Packet Co. v. SorrelsPacket Co. v. Sorrels
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Battle
On the 25th of May, 1885, Theodoric E. Sorrells filed his complaint in the Jefterson circuit court, alleging, among other things, the following :
That in the year 1830 John W. and James T. Pullen purchased from the United States the land on which the city of Pine Bluff is situated, and in the same year sold a part of the same to one Anthony H. Davis ; that in the year 1838 Davis sold to James J, Ohowning, William II. Pinkard and Henry S. Dawson a three-foúrths interest in th’s land.
That in the year 1838 the then owners of the land caused the same to be surveyed off into lots and blocks, and in the same year filed in the office of the clerk of Jefferson county a plat and plan of the city of Pine Bluff, designating and naming the various streets and alleys and dedicating to public use the streets of the city.
That long after the filing of the plat of the city, plaintiff became the legal owner in fee of lot number 5 in block
That the defendants, John D. Adams, Jas. H. Reed,. John H. Harbin and Samuel Hilzheim, composing the Arkansas River Packet Company, have, in violation of the rights of plaintiff, erected a warehouse in the middle of Dardenne street, within ten feet of the lot, thereby almost completely obstructing said street, and dug a deep ditch at the north end and near the- center of the street for the purpose of making a steamboat landing* That the ditch is so constructed as to reach the river near the north end of said lot, and that the erection and maintenance of the warehouse on said street and the ditch prevent the free use and occupation of the lot and damage his property; and were made without his knowledge and consent.
The complaint then prays that the court make an order restraining and enjoining the defendants from keeping said warehouse any longer in Dardenne street, and that the defendants be required to re‘move the samé from said street and to fill up the ditch.
To this complaint defendants filed an answer, in which they admit that they have a warehouse on the north end of Dardenne street, north of Barraque street, but deny that the same, in any manner interferes with the property of plain tiff, or that by the erection thereof they violated any of his rights, and allege that Dardenne street, north of Barraque street has been’ set apart and designated by the city council of Pine Bluff as the city wharf, and that the ditch complained of by plaintiff was
Plaintiff demurred to the answer because- the facts therein stated are not sufficient to constitute a defense; and the court sustained the demurrer to so much of it as pleads the ordinance of the city council of Pine Bluff as authority for building the warehouse, and in other respects overruled it; and, the defendants refusing to plead further, the court rendered a decree, granting an injunction, and commanding defendants, within thirty days, to move the warehouse from Dardenne street. And defendants appealed.
In Taylor v. Armstrong, 24 Ark., 102, this court held, that the interest which the public acquires by the dedi-. cation of land for a street or other highway,is merely an easement or right of passage over the soil, and that the owner, who made the dedication, still retains the fee, together with all rights of property not inconsistent with the public use; and that a subsequent conveyance by such owner, of a lot on a street laid off and dedicated by, him to the public use, in the absence of a reservation,
Mr. Kent, in his Commentaries, says: “Every thoroughfare which is used by the public, and is, in the language of the English books, ‘common to all the king’s subjects’ is a highway, whether it be a carriage way, a horse way, a foot way, or a navigable river. ‘It is,’ .-ays Lord Holt, ‘the genus of all public ways.’ The law with respect to public highways and to fresh water rivers is the same, and the analogy perfect as concerns the right of soil. The presumption is, that the owners of the land on each side go to the center of the road, and they have the exclusve right to the soil, subject to the right of passage in the public. Being owners of the soil, they have a right to all ordinary remedies for the freehold. They may maintain an action of ejectment- for encroachments upon the road, or an assize if disseized of it, or tresspass against any person who digs up the soil of it, or cuts down any trees growing on the side of the road, and left there for shade or ornament. The freehold and all profits belong to the owners of the adjoining lands. They may carry water in pipes under the highway, and have every use and remedy that is consistent wiih the public servitude or easement‘of a way over it, and with police regulations. The established inference-of law is j that a conveyance of land bounded on a public highway carries with it the fee to the center of the road, as part and parcel of the grant. The idea of an intention in the grantor to withhold his interest in a road to the middle of it, after
The decree of the court below is reversed, and this-cause is remanded with leave to both parties to amend their respective pleadings, if they so desire, and for-further proceedings.