People Ex Rel. Mark v. TomanPeople Ex Rel. Mark v. Toman
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Jones
delivered the opinion of the court:
In the criminal court of Cook county an order was entered in a habeas corpus proceeding discharging Ralph Mark, who was convicted of the crime of bigamy in the State of New York and afterwards released on parole. The provisions of his release required him to proceed from the Great Meadow prison to Buffalo and there report within twenty-four hours to H. C. Dupree, case supervisor.
We held in People v. Smith, 352 Ill. 496, that a parole violator may be the subject of extradition when he departs from the State of his conviction without permission of its authorities. He becomes a fugitive from justice and may be returned to his State to serve out his unexpired term of imprisonment. It is not technically correct to say that he has been returned because of parole violation. He is returned because, he has not served his full term of
We think the contention that the affidavit is chiefly a statement of the affiant’s conclusions as to what the records in New York disclose is not well founded. The affiant swore he was the custodian of the records, and as to the matters which he stated were contained in them we see no objection. The affidavit contains an unequivocal statement of fact that Mark, “after his release on parole, did fail to keep the terms of his parole in that he failed to report to H. C. Dupree, case supervisor, and * * * in that he left the State of New York without written permission.” A fair construction of the instrument does not support the contention that those statements were not made upon affiant’s own knowledge or that they were mere conclusions from record recitals.
The duty of determining whether the relator was substantially charged with crime and was a fugitive from justice rested upon the Governor of Illinois in the first instance. If the requisition papers presented to him were properly authenticated and contained enough information to satisfy him they were sufficient. He was not obliged to demand proof outside those papers. (Pettibone v. Nichols, 203 U. S. 192, 51 L. ed. 148.) Any mode of proof satisfactory in kind and convincing in effect and having a reasonable tendency to establish the fact of flight from justice fulfills the requirement of the law. (11 R. C. L. p. 733.) Strict common law evidence is not necessary. A mere statement that the demanded person is a fugitive has been held enough upon which to base a warrant, and its issuance, with
The remaining contention is that the discharge in the first proceeding was res ad judicata. The rules which may generally be invoked as to hearings on habeas corpus are not always applicable in extradition proceedings. When it is sought to avail of the writ of habeas corpus to discharge one in custody on the ground that he is unlawfully held the hearing may extend to the merits of the case, but in extradition proceedings, if the papers have been properly authenticated, they make a prima facie case in favor of the demanding State. (Pettibone v. Nichols, supra.) In the present case there is no question about the proper authentication. The relator was present but did not testify. He made no effort to overcome the prima facie case made by the requisition papers. The only proof offered by him was of his former discharge. That discharge was based on what the criminal court thought were insufficient requisition papers. The release of a person on the ground of informality or mistakes in the proceedings should not be a bar to an arrest on perfected papers or regular proceedings, and if
We are of the view that the criminal court of Cook county was in error in discharging the relator.. Its order in so doing is reversed and the cause is remanded, with directions to enter an order remanding the relator to the proper agent of the State of New York.
Reversed and remanded, with directions.