Elliott and Otho Jennings, the plaintiffs in error, were tried and found guilty on each of the seventy-one counts. Judgment was entered by the court on the verdict, sentencing each of the plaintiffs in error to pay a fine and to imprisonment in the county jail under each count. The record was removed to the Appellate Court for the Third District by a writ of error, and the judgment having been affirmed, the record has been brought to this court by writ óf error.
Taking up the questions raised by counsel for plaintiffs in error, not in the order of their argument but in the order of the events occurring on the trial, the first alleged error to be noticed is that there was no proper proof that the-town of Decatur was anti-saloon territory. A witness testified that he was town clerk of the town of Decatur; that he had
The next alleged error is that the venue was not proved. On that question the abstract shows the testimony of a witness who said that he knew the defendant Michael Elliott and his place of business at No. 245 East Main street, and as to its location he testified as follows: “It is in the town of Decatur, county of Macon, State of Illinois.” All the testimony related to sales by defendants and their bartenders in that place of business. The venue was proved.
It is alleged that the court made several erroneous rulings in the introduction of evidence. A witness whose place of business was near the premises of the defendants testified that, with the exception of two or three weeks when Elliott was away, there was hardly a day when there were not twenty or thirty cases of beer hauled to the back door of the defendants’ place of business and taken inside. During
In the argument counsel denounce the trial as a farce and criticise the trial judge as partial and unfair. Counsel have a right to make any fair criticism of a judge concerning matters shown by the record but they have no right to make unjust accusations not borne out by the record and when made they do not tend to advance the cause which they are intended to serve. The rulings on the trial were fair and impartial. A fair sample of matter complained of is, that when the counsel for the defendants made an offer of proof the judge suggested to him that the proper way was to ask questions and let the court rule on them. The court was right.
It is urged that the court erred in giving instructions to the jury, and the material objection is that the instructions stated the statutes relating to the sale of intoxicating liquors, including the giving away or delivering liquor or other shift or device for the purpose of evading the law, sales by .a clerk or servant, and the provision of the Criminal Code as to accessories. The objection is that many of these provisions were not applicable to any evidence. The defendants had bar-tenders who made sales as clerks or servants of the defendants. One witness called for ginger ale and was served with whisky, (which is a favorite shift or device,) and one witness who did not buy liquor but helped to unload liquor was given a glass of whisky in exchange for his labor. The instructions were applicable to the case and stated the law in the language of the statutes. There was no error in ruling on the instructions.
It is contended that the evidence did not support the verdict, but that is not so. The evidence introduced by the People was uncontradicted. The defendants occupied premises at No. 245 East Main street, in the city of Decatur. Near the front of the room there was a cigar case, back of
It is argued that the punishment inflicted upon the defendants was cruel, unusual and excessive, in violation of the constitution of the State of Illinois and the constitution of the United States.— The constitution of the United States provides that excessive bail shall not be required nor excessive fines imposed nor cruel nor unusual punishments inflicted. But that‘provision does not apply to legislation by the States. It is restricted exclusively to the Federal government, its courts and officers. (Barron v. Baltimore, 7 Pet. 243; Spies v. Illinois, 123 U. S. 166; In re Kemmler,
If the, punishment prescribed by the legislature for the illegal sale of liquor is not proportionate to the offense the law itself is void because prohibited by the bill of rights and no punishment at all can be inflicted for the offense. In such a case the vice is in the law itself, and the law being void, the sentence cannot be modified on appeal so as to remove the objection or make the law valid. (Weems v. United States, 217 U. S. 349; 19 Ann. Cas. 705.) In view of the decisions of other courts, and especially of the decisions of this court in City of Arcola v. Wilkinson, supra, that a penalty of $200 for each unlawful sale is not disproportionate to the nature of that offense, and in People v. Illinois State Reformatory, supra, that a sentence for the maximum term of imprisonment for any offense is not disproportionate to the nature of the offense, it is clear that the statute under which the defendants were sentenced does not infringe the constitutional provision. The statute prescribing a penalty for unlawful sales of liquor is valid, and the validity of the sentences is not affected by the fact that there were numerous violations and cumulative penalties. The statute being valid and the sentences within its terms, the judgment cannot be reversed on the ground that this court would have imposed less severe sentences, but we regard the sentences as unnecessarily severe for the accomplishment of the purposes of the law.
So far as the fines are concerned, the sentences were correct under the rule of Borschenious v. People, supra, where it was held that such a judgment is a several judgment upon each
The judgments of the Appellate Court and circuit court are reversed and the cause is remanded to the circuit court, with leave to the State’s attorney to move for, and direction to the court to enter, a judgment in accordance with the rule established by this court as above stated.
Reversed and remanded, with directions.