120 Ga. 209 | Ga. | 1904
Reece Owens was convicted of the murder of his father, and complains that the judge refused to grant him a new trial. Besides the general grounds, the motion contains eight special grounds. The rulings in the first three headnotes dispose of the points raised in six of these grounds. In another ground complaint is made that the court erred in admitting evidence which was irrelevant. The evidence was clearly relevant, and whether what the witness said was so unreasonable that it ought not to have been believed was a question for the jury. Another ground complains that while a witness ‘was upon the stand, testifying as to the reputation of the deceased for peace or violence, having said that the worst thing the witness knew about the deceased was that he “ could never be seen without that old Winchester rifle,” the judge remarked, “ that don’t amount to anything; that is one of the constitutional rights of the State, and one of the United States, to bear arms.” The assignment of error upon this language is that it was an expression of an opinion by the court as to the weight to be given the evidence. One’s character for peace or violence is established by general reputation, and a witness will not be permitted, on direct examination, to go further than state what was the general reputation of the person in question for peace or violence. The person calling such witness will not be permitted to inquire into specific acts of violence or particular habits which might throw light upon this question. On cross-examination, however, the witness may be sifted, and inquiry may be made into the conduct of the person on different
