People v. ColemanPeople v. Coleman
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Dethmers
Defendant appeals from conviction on an information charging that he engaged, without being licensed so to do under the provisions of PA 1939, No 21, as amended (CL 1948, § 493.1 et seq. [Stat Ann 1943 Rev and Stat Ann 1951 Cum Supp § 23.667(1) et serp]), in the small loan business and charged on the loans a greater rate of interest or consideration therefor than permitted by law to be charged by nonlicensees (7% per annum, as fixed by CL 1948, § 438.51 [Stat Ann § 19.11]).
During the period in question defendant made numerous loans of $10, $15, and other small sums less than $500, on condition that the borrower purchase certain merchandise from him, particularly a bottle containing 90 vitamin capsules, for $10 plus
Defendant says, first, that the above facts fail to establish that he charged interest on the loans in excess of 7% per annum; that he had a right to make loans to customers only. .Doubtless he had the right to restrict the granting of loans to those who had been or then were his customers. To view his operations as amounting to nothing more than that is to deny the facts their full import. Loans were not conditioned merely on the borrower being a customer, but on his making a specified purchase in connection with the loan transaction. The sale of vitamins to those who had no desire for them as a condition to receiving a loan was clearly a device designed to accomplish precisely one object; namely, the securing by defendant of a higher consideration for the loan than permitted by law to a nonlicensee. It was clearly a sham to evade the law.
Next, defendant says that essential to conviction is proof (1) that defendant intended usury and (2) that the borrower knew of the disparity between the value of the vitamins and the price he was charged therefor and, hence, that he shared with defendant
Affirmed.
Adams, Butzel, Carr, Bushnell, Sharpe, Boyles, and Reid, JJ., concurred