People v. BattestPeople v. Battest
- Reporters:
- , ,
Judgment unanimously affirmed. Memorandum: Defendant was convicted of assault in the second degree, resisting arrest, criminal mischief in the fourth degree, and attempted petit larceny. The latter two charges were based on defendant’s conduct in cutting a window screen and attempting to remove a radio from an inner windowsill. *959The first two counts stem from defendant’s conduct in repeatedly striking a police officer who was attempting to arrest defendant immediately following the property crime. Defendant’s primary contention on appeal is that the evidence is insufficient to support his convictions for second degree assault and resisting arrest because the arrest was unlawful. Defendant also contends that the court’s charge on resisting arrest was improper.
Since defendant’s challenge to the legality of his arrest goes to the sufficiency of the evidence, the issue must be determined on the trial evidence rather than, as urged by defendant, the evidence adduced at the suppression hearing. At trial, the People established that there was probable cause to arrest defendant from the outset of the encounter. The arresting officer was flagged down by a citizen who told him that two men had broken into her cousin’s house and attempted to steal a radio. She pointed out defendant, who was walking nearby and has a distinctive appearance, as one of the men. The reliability of an identifiable citizen is inherent and presumed (People v Hicks, 38 NY2d 90, 92-94; People v Cruz, 149 AD2d 151, 158; People v LeGrand, 142 AD2d 977, lv denied 73 NY2d 893; People v Cantre, 95 AD2d 522, 526, affd 65 NY2d 790). Her firsthand knowledge is implicit in the details of her report, given her obvious familiarity with the incident and her ability to point out defendant as one of the suspects. Thus, the officer properly acted on the information in confronting defendant.
Defendant also contends that his arrest was illegal because the officer did not inform defendant of “his authority and purpose and of the reason for such arrest”, pursuant to
In view of our conclusion that compliance with