Penfield v. VenutiPenfield v. Venuti
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Cabranes
RULING ON PENDING MOTIONS AND OBJECTIONS
JOSÉ A. CABRANES, District Judge:INTRODUCTION
This motion requires the court to construe the Connecticut criminal records erasure law,
Plaintiff, a citizen of Massachusetts, has brought this action against two Connecticut citizens under the court’s diversity jurisdiction.
I.
The record of a substantially identical state civil action, to which the parties have directed the court’s attention, reveals that defendant Joseph Venuti apparently was arrested on June 12, 1979 by officers of the Middletown Police Department and “charged with certain criminal and motor vehicle offenses stemming from the incident which is the subject of the [state lawsuit and this federal action],” Penfield v. Venuti, No. 30597, slip op. at 1 (Conn.Super. Ct., Middlesex Judicial Dist., May 12, 1981). These charges “were dismissed in the criminal division of the Middletown Superior Court.” Id. In the civil action pending in the state court, Joseph Venuti objected to “any questions [addressed to him in interrogatories and at depositions] . . . concerning his knowledge of the incident derived from the police investigation.” Id. at 2 (emphasis added). He objected also to questions “regarding facts [he] might have learned from third party sources, either his attorney, the attorney’s investigator, or police sources,” and refused to answer questions on those grounds. Id.
The objections of defendants in this action are substantially identical. See Memorandum of Law in Support of Defendants’ Motion to Quash and Motion for Protective Order (“Defendants’ Memorandum”) (filed Sept. 25,1981) and Supplemental Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion for Protective Order and Objections to Interrogatories and Production Requests (“Defendants’ Supplemental Memorandum”) (filed Oct. 26, 1981). Defendants object also to plaintiff’s attempt to take the depositions of the police officers whose investigation of the accident resulted in the filing of criminal charges against Joseph Venuti and to plaintiff’s request for the production of the physical evidence gathered at the scene of the accident that is now contained in police files. Defendants’ Memorandum; Defendants’ Supplemental Memorandum; see *366Memorandum in Opposition to Motion for Protective Order and Motion to Stay (“Plaintiff’s Memorandum”) (filed Oct. 2, 1981).
Defendants base their claim for a protective order on C.G.S.
Plaintiff responds to defendants’ request for a protective order by arguing that he is “only asking for physical evidence,” Plaintiff’s Memorandum at 2, and that if this evidence is placed beyond his reach by the Connecticut criminal records erasure statute, that statute is unconstitutional and therefore may not be applied in the present case. Specifically, plaintiff contends that C.G.S.
Because this action was brought pursuant to this court’s diversity jurisdiction,
II.
Police officers perform many functions not directly related to their duty to investigate crimes. This is especially true with regard to automobile traffic and accidents and other kinds of public and personal emergencies. In another context, the Supreme Court has reminded the lower feder*367al courts and state courts of the distinction between the “community caretaking functions” of the police and those activities associated with the investigation of crimes. It has drawn particular attention to the police role in the regulation of automobile traffic and investigation of automobile accidents:
Because of the extensive regulation of motor vehicles and traffic, and also because of the frequency with which a vehicle can become disabled or involved in an accident on public highways, the extent of police-citizen contact involving automobiles will be substantially greater than police-citizen contact in a home or office. Some such contacts will occur because the officer may believe the operator has violated a criminal statute, but many more will not be of that nature. Local police officers . . . frequently investigate vehicle accidents in which there is no claim of criminal liability and engage in what, for want of a better term, may be described as community caretaking functions, totally divorced from the detection, investigation, or acquisition of evidence relating to the violation of a criminal statute.
Cady v. Dombrowski, 413 U.S. 433, 441, 93 S.Ct. 2523, 2528, 37 L.Ed.2d 706 (1973) (emphasis added).
The “community caretaking functions” of the police include, most notably, the investigation of motor vehicle incidents and other emergencies or crises which do not necessarily require investigation of a violation of a criminal statute or action by prosecutorial authorities. They include also, for example, holding a person’s property while he is hospitalized, United States v. Markland, 635 F.2d 174,176 (2d Cir. 1980), cert, denied, 451 U.S. 991, 101 S.Ct. 2332, 68 L.Ed.2d 851 (1981), or taking custody of an automobile after an accident has occurred, United States v. Staller, 616 F.2d 1284, 1289-1290 (5th Cir.), cert, denied, 449 U.S. 869, 101 S.Ct. 207, 66 L.Ed.2d 89 (1980). In the aftermath of an automobile accident, the police, in the exercise of their customary community caretaking functions, generally investigate the situation and prepare a report, see, e.g., C.G.S. §§ 14-108a(b) and 14-224(a) (on reports to or by police officers regarding motor vehicle accidents), regardless of whether the accident is one that requires an investigation of a possible violation of the criminal law.
Defendants argue, in effect, that as a result of the Connecticut criminal records erasure statute, records compiled or materials collected routinely by police officers about a motor vehicle accident cannot be discovered in civil litigation arising from that accident if those records or materials become the basis (or form a part) of an unsuccessful prosecution under a criminal statute. The court cannot agree.
It has been stated by the state’s highest court that “[t]he intent of the legislature is to be found in the meaning of the words of the statute; that is, in what the legislature actually did say, not in what it meant to say.” Doe v. Manson,-Conn.-,-, 438 A.2d 859, 861 (1981) (citations omitted; emphasis in original), and where the statutory language is “plain and unambiguous, there is no room for judicial construction of the statute.” Id. The scope of C.G.S.
On its face, C.G.S.
A holding that C.G.S.
If the General Assembly had intended to “erase,” under C.G.S.
Although it is not necessary in this case to rely directly on the legislative history of the criminal records erasure law, it bears noting that the available legislative history confirms the meaning conveyed by the plain language of the statute. The purpose of the Connecticut General Assembly in enacting this statute was to permit a person against whom criminal charges have been dropped to have the fact of his prosecution “erased” from his record. In other words, the statute was intended to remove the stigma of arrest or other formal charges from those who were never found to have committed any crime. See General Assembly Proceedings 1963: Senate 2729-2730 (remarks of Senator Alfano); General Assembly Proceedings 1963: House of Representatives 3498-3499 (remarks of Representative Duda); see also General Assembly Proceedings 1969: Senate 1748-1749 (remarks of Senator Pickett); General Assembly Proceedings 1969: House of Representatives 2196-2200 (remarks of Representatives Strada, Ajello, and Povinelli).
However, the General Assembly evinced no intention to accord special tactical advantages in civil litigation to a person involved in a motor vehicle incident merely because thereafter he is arrested and prosecuted but ultimately held harmless under criminal law. Plaintiff here apparently seeks nothing more than the evidence that would have been available to him if defendant Joseph Venuti had not been arrested and prosecuted. It does not appear that he aims to discover information drawn from the unsuccessful prosecution or otherwise to impose on the defendant the stigma of his arrest. In these circumstances, to permit defendants in this civil action to invoke C.G.S.
Most or all of the physical evidence collected by the police at the time of the incident which is the subject of this lawsuit presumably would have existed notwithstanding the criminal prosecution. That evidence would have been collected, or reported upon, by police officers performing their community caretaking functions or reported .to the police under applicable law. See, e.g, C.G.S. §§ 14-108a(b) and 14-224(a). Connecticut’s criminal records erasure statute does not prevent access to such evidence in a civil action merely because the police retrieved physical evidence before private parties could do so; because the police thereafter submitted reports on the incident; and because prosecutors thereupon commenced criminal proceedings (ultimately unsuccessful) against the person who happens to be a defendant in the civil action.
III.
It is difficult to state with precision a general rule on the demarcation between the community caretaking functions of law enforcement officials and their prosecutorial functions. Indeed, the questions asked by such officials and the evidence sought by them in a criminal investigation may be the same as in any inquiry undertaken in the discharge of their community caretaking functions. Accordingly, the criminal records erasure statute sensibly can foreclose disclosure of information only when a person (ultimately held harmless under criminal law) is actually charged or arrested; it is the charge or arrest which triggers a criminal prosecution and imposes the stigma with which the statute is primarily concerned.
In defining the start of a criminal prosecution in the context of the Sixth Amendment guarantee of the right to counsel, the Supreme Court has found that “the initiation of adversary judicial criminal proceedings . . . by way of formal charge, preliminary hearing, indictment, information, or arraignment” signals the commencement of a criminal prosecution. Kirby v. Illinois, 406 U.S. 682, 689-90, 92 S.Ct. 1877,1882-83, 32 L.Ed.2d 411 (1972). See also Brewer v. Williams, 430 U.S. 387, 398, 97 S.Ct. 1232, 1239, 51 L.Ed.2d 424 (1977). The Connecticut General Assembly, in the related statute governing security and privacy of criminal records, includes “arrest” as one of several kinds of “formal criminal charges.” C.G.S. § 54-142g(a). Cf. United States v. Henderson, 482 F.Supp. 234, 242 (D.N.J.1979) (identifying arrest as the initiation of a criminal prosecution for purposes of “expungement” and related provisions of the federal Youth Corrections Act,
IV.
The court is able, under the principles outlined above, to dispose of the issues presented by the pending motions and objections.
The physical evidence obtained at the scene of the accident which otherwise would have been obtainable by private parties in the absence of a criminal prosecution are discoverable.
Questions directed to police officers and others on the subject of the evidence police officers collected at the scene of the accident are not generally foreclosed by C.G.S.
V.
Plaintiff’s arguments on the pending motions have been limited entirely to the question of the constitutionality of C.G.S.
CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, defendants’ motion for a protective order is denied.
Defendants also have objected to certain interrogatories and requests for production. They assert, in conclusory statements unsupported by any explanation or by reference to any authorities, that the requested discovery is protected by “the attorney-client privilege or work-product rule” or is “vague, ambiguous and unintelligible.” See Defendants’ Supplemental Memorandum at 5-6. Because these interrogatories and requests for production are straightforward and unambiguous and because the defendants’ objections are not articulated in a form that enables the court to understand them, they are overruled.
Defendants shall respond to plaintiff’s discovery requests by no later than December 31, 1981.
No good cause having been shown why the deposition of defendant Joseph Venuti should not proceed under applicable federal rules of civil procedure, plaintiff may, by no later than December 18, 1981, serve upon that defendant a notice for the taking of his deposition. Any such deposition shall be completed by no later than December 31, 1981.
It is so ordered.
Notes
. Compare the language of C.G.S.