Pearson v. Clackamas County Sheriff’s DepartmentPearson v. Clackamas County Sheriff’s Department
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Stacie F. Beckerman
OPINION AND ORDER
BECKERMAN, U.S. Magistrate Judge.
Plaintiff David Lloyd Pearson (“Pearson”), an adult in custody (“AIC”) of the Idaho Department of Corrections (“IDOC”), filed this action against the Clackamas County Sheriff’s Office, Clackamas County, the Clackamas County Jail, Clackamas County Sheriff Angela Brandenburg (“Sheriff Brandenburg”), Clackamas County Sheriff’s Deputy Troy Gilmore (“Gilmore”), an unknown Clackamas County Jail captain, unknown Clackamas County Jail medical staff, and three unknown Clackamas County Sheriff’s Office law enforcement officers (together, “Defendants”), alleging constitutional claims under
///
BACKGROUND2
Pearson’s claims relate to the injuries he allegedly suffered when Clackamas County Sheriff’s Office deputies arrested him and the subsequent medical care he received for those injuries while in Clackamas County’s custody. (See generally Am. Compl. (“FAC”), ECF No. 17.)
On December 21, 2023, Gilmore and two unnamed Clackamas County Sheriff’s deputies confronted Pearson as he was leaving his employer’s private driveway. (Id. at 8.) When Pearson saw the deputies, he turned his car around and drove back toward his employer’s house, parked his car, and fled into a wooded area on foot. (Id. at 11.) The three deputies and a police canine pursued Pearson into the wooded area. (Id. at 10-11.) The canine found Pearson and bit him on his left thigh “sinking his teeth deep into the soft tissue [and] muscle, all the way to the bone[.]” (Id. at 10.) The three deputies arrived seconds later and restrained Pearson flat on his back. (Id.)
The canine bite caused Pearson to suffer severe lacerations and severed nerves in his left thigh. (Id. at 5.) Pearson’s injuries caused him to lose blood to the point that he was incapacitated and could not move. (Id.) A deputy applied a tourniquet to Pearson’s injuries before loading him into an ambulance which rushed him to a trauma center for emergency surgery.
On December 24, 2023, Pearson was discharged from the trauma center into the Clackamas County Sheriff’s Office’s custody. (Id. at 16.) Clackamas County Sheriff’s deputies transported Pearson to the Clackamas County Jail. (Id.) Jail staff confiscated Pearson’s pain medications and antibiotics that the doctors prescribed to him after his surgery. (Id. at 16-17.) After spending his first night in a holding cell, Pearson ultimately spent sixty-five days in a medical isolation cell with “unsanitary” conditions. (Id.) The jail’s medical staff allegedly failed properly to care for Pearson’s injuries, which subjected Pearson to pain, suffering, and infection, resulting in permanent injuries.3 (Id. at 13.)
///
DISCUSSION
I. LEGAL STANDARDS
To survive a motion to dismiss under
///
II. PROPER DEFENDANTS
A. Municipal Defendants
Defendants move to dismiss Pearson’s claims against the Clackamas County Sheriff’s Office, the Clackamas County Jail, and “Clackamas County Medical” on the ground that those entities cannot be sued because they are not “persons” within the meaning of Section 1983. (See Defs.’ Mot. at 4.)
1. Applicable Law
“[L]ocal governmental unit[s] or municipalit[ies] can be sued as a ‘person’ under section 1983.” Hervey v. Estes, 65 F.3d 784, 791 (9th Cir. 1995) (quoting Monell v. Dep’t of Soc. Servs. of N.Y.C., 436 U.S. 658, 690 (1978)). “Other types of governmental entities can only be sued if they are intended to be separate and distinct legal entities.” Lukens v. Portland Police Bureau, No. 3:11-cv-00827-MO, 2011 WL 5999376, at *2 (D. Or. Nov. 29, 2011) (dismissing the Portland Police Bureau as a defendant, with prejudice, from Section 1983 claims because the police bureau is not a distinct entity capable of being sued (citing Hervey, 65 F.3d at 792)).
Courts in this district have consistently dismissed federal and state claims against local law enforcement agencies because the plaintiffs should have filed against the city or county. See, e.g., Schoene v. Rasmussen, No. 3:23-cv-01151-HZ, 2024 WL 2153589, at *8 (D. Or. May 14, 2024) (“[C]ourts in this district have held that local law enforcement agencies in Oregon were not intended to be separate and distinct legal entities and thus cannot be sued under § 1983.” (citing Harris v. City of Portland Police Dep’t, No. 3:15-cv-00853-HZ, 2016 WL 740425, at *5 (D. Or. Feb. 24, 2016))); Dombroski v. City of Salem, No. 6:09-cv-06284-TC, 2012 WL 1035719, at *3 (D. Or. Mar. 26, 2012) (dismissing all federal and state law claims against the Salem Police Department because “Oregon, along with many other jurisdictions, has held that any claim of liability against a police department must be brought against the city itself” (citing
2. Analysis
Pearson asserts claims against Clackamas County, the Clackamas County Sheriff’s Office, the Clackamas County Jail, and “Clackamas County Medical[.]” (See FAC at 1-3, 14-15.) The Court finds that the proper defendant to those claims is Clackamas County. See Schoene, 2024 WL 2153589, at *8 (“[C]ourts in this district have held that local law enforcement agencies in Oregon were not intended to be separate and distinct legal entities and thus cannot be sued under § 1983.”); Barrera v. Multnomah Cnty. Inverness Jail, No. 3:23-cv-00146-CL, 2023 WL 4239328, at *1 (D. Or. Feb. 9, 2023) (“Plaintiff cannot bring claims against ‘Multnomah County Inverness Jail’ because it is a county detention facility and not a ‘person’ capable of being sued under Section 1983.”) (citations omitted), findings and recommendation adopted, 2023 WL 4235599 (D. Or. June 28, 2023). Accordingly, the Court dismisses the Clackamas County Sheriff’s Office, the Clackamas County Jail, and “Clackamas County Medical[.]”
B. Sheriff Brandenburg
Defendants move to dismiss Sheriff Brandenburg on the ground that Pearson’s claims against her in her official capacity are redundant. (See Defs.’ Mot. at 8.) Specifically, Defendants argue that a claim against Sheriff Brandenburg in her official capacity is effectively a claim against Clackamas County, and Pearson asserts identical claims against Clackamas County, making Sheriff Brandenburg’s inclusion in this action redundant. (See id.)
The Court agrees that Pearson’s separate claims against Clackamas County and Sheriff Brandenburg in her official capacity are redundant. See Ctr. for Bio-Ethical Reform v. L.A. Cnty. Sheriff Dep’t, 533 F.3d 780, 799 (9th Cir. 2008) (“When both a municipal officer and a local government entity are named, and the officer is named only in an official capacity, the court may
It is not clear to the Court, however, that Pearson only asserts claims against Sheriff Brandenburg in her official capacity. (Compare FAC at 2, indicating on the original complaint for this action that Pearson named Sheriff Brandenburg in her official capacity with id. at 15, listing Sheriff Brandenburg as a defendant in Pearson’s related case without indicating whether he is suing her in her individual or official capacity; see also Pl.’s Sur-Response Defs.’ Mot. Dismiss (“Pl.’s Sur-reply”) at 10-11, discussing Pearson’s Fourth Amendment “Section 1983 claim against Defendant[s] in Individual Capacity” and arguing that Defendants are liable for their “[d]eliberate indifference from the top to actual illegal conduct at the bottom” and that “[n]o amount of words changes the facts of what happened and how responsibility goes right up the chain of command,” ECF No. 42.) Accordingly, the Court grants Defendants’ motion to dismiss Pearson’s claims against Sheriff Brandenburg in her official capacity but denies Defendants’ motion to dismiss Pearson’s claims against Sheriff Brandenburg in her individual capacity on the ground that the claims against her are redundant.5
///
///
///
C. Unnamed Defendants
Defendants move to dismiss the unnamed defendants on the ground that Pearson has failed timely to file an amended complaint identifying the unnamed defendants in accordance with the Court’s scheduling order. (See Defs.’ Mot. at 8-9.)
1. Applicable Law
“As a general rule, the use of ‘John Doe’ to identify a defendant is not favored.” Gillespie v. Civiletti, 629 F.2d 637, 642 (9th Cir. 1980) (citation omitted). “However, situations arise . . . where the identity of alleged defendants will not be known prior to the filing of a complaint.” Id. “In such circumstances, the plaintiff should be given an opportunity through discovery to identify the unknown defendants[.]” Id. (citation omitted). “To proceed against ‘specific, but as yet unidentified defendants,’ [the plaintiff] must ‘otherwise state[ ] a valid claim.’” Miller v. Fed. Bureau of Investigation, No. 3:24-cv-01224-SB, 2024 WL 4524865, at *7 n.1 (D. Or. Aug. 20, 2024) (quoting Pastora by & through Toghraie v. County of San Bernardino, No. 22-55617, 2023 WL 3734264, at *2 (9th Cir. May 31, 2023)).
2. Analysis
For the reasons discussed below, the Court finds that Pearson has adequately alleged facts supporting his claims against the deputies involved in his arrest.6 Thus, the Court denies
However, for reasons discussed below, the Court finds that Pearson fails to allege facts to support a claim upon which relief can be granted against the unnamed Clackamas County Jail captain and staff. The Court therefore dismisses Pearson’s claims against these defendants because Pearson fails to state a claim against them upon which relief can be granted. See Miller, 2024 WL 4524865, at *7 n.1 (“To proceed against ‘specific, but as-yet unidentified defendants,’ [the plaintiff] must ‘otherwise state[ ] a valid claim.’” (quoting Pastora by & through Toghraie, 2023 WL 3734264, at *2)).
III. FOURTH AMENDMENT
Pearson asserts a Section 1983 claim against Gilmore and two unknown Clackamas County Sheriff’s deputies, alleging that the three deputies violated Pearson’s Fourth Amendment leave to allow Pearson to amend his complaint, the Court will address a new case management schedule once the pleadings are settled.
A. Applicable Law
“A police officer’s use of excessive force on a person [is] a seizure subject to the [reasonableness requirement of the] Fourth Amendment.” Hyer v. City & Cnty. of Honolulu, 118 F.4th 1044, 1060-61 (9th Cir. 2024) (citing Graham v. Connor, 490 U.S. 386, 388 (1989)); see also Williams v. City of Sparks, 112 F.4th 635, 642 (9th Cir. 2024) (noting that “[a] police officer’s application of deadly force to restrain a subject’s movements ‘is a seizure subject to the reasonableness requirement of the Fourth Amendment’” (quoting Tennessee v. Garner, 471 U.S. 1, 7 (1985))). “To state an excessive force claim, plaintiff must allege facts showing that the officers’ conduct was ‘objectively [un]reasonable in light of the facts and circumstances confronting them[.]’” Mihailovici v. Snyder, No. 3:15-cv-01675-KI, 2016 WL 447842, at *4 (D. Or. Feb. 4, 2016) (quoting Graham, 490 U.S. at 397).
B. Analysis
Pearson does not appear to allege that the use of a canine alone constituted excessive force. (See FAC at 11, acknowledging that he attempted to elude arrest and alleging that “[t]he excessive force happened when the K-9 was allowed to continue ripping at my leg.”) Rather, it appears that Pearson’s excessive force allegations are specific to the time after the deputies restrained Pearson and allegedly allowed the canine to continue biting him. (See id. at 8, “[T]he time between the three officers holding me down and pulling the K-9 off me is in particular the excessive force this suit is about.”; id. at 13, alleging that Pearson’s excessive force claim relates to “[t]he time between being in custody by the fact I was held down by three law enforcement officers and the K-9 being forced by a slap in the face to let go”).
Pearson alleges that when the deputies and canine found him, he was lying on his back. (See id. at 10.) Pearson alleges the canine confronted him first, and that the three deputies arrived approximately two seconds later and restrained Pearson’s arms and torso. (See id.) Pearson did not resist. (See id.) Pearson alleges that the three deputies held him down on his back and allowed the canine “to rip and tear at [his] upper thigh” for approximately “two to four minutes.” (See id.)
Defendants cite Hughes and argue that Gilmore was not an integral participant in the alleged constitutional violation because Pearson “has not and cannot allege that Deputy Gilmore had any control of the canine who bit him.” (Defs.’ Mot. at 7.) In Hughes, the law enforcement officers surrounded a house where the plaintiff, who had escaped from jail and had a history of weapons charges, violent gang affiliation, and evading law enforcement, was known to be hiding. See Hughes, 31 F.4th at 1216-17. When the plaintiff did not respond to the officers’ commands to exit the house, the officers released a police dog into the house that attacked the plaintiff. See id. The plaintiff in Hughes asserted excessive force claims against the four officers who were present when he was arrested alleging, inter alia, that the officers allowed a police dog to continue biting him after he was handcuffed. See id. at 1223.
The Ninth Circuit affirmed entry of summary judgment relating to the plaintiff’s claims against the three officers who were not the police dog’s handler. Id. The court explained that those three officers were not integral participants in the alleged constitutional violation because one of the officers was “on the other side of the home at the time,” and the remaining two officers “cannot be held liable for fleeting acts which they did not commit, came without
Hughes is distinguishable. Here, unlike in Hughes, Pearson alleges that all three officers were involved in restraining him. Compare id. at 1223 (finding that one of the officers was entitled to summary judgment because he was “on the other side of the home at the time”) with (FAC at 4, “After being put in custody by three officers holding me down, the canine was allowed to continue ripping into my left upper thigh[.]”) Further, in Hughes, the Ninth Circuit held that two of the officers could not be held liable for “fleeting acts” which all occurred within one minute and “which they did not commit, came without warning, and could not have prevented.” Hughes, 31 F.4th at 1223. Here, in contrast, Pearson alleges that the deputies restrained him and “allowed [the canine] to continue [biting Pearson] while [he] was held down for approx[imately] two to four minutes[,]” and that “the officers closest to the [canine] had to slap the [canine] in the muzzle to make him/her release [his] leg.” (FAC at 4, 10.)
Pearson’s allegations support a reasonable inference that the alleged constitutional violation was not a result of fleeting acts which came without warning and which Gilmore could not have prevented. Thus, the Court finds that Pearson has adequately alleged that Gilmore integrally participated in the alleged constitutional violation. See Chew v. Gates, 27 F.3d 1432, 1446 (9th Cir. 1994) (“Although these defendants did not personally participate in the infliction of [the plaintiff]’s injury, they may be held individually liable if they ‘cause[d]’ him to be subjected to a constitutional deprivation.”) (citations omitted); Bogle v. Clackamas County, No. 3:15-cv-00013-SI, 2017 WL 5490870, at *5 (D. Or. Nov. 15, 2017) (“[B]ecause Defendants . . .
Accordingly, the Court denies Defendants’ motion to dismiss Pearson’s Fourth Amendment claim against Gilmore.
IV. EIGHTH AMENDMENT
Pearson appears to assert two Eighth Amendment claims against unnamed “Clackamas County Medical [and] Jail Staff.” (FAC at 15; see Pl.’s Resp. Mot. Dismiss (“Pl.’s Resp.”) at 2, describing Pearson’s claims as asserting two separate “Eighth Amendment violation . . . claim[s]” relating to “[t]he entrance and 24 hours in booking” and “[t]he infection of the wound,” ECF No. 34.8) Defendants move to dismiss Pearson’s claims, arguing that he fails to allege that the medical or jail staff engaged in any “deliberately indifferent conduct[.]” (Med. Mot. at 5-7.)
A. Applicable Law
“A public official’s ‘deliberate indifference to a prisoner’s serious illness or injury’ violates the Eighth Amendment ban against cruel punishment.” Clement v. Gomez, 298 F.3d 898, 904 (9th Cir. 2002) (quoting Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97, 105 (1976)). A plaintiff must establish that he was “confined under conditions posing a risk of ‘objectively, sufficiently serious’ harm and that the officials had a ‘sufficiently culpable state of mind’ in denying the proper medical care.” Id. (citing Wallis v. Baldwin, 70 F.3d 1074, 1076 (9th Cir. 1995)). “Thus, there is both an objective and a subjective component to an actionable Eighth Amendment violation.” Id.
“The subjective component requires [AICs] to show that the officials had the culpable mental state, which is deliberate indifference to a substantial risk of serious harm.” Clement, 298 F.3d at 904 (simplified). “Deliberate indifference” is established only when “the official knows of and disregards an excessive risk to inmate health or safety; the official must both be aware of the facts from which the inference could be drawn that a substantial risk of serious harm exists, and he must also draw the inference.” Id. (citing Farmer v. Brennan, 511 U.S. 825, 837 (1994)). “A prison official’s duty under the Eighth Amendment is to ensure ‘reasonable safety,’” and “prison officials who act reasonably cannot be found liable[.]” Farmer, 511 U.S. at 844-45 (quoting Helling v. McKinney, 509 U.S. 25, 33 (1993)). “Mere indifference, negligence, . . . medical malpractice[, or e]ven gross negligence is insufficient to establish deliberate indifference to serious medical needs.” Lemire v. Cal. Dep’t of Corr. & Rehab., 726 F.3d 1062, 1082 (9th Cir. 2013) (simplified); Hamby v. Hammond, 821 F.3d 1085, 1092 (9th Cir. 2016) (“A showing of medical malpractice or negligence is insufficient to establish a constitutional deprivation under the Eighth Amendment.” (quoting Toguchi v. Chung, 391 F.3d 1051, 1060 (9th Cir. 2004))).
///
///
///
///
B. Analysis
1. Holding Cell9
a. Objective Prong
With respect to the objective prong, Pearson alleges that a day after emergency surgery to repair life threatening injuries, he was transferred to the Clackamas County Jail where he was held in unsanitary conditions, deprived of his prescribed pain medication, and denied attention to his bleeding wound. (See FAC at 16.) Pearson further alleges that his holding cell did not have toilet paper or blankets, he had to sleep on a “dirty old mattress,” his injuries were not tended to, and the staff provided him “half eaten food[.]” (See id.) Defendants do not appear to dispute that Pearson’s allegations satisfy the objective prong. Thus, the Court finds that Pearson has adequately alleged that his injury and medical needs were “sufficiently serious” to satisfy the objective prong of the Eighth Amendment analysis. See Looman v. Wick, 329 F. App’x 729, 730 (9th Cir. 2009) (finding that the plaintiff’s allegations that “he was deprived of his pain medication for up to eight hours the day after he had hernia surgery” satisfied the objective prong of his Eighth Amendment claim).
b. Subjective Prong
With respect to the subjective prong, Pearson fails to identify any individual or individuals that allegedly acted with deliberate indifference to his medical needs while he was in the holding cell. In his response, Pearson references an unnamed nurse who allegedly failed properly to examine him upon his arrival and “holding officers” who ignored his requests for blankets. (Pl.’s Resp. at 17-18.) The Court cannot consider Pearson’s additional allegations that
Further, even if it could consider the additional allegations in Pearson’s response, the Court finds those allegations are vague and insufficient to state an Eighth Amendment claim against unnamed officers or medical staff. See Kealoha v. Espinda, No. 1:16-cv-00486, 2017 WL 741570, at *5 (D. Haw. Feb. 24, 2017) (explaining that “[i]f the names of individual defendants are unknown at the time a complaint is filed, . . . a plaintiff may refer to the unknown defendants as Defendant John Doe 1, John Doe 2, John Doe 3, and so on, but he must allege facts to support how each particular Doe defendant violated his constitutional rights,” and holding that the self-represented plaintiff failed to state a claim because he “indiscriminately sue[d] Doe Defendants 1-200 without explaining their positions with [the relevant agency] or alleging how each individual violated his rights”); Herrera v. Nguyen, No. 1:12-cv-01915, 2013 WL 1364691, at *2 (E.D. Cal. Apr. 3, 2013) (dismissing the plaintiff’s Eighth Amendment claim regarding his treatment for high blood pressure and explaining that “the Court finds Plaintiff’s allegations to be vague” where the plaintiff “sets forth generalized allegations regarding his health care, and identifies [the defendant]” but did not “describe what each defendant . . . did to violate the particular right”).
Accordingly, the Court dismisses Pearson’s Eighth Amendment claim based on his twenty-four hours in the holding cell.
///
///
2. Medical Isolation Cell
a. Objective Prong
With respect to the objective prong, Pearson alleges that for sixty-five days, Defendants held him in a medical isolation cell with unsanitary conditions, prevented him from accessing prescribed pain medication, and provided inadequate care from unqualified medical providers. (See FAC at 16-17.) Pearson further alleges that the inadequate medical care caused his wound to become infected, he “came within a few hours of losing [his] leg[,]” and his leg is permanently disfigured. (Id. at 18-19.) Defendants do not appear to dispute that Pearson’s allegations satisfy the objective prong. Thus, the Court finds that Pearson has adequately alleged facts to satisfy the objective prong of the Eighth Amendment analysis. Looman, 329 F. App’x at 730 (finding that the plaintiff’s allegations that “he was deprived of his pain medication for up to eight hours the day after he had hernia surgery” satisfied the objective prong of his Eighth Amendment claim); Ahdom v. Lopez, No. 1:09-cv-01874, 2010 WL 3001406, at *5 (E.D. Cal. July 29, 2010) (finding that the plaintiff’s allegations that the defendants’ failed to prescribe antibiotics after surgery which caused his injuries to become infected satisfied the objective prong of his Eighth Amendment claim).
b. Subjective Prong
With respect to the subjective prong, Pearson primarily alleges that the Clackamas County Jail’s medical staff members responsible for caring for his injuries were unqualified, failed properly to care for his injuries, and failed to use “sanitary procedures.” (FAC at 17, “None of the people working on my leg had any recent wound care experience, one older woman had some [thirty] years ago. One of the other serious issues was the lack of sanitary procedures.”) Pearson generally alleges that “[e]veryday a different person would change the bandages” and that “gloves were put on most of the time[.]” (Id.) Pearson alleges that he “would
As described above, the Court finds that Pearson has failed to state a claim upon which relief can be granted because he does not identify any specific defendant’s conduct that was allegedly deliberately indifferent to his medical needs. See Lemire, 726 F.3d at 1082 (“Mere indifference, negligence, . . . medical malpractice[, or e]ven gross negligence is insufficient to establish deliberate indifference to serious medical needs.”) (simplified); Hamby, 821 F.3d at 1092 (“A showing of medical malpractice or negligence is insufficient to establish a constitutional deprivation under the Eighth Amendment.”); see also Kealoha, 2017 WL 741570, at *5 (explaining that “[i]f the names of individual defendants are unknown at the time a complaint is filed, . . . a plaintiff may refer to the unknown defendants as Defendant John Doe 1, John Doe 2, John Doe 3, and so on, but he must allege facts to support how each particular Doe defendant violated his constitutional rights,” and holding that the self-represented plaintiff failed to state a claim because he “indiscriminately sue[d] Doe Defendants 1-200 without explaining their positions with [the relevant agency] or alleging how each individual violated his rights”).
V. MONELL CLAIMS
Pearson appears to assert three Monell claims against Clackamas County: one claim for an alleged custom or policy of using excessive force “by [canine] bite” (Pl.’s Resp. at 6), and two claims for alleged policies relating to providing inadequate medical care. (See generally FAC at 14-20; Pl.’s Resp. at 2, describing Pearson’s allegations as including a claim for “[t]he violation of [Pearson]’s [F]ourth [A]mendment right and the four elements of the Monell claim during the arrest” and two separate “Eighth Amendment violation and [M]onell claim[s]” relating to “[t]he entrance and 24 hours in booking” and “[t]he infection of the wound”).
A. Applicable Law
To prevail on a Monell claim under Section 1983, a plaintiff must demonstrate that a municipal custom or policy caused the violation of a constitutional right. See Monell, 436 U.S. at 690 (“Local governing bodies . . . can be sued directly under [Section] 1983 . . . where, as here, the action that is alleged to be unconstitutional implements or executes a policy statement, ordinance, regulation, or decision officially adopted and promulgated by that body’s officers.”). “[M]unicipalities may be liable under [Section] 1983 for constitutional injuries pursuant to (1) an official policy; (2) a pervasive practice or custom; (3) a failure to train, supervise, or discipline;
To establish Monell liability, a plaintiff must demonstrate that: “(1) they were deprived of a constitutional right; (2) the municipality had a policy, custom, or practice; (3) the policy, custom, or practice amounted to deliberate indifference of the plaintiffs’ constitutional rights; and (4) the policy, custom, or practice was the ‘moving force’ behind the constitutional violation.” Cantu v. City of Portland, No. 3:19-cv-01606-SB, 2020 WL 2952972, at *3 (D. Or. June 3, 2020) (citing Dougherty v. City of Covina, 654 F.3d 892, 900 (9th Cir. 2011)). “That is, a plaintiff must show that the municipal action was taken with the requisite degree of culpability and must demonstrate a direct causal link between the municipal action and the deprivation of federal rights.” Bd. of Cnty. Comm’rs of Bryan Cnty. v. Brown, 520 U.S. 397, 404 (1997).
“When inadequate training is the basis of a Monell claim, liability arises ‘only where the failure to train amounts to deliberate indifference to the rights of persons with whom police come into contact.’” Barror v. City of St. Helens, No. 3:20-cv-00731-SB, 2023 WL 5350755, at *1 (D. Or. Aug. 18, 2023) (quoting City of Canton v. Harris, 489 U.S. 378, 388 (1989)). “Deliberate indifference can be established in three ways[: f]irst, the municipality made ‘a conscious or deliberate choice’ not to train its officers by ‘disregard[ing] the known or obvious consequence that a particular omission in their training program would cause [municipality] employees to violate citizens’ constitutional rights.’” Id. (quoting Flores v. County of Los Angeles, 758 F.3d 1154, 1158-59 (9th Cir. 2014)). “Second, ‘a violation of federal rights may be a highly predictable consequence of a failure to equip law enforcement officers with specific tools to handle recuring situations,’ especially when there is a high likelihood ‘that the situation will recur and the predictability that an officer lacking specific tools to handle that situation will
B. Analysis
1. Fourth Amendment
Pearson appears to allege that he can hold Clackamas County liable for alleged violations of his Fourth Amendment rights because the nature of his arrest “strongly points to a reckless indifference from the sheriff down to the arresting officer.” (FAC at 4.) In his response, Pearson argues that “the existence of a formal policy[,]” a persistent practice, and “[a] failure by policy makers to properly train” are applicable to this case. (See Pl.’s Resp. at 13.) Defendants move to dismiss Pearson’s claim on the ground that “Plaintiff has not described facts that amount to a potential constitutional violation, but rather events that at best amount to a single incident of mere negligence.” (Defs.’ Mot. at 6.)
Pearson fails to identify or allege the existence of any formal policy, persistent practice, or policymakers’ failure to train Clackamas County’s law enforcement officers that was the “moving force” behind the alleged constitutional violations. Pearson appears to allege that the Clackamas County Sheriff’s Office’s policy of using canines during arrests is unconstitutional but acknowledges that “in most cases[, using canines] do[es] not result in such gross deliberate indifference to the constitutional rights on an individual nor such mortal grievous injury.” (Id.) Pearson does not allege any facts supporting a reasonable inference that any Clackamas County
Further, Pearson fails to identify any instances outside of his own where the Clackamas County Sheriff’s Office’s deputies’ use of a canine allegedly constituted excessive force. Thus, the Court finds that Pearson has failed to allege facts supporting the existence of a policy or custom within Clackamas County of using excessive force through the use of police canines. See Trevino v. Gates, 99 F.3d 911, 918 (9th Cir. 1996) (“Liability for improper custom may not be predicated on isolated or sporadic incidents; it must be founded upon practices of sufficient duration, frequency and consistency that the conduct has become a traditional method of carrying out policy.”) (simplified); cf. Barror, 2023 WL 5350755, at *2 (granting summary judgment on the plaintiff’s failure to train Monell claim based on “highly predictable consequences” because the “plaintiff does not provide (1) evidence of similar scenarios, (2) data or testimony on the number of [relevant] suspects that the [defendant]’s officers interact with, or (3) evidence that such training would actually reduce the risk of potential constitutional right violations”). Accordingly, the Court dismisses Pearson’s Fourth Amendment Monell claim.
2. Eighth Amendment
A threshold question in determining whether Pearson can establish Monell liability is whether a constitutional violation occurred. As discussed above, Pearson fails to allege facts supporting an Eighth Amendment claim upon which relief can be granted. Because Pearson fails adequately to plead an Eighth Amendment violation, Pearson’s Monell claims fail as a matter of law. See Heller, 475 U.S. at 799 (holding that a Monell claim cannot survive without an underlying constitutional violation); see also Lockett v. County of Los Angeles, 977 F.3d 737, 741 (9th Cir. 2020) (“Monell claims thus require a plaintiff to show an underlying constitutional
In any event, the Court finds that Pearson fails to allege facts supporting the existence of a policy or pervasive practice relating to the Clackamas County Jail’s holding or medical isolation cell practices that constitutes deliberate indifference to the AICs’ constitutional rights. See Wilkinson v. Centurion Med., No. 1:24-cv-00334, 2024 WL 3990726, at *3 (D. Idaho Aug. 29, 2024) (“Plaintiff’s speculative allegations do not show that [the defendant] has a policy to delay medical treatment to inmates . . . . Plaintiff’s own experience does not show a policy or custom. His own experience may have been caused by the mere or gross negligence of a scheduler or medical provider, or by the deliberate indifference of individuals, acting in the absence of a policy or custom.”); Ramsey v. City of Rancho Cordova, No. 2:23-cv-02178, 2024 WL 2153648, at *3-4 (E.D. Cal. May 13, 2024) (dismissing the plaintiff’s Eighth Amendment Monell claim because the “plaintiff’s complaint only discuss[es] the incident that is the subject of this action, not other incidents”); see also Lemire, 726 F.3d at 1082 (“Mere indifference, negligence, . . . medical malpractice[, or e]ven gross negligence is insufficient to establish deliberate indifference to serious medical needs.”) (simplified); Hamby, 821 F.3d at 1092 (“A
Accordingly, the Court dismisses Pearson’s Eighth Amendment Monell claims.
VI. NEGLIGENCE
Pearson appears to assert supervisory negligence claims against an unnamed defendant and Sheriff Brandenburg. (See FAC at 9, asserting claims against an unnamed Clackamas County Jail “captain” and Sheriff Brandenburg for “gross negligence in allowing procedure and protocol to become so lax [that] officers . . . acted with reckless negligence and irresponsibility”; id. at 12, “Along with [the arresting officers] in this suit is the Captain and Sheriff of Clackamas County because the negligence and lax protocol must come from the top.”) The Court interprets Pearson’s allegations as asserting a supervisory negligence claim against Sheriff Brandenburg relating to the alleged excessive force, and a supervisory negligence claim against the unnamed Clackamas County Jail “captain” relating to the allegedly inadequate medical care.
Defendants move to dismiss Pearson’s negligence claim on the ground that it is impermissibly based on the same facts as his Section 1983 claim. (See Defs.’ Mot. at 9, citing Lifestyle Ventures, LLC v. County of Clackamas, No. 3:15-cv-01291, 2016 WL 11394982, at *5 (D. Or. May 18, 2016).) Defendants further argue that the Court should dismiss Pearson’s negligence claim because he “has not pleaded the essential elements” of his claim and fails to plead compliance with the Oregon Tort Claims Act’s (“OTCA”) notice requirement. (Id. at 9, citing
A. Applicable Law
Under Oregon law, a plaintiff asserting a negligence claim must prove:
- that defendant’s conduct caused a foreseeable risk of harm,
- that the risk is to an interest of a kind that the law protects against negligent invasion,
- that defendant’s conduct was unreasonable
in light of the risk, - that the conduct was a cause of plaintiff’s harm, and
- that plaintiff was within the class of persons and plaintiff’s injury was within the general type of potential incidents and injuries that made defendant’s conduct negligent.
Son v. Ashland Cmty. Healthcare Servs., 244 P.3d 835, 841 (Or. Ct. App. 2010) (simplified).
“Under the OTCA, a party may bring a tort claim against a public body or an officer or employee of a public body, but the party must give advance notice of the party’s intent to assert the claim[.]” Moore v. Portland Pub. Schs., 537 P.3d 544, 551 (Or. Ct. App. 2023) (citing
Parties can satisfy the OTCA’s notice requirement “several different ways, including by giving a formal notice of claim, and by ‘[c]ommencement of an action on the claim by or on behalf of the claimant within the applicable period of time provided in subsection (2)[.]’” Moore, 537 P.3d at 551 (first citing
B. Analysis
As the Court has previously explained, courts in this district “recognize that while a party may not advance both negligence and constitutional claims based on the same operative facts at the summary judgment stage, a party may do so at the initial pleading stage.” Lifestyle Ventures, LLC, 2016 WL 11394982, at *5 (collecting cases).
The Court, however, finds that Pearson has failed adequately to plead specific facts to support a negligence claim. Specifically, Pearson alleges no facts to establish that the deputies or jail staff were not properly trained in the relevant policies or that the unnamed “captain” or Sheriff Brandenburg knew or should have known their officers needed better training. See Santiago v. City of Eugene, No. 6:21-cv-01715-MK, 2024 WL 4008491, at *12 (D. Or. Aug. 19, 2024) (“To prevail at trial, Plaintiff would need to present some evidence that the City knew or should have known it needed to better train its officers on de-escalation and use of force policy.” (citing Whelan v. Albertson’s, Inc., 879 P.2d 888, 892 (Or. Ct. App. 1994))), findings and recommendation adopted, 2024 WL 4770482 (D. Or. Nov. 13, 2024).
Further, the Court finds that Pearson fails adequately to plead facts supporting that he satisfied the OTCA’s notice requirement. See Hawkins v. City of Eugene, No. 6:24-cv-00951-JR, 2024 WL 4574394, at *1 (D. Or. Oct. 2, 2024) (granting the defendant’s motion to dismiss because the “plaintiff makes no mention of delivering formal or actual notice[ under the OTCA]”), findings and recommendation adopted, 2024 WL 4574384 (D. Or. Oct. 24, 2024).
Accordingly, the Court dismisses Pearson’s negligence claims.
///
CONCLUSION
For the reasons stated, the Court GRANTS IN PART and DENIES IN PART Defendants’ motions to dismiss (ECF Nos. 27, 28) as follows:
- DISMISS WITHOUT LEAVE TO AMEND
- Pearson’s claims against the Clackamas County Sheriff’s Office, the Clackamas County Jail, and “Clackamas County Jail Medical” Department; and
- Pearson’s claims for damages against Sheriff Brandenburg in her official capacity as the Clackamas County Sheriff.
- DISMISS WITH LEAVE TO AMEND
- Pearson’s Eighth Amendment claims;
- Pearson’s Fourth Amendment supervisory and Monell claims; and
- Pearson’s state law negligence claims.
The Court DENIES Defendants’ motion to dismiss Pearson’s Fourth Amendment claims against Gilmore and the two unnamed Clackamas County Sheriff’s deputies. Pearson may file a second amended complaint by June 20, 2025. If Pearson does not file a second amended complaint by June 20, 2025, this case will proceed with his Fourth Amendment claims against Gilmore and the two unnamed Clackamas County Sheriff’s deputies.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
DATED this 19th day of May, 2025.
HON. STACIE F. BECKERMAN
United States Magistrate Judge