Pan American World Airways, Inc. v. International Brotherhood of TeamstersPan American World Airways, Inc. v. International Brotherhood of Teamsters
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Winter
Plaintiff-appellant Pan American World Airways, Inc. (“Pan Am”) appeals from Judge Glasser’s denial of its motion for a preliminary injunction against intermittent work stoppages by Pan Am employees represented by the International Brotherhood of Teamsters and its affiliate, Local 732. We affirm.
BACKGROUND
No dispute of material fact exists. Pan Am is an air carrier subject to the provisions of the Railway Labor Act,
In September 1984, as the expiration date of the extension approached, Pan Am issued notices of proposed changes in the status quo as required by Section 6 of the RLA,
On August 1, 1989, Pan Am filed this action requesting a declaratory judgment, damages, and an injunction prohibiting such self-help measures by the union. Pan Am moved for a preliminary injunction. The motion was heard by Magistrate Chrein, who recommended that the injunction be denied. On August 18, 1989, Judge Glasser reviewed Pan Am’s objections to the magistrate’s decision and denied Pan Am’s application for a preliminary injunction. Judge Glasser also denied Pan Am’s motion to present additional testimony on the ground that both parties had sufficient opportunity to present testimony at the two-day hearing before the magistrate. Pan Am appeals from Judge Glasser’s ruling.
DISCUSSION
Pan Am argues that the union’s self-help activities are unlawful under the RLA because: (i) the union has lost the right to engage in self-help, and (ii) intermittent strikes are impermissible as self-help. We disagree.
Under the RLA, disputes over the terms of new collective bargaining agreements— styled “major disputes,” see Pan Am. World Airways, Inc. v. Flight Eng’rs’ Int’l Ass’n, 306 F.2d 840, 845 (2d Cir.1962), in contrast to disputes over the meaning of existing agreements, styled “minor disputes,” id. — are governed by certain procedural requirements. When a collective bargaining agreement is about to expire and one party desires changes in its terms, that party must serve notice of those proposed changes on the other party under RLA Section 6,
It is beyond dispute in the instant case that the governing collective bargaining agreement has expired, the RLA’s “major dispute” procedures have been exhausted, and no new agreement has been reached. The terms and conditions under which the IBT employees now work were unilaterally imposed by Pan Am in the exercise of its right of self-help. It now
We are skeptical that the union’s intermittent work stoppages relate to “new” matters rather than the disputes outstanding since September 1984. The changed circumstances designated by Pan Am are no more than turnover in employees, changes in the structure of the workforce, Pan Am’s financial difficulties, and alterations in the airline’s agreements with various other employee unions. Such changes, however, are the inevitable consequence of the passage of time in a dynamic economy. Pan Am’s concept of “new” issues is so elastic that, if adopted, it would force unions to strike when first free to do so or face the almost perpetual need to exhaust RLA “major dispute” procedures while employers impose unilateral terms and conditions of employment.
However, even if “new” issues are more narrowly defined, their existence would not require renewal of the entire RLA notice and mediation process. In Pan Am., 306 F.2d 840, a coneededly “new” issue regarding crew complement, not raised in the original Section 6 notice, was introduced during negotiations. Nevertheless, we held that the union was free to strike without exhausting the “major dispute” procedures. It is the expiration of an agreement and a dispute over the terms of a new agreement that trigger the mandatory “major dispute” procedures. Absent a new agreement, those procedures need be exhausted only once. Certainly, the emergence of new issues after the procedures have been exhausted but before a strike occurs hardly entitles the employer to impose unilaterally the solutions it prefers while the union is forced to exhaust RLA procedures a second time.
We therefore also conclude that, once the RLA “major dispute” procedures have been exhausted, a hiatus in collective bargaining following the employer’s unilateral imposition of terms and conditions of employment is irrelevant. The essential ingredient of a status quo that can be disturbed only after exhaustion of the “major dispute” procedures is a resolution of disputed issues accepted by each side. No such resolution exists here. The union’s consistent posture toward the terms and conditions imposed by the airline on February 21, 1988 has been one of resistance reflected in its open disagreement with those terms and conditions.
Pan Am in effect argues that the courts should create an “expiration date” for self-help rights under the RLA. The parties do have a continuing statutory obligation to utilize their best efforts to reach a collective bargaining agreement,2 and that obligation continues after the parties are released to their self-help remedies. See Chicago & N. W. Ry. v. United Transp. Union, 402 U.S. 570, 574-75, 91 S.Ct. 1731, 1733-34, 29 L.Ed.2d 187 (1971); Jacksonville Terminal, 394 U.S. at 378, 89 S.Ct. at 1115 (statutory scheme for settlement of disputes preserves ultimate right to self-help); see also Pan Am., 306 F.2d at 846 (after cooling-off period “further progress toward the determination of the controversy will be left entirely to the interplay of economic forces” and parties may resort to
Pan Am argues in the alternative that intermittent work stoppages are an impermissible form of self-help under the RLA. We again disagree. The Norris-LaGuardia Act,
Pan Am argues that intermittent work stoppages are illegal under the RLA because such stoppages are “unprotected” activity under the National Labor Relations Act (“NLRA”),
In any event, intermittent work stoppages are not unfair labor practices under the NLRA. See National Labor Relations Bd. v. Insurance Agents Int’l Union, 361 U.S. 477, 483, 487-88, 492-95, 498, 80 S.Ct. 419, 424, 426-27, 428-30, 432, 4 L.Ed.2d 454 (1960). Rather, some repeated, intermittent work stoppages are merely “unprotected” activity that may legally be the cause of discharge or discipline by the employer. See Robertson Indus., 560 F.2d at 398-99; Shelly & Anderson Furniture Mfg. Co. v. National Labor Relations Bd., 497 F.2d 1200, 1203 (9th Cir.1974). It would indeed be anomalous for us to read into the RLA a prohibition not in the NLRA. The union’s resort to self-help thus violates no specific mandate of the RLA, and the injunctive relief sought by Pan Am is barred by Section 4 of the Norris-LaGuardia Act. See Pan Am., 306 F.2d at 846-47.3
Affirmed.
Notes
. Between April and November 1988, the union wrote to Pan Am’s chairman each month requesting a meeting, and Pan Am responded affirmatively. Nevertheless, no meetings were scheduled.
. Title
It shall be the duty of all carriers, their officers, agents, and employees to exert every reasonable effort to make and maintain agreements concerning rates of pay, rules, and working conditions, and to settle all disputes, whether arising out of the application of such agreements or otherwise, in order to avoid any interruption to commerce or to the operation of any carrier growing out of any dispute between the carrier and the employees thereof.
. We find meritless Pan Am‘s procedural complaints that the district court failed to give adequate de novo consideration to objections to the magistrate’s recommendations and denied Pan Am permission to present additional testimony. Judge Glasser reviewed the record and the magistrate’s recommendation and heard oral argument. That constituted adequate de novo review under