People v. AllenPeople v. Allen
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Holbrook
On January 12, 1972, defendant was convicted by a jury of breaking and entering a house trailer with intent to commit larceny,
At the sentencing the defendant vehemently asserted his innocence and in response the trial court stated:
’’The Court: Well, part of our problem, Louis, is that the jury heard the testimony, and the jury found you guilty—
’’Defendant: But the—
’’The Court: —frankly, and Mr. Elmore went up and took a polygraph test and he stated in the polygraph test you were the one that went in the trailer, and you were the one that went in and beat up the old man and the polygraph operator said he’s telling the truth.
’’Defendant: That’s the polygraph operator. That man ain’t — if I come in with a pistol, Judge, and beat you up, you wouldn’t mistake me for that man. * * *
” — or nothing. Now, you done told me that this Bob Elmore took a polygraph test, and they — and you all going by this polygraph test.
’’The Court: I’m not going by the polygraph test.
’’Defendant: Could you please tell me what kind of— what evidence do — can you all show me what you all sending me to the penitentiary on?
“The Court: Well, what you are being sentenced on, Louis, is the—
“Defendant: Anything—
“The Court: —verdict of the jury.
“Defendant: The verdict of the jury?
“The Court: That’s right. Now—
“Defendant: Because Linda Sue is white. I’m a black man. That’s why they took her word. How can they take her word more better than mine and the woman be arrested for perjury in the courtroom, but my word is still not as good as hers? How — what else can it be, man, but a—
“The Court: Well—
“Defendant: Can’t be right. * * *
“The Court: Louis, let me ask you this question, and this is something the court’s got no business asking you. Are you willing to take a polygraph test?
“Defendant: For what?
“The Court: All right, I just asked.
“Defendant: Well, will it be — it help me?
“The Court: You just answer the question yes or no. “Defendant: Tell me how it can help me.
“The Court: You just answer the question yes or no. “Defendant: No, I ain’t taking nothin’.”
A motion for a new trial was placed on file before the sentencing, but apparently because the defendant wanted a new attorney it was not heard. On October 30, 1972, a hearing was held on defendant’s renewed motion for a new trial and resentencing. A motion was also made that a judge other than the trial judge hear the motions, because the trial judge was prejudiced by his knowledge of Robert Elmore’s polygraph test. All motions were denied. Defendant now appeals.
It has been a longstanding unequivocal rule in this state that the results of lie detector tests or reference to them are inadmissible at trial.
People v Frechette,
380 Mich 64; 155 NW2d 830 (1968);
As for the propriety of another person’s, in this case defendant’s alleged accomplice’s, lie detector test becoming part of defendant’s presentence report, the issue is apparently a novel one in this jurisdiction. The statute authorizing the taking of presentence reports states that the probation officer shall only inquire into the “antecedents, character and circumstances of such person or persons”.
Because of our disposition of this case, we need not discuss the other issues defendant raises on appeal. Remanded for proceedings consistent with this opinion. We do not reserve further jurisdiction.
All concurred.