Patton v. LoughridgePatton v. Loughridge
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Adams
But, in our opinion, it is immaterial whether the claim in question was distinctly passed on or not. If this plaintiff had any such claim at the time the decree was rendered against him for alimony it should have been passed on. If a husband divides his estate with his wife, or is swindled out of a part of it by her, and she afterward brings an action against him for divorce and alimony, the fact that she had already acquired a part of his estate would be proper to be shown in defense to her claim for alimony, either to defeat or *220reduce it. It would certainly not be proper to leave open a question, after a decree for alimony, as to bow much of tlie husband’s estate the wife had previously had and appropriated. Now, whatever necessarily inheres in a defense to a claim must be presumed to be adjudicated when the claim is adjudicated. Such being our view we are constrained to hold that the defendant is not liable.
REVERSED.