People v. AdamsPeople v. Adams
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Duncan
delivered the opinion of the court:
Plaintiff in error was convicted in the criminal court of Cook county upon the third count of an indictment charging him with manslaughter. The jury in their verdict recommended the minimum penalty. Motions for a new trial and in arrest of judgment were overruled, and plaintiff in error was sentenced on the verdict. He has sued put this writ of error to reverse the judgment.
The indictment charged plaintiff in error with having - killed Helen O’Connell on December 2, igiy, in the county of’ Cook and State of Illinois. The first count charged manslaughter in the ordinary form, with an automobile- as the instrument. The second count charged the killing by the operation of the automobile at a dangerous and excessive
Plaintiff in error was twenty-nine years old at the time of the killing and was running a garage at 1524 Taylor street, Chicago. He was the owner of the closed limousine driven by him on said day, in which he was conveying passengers between 2 :oo and 2 :3o o’clock P. M. eastward on Twelfth street. He stopped .his car at the west line of Ashland boulevard - where it crosses Twelfth street. On the west side of Ashland boulevard Twelfth street is very much wider than it is„ on the east side of Ashland boulevard. The street car tracks on Twelfth street west of Ashland boulevard are near the north and south curbs, and vehicle traffic there runs between the east-bound street car track on the south side and the west-bound track on the north side. As the car tracks approach the center of Ashland boulevard they both curve abruptly toward the center of the crossing, so that
It does not definitely appear whether the deceased was, at the moment she was struck by the machine, moving from the south side of Twelfth street in front of the street car to the north side of Twelfth street with a view of taking a street car west-bound on Twelfth street, or whether she had already gotten to the point where west-bound cars are taken. It does definitely appear, from the physical facts, that she was struck by the automobile on the north side of the Twelfth street car track, because the automobile was headed southeast when it struck the woman and her small son, who was with her. The boy was driven onto the east-bound track in front of the street car, which stopped within a foot of the boy while he was lying on the track. The woman’s body was driven close to the eastbound car on its blind or north side, and her body was lying on that side of the car, just east of the front wheels. There was a stipulation in the record or an admission by the plaintiff in error that the woman had left her home and was going to visit her neighbor, “and that she was about to take a west-bound car, as soon as one arrived, to go to her destination.” This would indicate that she was at the place where such a car could be taken, from thirty to fifty feet east of the east line of Ashland boulevard and on the north side of the east-bound track. The conductor of the street car testified positively that people had been passing in front of
We do not desire to discuss the merits of the case further than to say that plaintiff in error’s own testimony can not be clear or satisfactory because of the fact that he testified to conclusions rather than to the actual facts, and his positions at various times cannot be located from his testimony in the record because he testified to them by pointing to a chart which is not in evidence. He testified to no facts showing why he could not have stopped on the north side of Twelfth street, — at least after he passed Ashland boulevard, — and let the street car pass on and cross in the rear of it instead of in front of it. Had the witnesses been confined to the actual facts, instead of testifying to conclusions as to what he could or could not have done with safety, ‘the merits of the case would readily appear in evidence. On another trial this should be done.
Plaintiff in error makes the claim that the indictment is insufficient (i) because it contains allegations of willful and culpable negligence; and (2) because it fails to set out facts charging the crime of manslaughter. Manslaughter is defined by our statute to be the unlawful killing of a human being without malice, express or implied, and without any mixture of deliberation whatever. The intent to kill, or malice, is not a necessary ingredient at all in manslaughter. While it is not necessary to charge malice or intent, yet it is well known that a party charged with murder may be convicted of manslaughter under such a charge, for the sensible reason that the charge of manslaughter is necessarily included in the charge of murder. It is common in Illinois for indictments for manslaughter to charge that the defendant unlawfully, feloniously and willfully did the thing or the act that caused the death of the deceased. Under the law in this State the objection to this indictment cannot be sustained, and the court did not err in overruling the
Involuntary manslaughter, as defined in our statute, consists in the-.killing of a human being without any intent to do so, in the commission of an unlawful act, or a lawful act which probably might produce such a consequence in an unlawful manner. It is difficult to see how the offense could be more clearly defined, and the distinction between murder and manslaughter is as clearly made by our statute as it can be in words. Involuntary manslaughter is charged in this case, and the negligent act charged is the driving of the automobile against the deceased by reason of plaintiff In error’s culpable negligence in failing to keep a proper lookout for people at that point, where he knew they were customarily to be found congregated. In fact, plaintiff in error stated that he knew that people took the west-bound car on Twelfth street at about the point where he struck the deceased, and at the time that‘he struck her he was partly on the west-bound street car track and partly on the street with his automobile. The real question in the case is whether he was guilty of culpable or criminal negligence. That was a question of fact for the jury, and they should have been directed to pass upon that fact under instructions free from error or misleading statements as to the law. The fourth instruction for the People given by the court directs the jury, in substance, that every person who drives upon the public highway is under a legal duty to observe, in the control and management of his vehicle, the exercise of reasonable care to prevent injury to others. This is the law, but the instruction “goes farther and states that every person is criminally responsible. for the neglect or willful failure to per- ’ form that duty. It is not the law that a person is criminally responsible for every act of mere negligence that causes the death of another. Negligence, to be criminal, mu.st be gross or wanton negligence. Gross negligence is negligence that borders onto recklessness, and wanton negligence, as applied to’ the running
The State’s attorney also made prejudicial remarks to the jury, wherein he stated, in substance, that they should consider what they had read in the newspapers concerning the recklessness of chauffeurs in general, and also consider what had been their own observations of chauffeurs who drive machines for hire, as to whether or not they were negligent or careful. The jury were not warranted in considering what newspapers may have said or their own observations of chauffeurs in general in deciding the guilt or innocence of the plaintiff in error. There is no principle in the law more strictly adhered to in this class of cases than that a defendant should be tried on his own conduct as determined by the evidence itself.
The complaint that the court refused to give certain instructions for plaintiff in error cannot be considered as a matter affecting the validity of the court’s judgment, as the abstract does not show that the instructions given for the People and for plaintiff in error are all the instructions that were given on the trial. And for the same reason the question could not arise in this case as to whether or not there is sufficient evidence in the record to support the judgment, as the record does not recite that the evidence therein
For the errors above noted the judgment of the criminal court is reversed and the cause is remanded.
Reversed and remanded.