PEOPLE v. MALLORY.
Supreme Court of Michigan
January 4, 1967
378 Mich. 538
This is settled law. It is not settled law in my view that the same obligation is imposed where the conviction is for a petty offense as defined in the Federal criminal justice act.
I would affirm the trial judge.
BRENNAN, J., took no part in the decision of this case.
PEOPLE v. COPELAND.
No. 51,213
Supreme Court of Michigan
January 4, 1967
378 Mich. 611
Calendar No. 4. Submitted April 6, 1966.
Appeal by leave granted from Court of Appeals, Division 1; Lesinski, C. J., and J. H. Gillis and Watts, JJ., order denying leave to appeal from an order of Recorder‘s Court for the City of Detroit; Schemanske (Frank G.), J., of November 2, 1964, denying defendant appellate counsel and transcript.
Larry Tyrone Copeland was convicted of assault and battery. Reversed.
Frank J. Kelley, Attorney General, Robert A. Derengoski, Solicitor General, Samuel H. Olsen, Prosecuting Attorney, Samuel J. Torina, Chief Appellate Lawyer, and James E. Lacey, Assistant Prosecuting Attorney, for the people.
Goodman, Crockett, Eden, Robb & Philo (Rolland R. O‘Hare and Sheldon M. Meizlish, of counsel), for defendant.
KELLY, J. Defendant was convicted of assault and battery by recorder‘s court Judge Hon. Frank G. Schemanske and sentenced to 90 days in the Detroit House of Correction. He was not represented by counsel.
At the conclusion of the 90-day sentence defendant was returned to prison. The chairman of the Michigan department of corrections parole board explains his return as follows:
“He served his term at the Detroit house of correction, was returned to prison and found to be automatically guilty of violating his parole by reason of his conviction.”
This is a companion case to People v. Mallory, 378 Mich 538, and the reasons set forth in my concurring opinion for reversal in that case apply to the present case.
Reversed and remanded to recorder‘s court for appointment, upon finding of indigency, of appellate counsel for defendant and furnishing of all portions of the transcript and record essential in preparation of postconviction motions and appeal.
T. M. KAVANAGH, C. J., concurred with KELLY, J.
DETHMERS, J., concurred in result for reasons stated in his opinion in People v. Mallory, 378 Mich 538, 548.
ADAMS, J., (concurring in result). I concur in reversal and remand in accordance with the last paragraph of Justice KELLY‘S opinion.
T. M. KAVANAGH, C. J., concurred with SOURIS, J.
BLACK, J. (dissenting). I would affirm. See separate opinion of People v. Mallory, 378 Mich 538, 582.
O‘HARA, J. (dissenting.) I would affirm. See separate opinion of People v. Mallory, 378 Mich 538, 607.
BRENNAN, J., took no part in the decision of this case.