Owens v. GreenOwens v. Green
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Wilson
delivered the opinion of the court:
The plaintiffs, John E. Owens and seventy-nine others, as taxpayers, brought an action in the circuit court of Cook” County against Dwight H. Green, individually, and as Governor of the State, the Chicago Title and Trust Company, individually, and as trustee under a trust agreement dated October 17, 1946, known as Trust No. 33500, Courts Building Corporation, George S. Lurie, individually, and as president of the corporation, the Treasurer, Director of Finance, Director of. Revenue, Director of the Department
From the pleadings it appears that section 4 of Senate Bill No. 417 appropriated to the Department of Finance $6,000,000 for: “Acquisition of state office facilities in the city of Chicago through the purchase or construction .of a building or buildings, including the acquisition of the realty upon which such building or buildings are situated.” Section 4 appropriated an additional $1,852,690 for other purposes and $300,000 “For contingencies: To cover expenditures for purposes for which the amount appropriated in any item above enumerated is or becomes insufficient.”
The sum of $6,000,000, a part of the appropriation made by Senate Bill No. 417, was withdrawn from the treasury of the State and paid to the trustee for the purchase of the Burnham Building. The contract of sale provided that the trustee pay approximately $3,750,000 to the Metropolitan Life Insurance Company to satisfy the first mortgage indebtedness against the property and that the balance be paid to the Courts Building Corporation. The trustee took and holds title to the Burnham Building for the use and benefit of the State of Illinois, as beneficiary of the trust agreement referred to and, since December 31, 1946, has
The foregoing facts are set forth in considerable detail in counts 1 and 2 of plaintiffs’ amended and supplemental complaint. The first count charges the appropriations of $6,000,000- and $300,000, previously mentioned, are unconstitutional and illegal and, in particular, that the appropriation of $6,000,000 contravenes section 16 of article V of our constitution, article III and sections 13, 18 and 33 of article IV.
Count 2 adopts the allegations of the first count and makes the additional allegations that since October 17, 1946, the day the trust agreement was executed, the Chicago Title and Trust Company has usurped the sovereign powers of the State, illegally proceeded to act as owner of the Burnham Building in various specified particulars, and that all of the receipts and payments of moneys by the title company have been, and will continue to be, made without any authority or right whatever and are ex maleficio. Violations of the following constitutional and statutory provisions are alleged to grow out of the “Trust Agreement” plan: Section 17 of article IV of the constitution; sections 1, 2 and 2a of “An Act in relation’ to the payment and disposition of moneys received for or. on behalf of the State;” (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1947, chap. 127, pars. 170, 171, 172;) section x of “An Act in relation to funds or monies’ received by public officers or agents of public or municipal bodiés, by virtue of their offices or positions;” (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1947,
Count 3 charges that, prior to February, 1945, negotiations were had between certain officers of the State and the Courts Building Corporation for the sale of the Burn-ham Building to the State for $5,000,000; that the Governor declared there would be no real-estate brokerage commission paid on any building purchased by the State; that the State refused to pay $5,000,000 for the building; that further negotiations eventually resulted in an option from the Courts Building Corporation to the State on April 17, 1945, giving the latter the right to purchase the building for $4,850,000; that, on April 26, 1945, defendants, or some two or more of them, conspired together to permit the option to be forfeited and to divert illegally from the State treasury $6,000,000 to purchase the same building; that, subsequent to April 26, 1945, the other defendants approved, ratified and confirmed the conspiracies as conceived and, by their acts, deeds and transactions, contributed to, aided and abetted the consummation of the conspiracy, and that, in the perpetration of the conspiracy, the sum of $6,000,000 was illegally withdrawn from the State treasury and delivered to the Chicago Title and Trust Company in violation of the constitution, the statutes and the public policy of the State of Illinois. Count 3 continues by making allegations, among others, that defendants, with knowledge of the existence of the option, on April 26, 1945, included an appropriation of $6,000,000 in Senate Bill No. 417; that there was nothing in the Appropriation Act to apprise the legislature the amount was to be used for the purchase of the Burnham Building; that, pursuant to the conspiracy, the option to buy the property for $4,850,000 was permitted by defendants to terminate, lapse and be forfeited on April 30, 1945; that two or more of the defendants agreed to defer the consummation of the transaction until near the end of
Count 4 contains allegations that the Director of Finance and his assistant, Charles J. McKenna, contacted several real-estate appraisers in Chicago in an effort to obtain from them a written appraisal of a valuation of $4,850,000, or more, on the Burnham Building; that the appraisers refused to make such an appraisal; that the Director of Finance and his assistant were advised by the appraisers the building was not worth the sum named, and that the two State officers then decided to have no appraisal made. Plaintiffs allege, further, that, on April 1, 1945, and April 1, 1946, the assessor of Cook County fixed the fair and full market value of the building at $2,076,476; that this valuation represented the fair and full market value of the property during the calendar years 1945 and 1946; that the nearby Conway Building, located at 111 West Washington Street, was assessed on April 1, .
Concluding allegations of the fourth count are that, prior to the consummation of the conspiracy, the transaction was called to the attention of the Governor by the’ plaintiffs by a petition signed by approximately 300 taxpayers and tenants; that plaintiffs petitioned the Governor for a conference almost daily from October 22 to December 31, 1946,
Certain plaintiffs, conformably to a motion presented during the pendency of this appeal, have been permitted to withdraw as appellants, without prejudice to the merits of the cause, or as to other appellants.
Seeking a reversal, plaintiffs make and argue numerous contentions. Of these, the general contention that plaintiffs’ final pleading sufficiently’ charges a conspiracy on the part of defendants will be first considered. The complaint, in general terms, charges those defendants who are. public officials with unfair, fraudulent and dishonest actions. It abounds in charges that various defendants conspired with one another, but without setting forth adequate facts to make out a conspiracy. In the first place, the presumption obtains’ that the transactions assailed by plaintiffs are fair and honest and that the actions of the defendant public officials were made in good faith and with honest motives. (Racine Fuel Co. v. Rawlins, 377 Ill. 375; Chicago Park Dist. v. Herczel & Co. 373 Ill. 325 ; Tribune Co. v. Thompson, 342 Ill. 503.) It is not enough to merely use the terms “fraud” or “fraudulently” for the adequate reason that the unexplained use of these terms alleges nothing. When used, as here, they are generally deemed expletives — words of abuse. (Dean v. Kellogg, 394 Ill. 495; Anderson
Other allegations relative to the alleged conspiracy place stress upon the fact that the assessed valuation of the Burnham Building on April 1, 1945, and April 1, 1946, was $2,076,476. The assumption that this value was the full and
Numerous allegations pertain to the motive and intention of the General Assembly. Courts have no right to inquire into the motives of the legislature nor into the wisdom or expedience of an act within its legislative power. People ex rel. Huempfner v. Benson, 294 Ill. 236.
Defendants’ motions, to the extent they sought to strike the complaint upon the ground that plaintiffs’ amended and supplemental complaint fails to adequately charge a conspiracy, were properly sustained.
In Martens v. Brady, 264 Ill. 178, the contention was made that three appropriation acts in appropriating money “for the purpose of building and maintaining State aid roads in the several counties of the State,” violated section 16 of article V of the constitution in not specifying the amount for building roads in one item and the amount for maintaining them in another item. Rejecting the argument advanced, this court observed, “Building roads and maintaining them when built are different undertakings, but both are necessary to carry out the general scheme or purpose of the act, which is to provide for better highways throughout
In Mitchell v. Lowden, 288 Ill. 327, the contention was made that an appropriation of $60,000,000, to be derived from the sale of bonds, violated section 16 of article V because it failed to specify the objects and purposes for which the appropriation was made, appropriating to such objects and purposes, respectively, their several amounts in distinct items and sections. This court answered, “The single purpose for which the money appropriated is to be used is the construction of the system of roads. There will, perhaps, be many contracts for the construction of parts of the roads, but each contract is not an item which can be separately stated and for which a definite amount can be appropriated. There will, perhaps, be many contracts for the purchase of material and tools, but each contract of purchase is not an item which can be separately stated and for which a definite amount can be appropriated. Nor is the purchase of all of one kind of material such an item. All are items of the aggregate, but the constitution does
It is evident that obtaining State office facilities in Chicago by purchase and obtaining these same facilities by construction are closely related, in fact, interdependent, as the General Assembly could hardly know in advance whether it would be more practicable to purchase or construct the desired facilities. The mode of accomplishing the single general purpose of providing State office facilities in Chicago is stated in the alternative as a commonsense mode of procedure. The appropriation of $6,000,000 is not subject to the constitutional attack levelled against it merely because the manner of attaining a single purpose, namely, acquiring State office facilities, is stated in the alternative. The appropriation attacked is not vulnerable upon the ground that it is for several items or purposes instead of a single object and purpose, as required by section 16 of article V.
Plaintiffs contend, further, that the Appropriation Act transcends article III of our constitution which provides for the division of powers of our State government among the legislative, executive and judicial departments. The assertion is made that the Appropriation Act attempts to vest in the State officers, members of the executive department, discretion to determine whether the money shall be used for the purchase of a building or buildings, or the construction of a building or buildings, and that the function delegated is legislative. A statute which vests in administrative officers a discretion not only as to the administration of the enactment but, also, the determination of what the law is, or the right to apply it to one and refuse its application to another
Plaintiffs next contend that the Appropriation Act violates section 33 of article IV, which ordains, “The general assembly shall not appropriate out of the state treasury, or expend on account of the new capítol grounds, and construction, completion, and furnishing of the state house, a sum exceeding, in the aggregate, $3,500,000, inclusive of all appropriations heretofore made, without first submitting the proposition for an additional expenditure to the legal voters of the state, at a general election; nor unless a majority of all the votes cast at such election shall be for the proposed additional expenditure.” Plaintiffs’ argument in this regard is that a building for the housing of State office facilities is nothing more or less than a State house and that, in any event, the quoted constitutional provision “should not be given such a narrow construction as to nullify the intent and purpose clearly intended.” The obvious application of section 33 of article IV is solely to appropriations on account of the new capítol grounds and the construction, completion and furnishing of a State house. Plaintiffs’
By their final pleading, plaintiffs, alleged that the Appropriation Act violates section 13 of article IV of the constitution. Their original brief ignores this point except for a single reference in a summary of the pleadings, and we find the issue argued for the first time in plaintiffs’ reply brief. The point has been waived.
Plaintiffs contend, further, that the entire transaction, including all agreements, contracts, the trust agreement, deeds and other documents violate several constitutional and statutory provisions. They urge that the transaction violates section 17 of article IV of the constitution providing, “No money shall be drawn from the treasury except in pursuance of an appropriation made by law, and on the presentation of a warrant issued by the auditor thereon; and no money shall be diverted from any appropriation made for any purpose, or taken from any fund whatever, either by joint or separate resolution.” Plaintiffs’ argument is largely a play on words. They say that the appropriation of $6,000,000 is for the acquisition of State office facilities through the purchase or construction of a building or buildings, including
Apart from the fact that plaintiffs’ allegations fail to disclose any diversion of the money appropriated for the purpose of acquiring State office facilities in Chicago, section 17 of article IV has been held to be directed at diversion of moneys appropriated by the General Assembly, either by joint or separate resolution. Burritt v. Comrs. of State Contracts, 120 Ill. 322.
Although plaintiffs’ complaint does not so charge, they now contend that the transaction in controversy violates section 208 of division I of the Criminal Code (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1947, chap. 38, par. 449,) and section 2 of “An Act to punish fraud or extravagance in the expenditure of moneys appropriated for public improvements.” (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1947, chap. 38, par. 451.) Since these points are being urged for the first time upon review, they are not open to consideration.
The next contention made and argued is that the transaction violates section 2 of “An Act in relation to the payment and disposition of moneys received for or on behalf of the State.” (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1947, chap. 127, par. 170.) This act applies to the officers of the executive department of the State government, the cleric of the Supreme Court, the departments of the State government, and all other officers, boards, commissions, commissioners, departments, institutions, arms or agencies of the executive department of
Plaintiffs next contend that the transaction violates section 28 of the Civil Administrative Code, (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1947, chap. 127, par. 28,) which prescribes that contracts for the construction of buildings for the various departments, or for other construction work in or about buildings, exceeding the estimated value of $1000 shall be let to the lowest responsible bidder. Plaintiffs assert that the agreement for carrying the challenged transaction into effect provided that the trustee would purchase coal for the heating of the building as a private owner of any building, without advertising for bids and without letting the contract to the lowest bidder, and that the trustee would remove the partition walls of the building and remodel the building to make it adaptable for State office facilities, without advertising for bidders on the contracts and without letting them to the lowest bidders. Recourse to the complaint fails to disclose any allegation of facts showing either a violation or a threatened violation of the
Any possible constitutional or statutory doubt cast upon the purchase of the Burnham Building has been removed by an amendment, in the nature of a validating act, to the Civil Administrative Code (Laws of 1947, pp. 16376; Ill. Rev. Stat. 1947, chap. 127, par, 36,) which provides, in part: “With the consent of the Governor, the Department [of Finance] may contract with a responsible person, corporation, firm or trust company skilled in the business of office building management, operation and maintenance, for the management, operation and maintenance of said office building, and in connection therewith it may permit the operation, management and maintenance thereof pursuant to the trust agreement entered into under authority of the appropriation of the Sixty-fourth General Assembly for the acquisition of State office facilities in the City of Chicago. Any such person, corporation, firm or trust company with whom such contract has been or may be entered into shall, under the supervision, and subject to the direction and control of the Department, have authority to exercise the powers and duties herein prescribed.” Where there is no constitutional prohibition, the legislature may, by curative act, validate any proceeding which it might have authorized in advance. (Krause v. Peoria Housing Authority, 370 Ill. 356; People ex rel. Shipton v. Dunleith and Dubuque Bridge Co. 322 Ill. 99; People ex rel. Pillsbury v. Edvander, 304 Ill. 400; People ex rel. Vautrin v. Madison, 280 Ill. 96.) Ratification is as effective in establishing the duties, rights and liabilities of an agency as if the acts ratified had been fully authorized in the first instance. (Larsen v. Thuringia American Ins. Co. 208 Ill. 166.) The principal, if not the only, exception to legislative
Plaintiffs maintain that the Validating Act is unconstitutional, among other reasons, because it embraces in the body of the act a subject or subjects not expressed in the title, contrary to section 13 of article IV which provides, so far as pertinent, “No act hereafter passed shall embrace more than one subject, and that shall be expressed in the title. But if any subject shall be embraced in an act which .shall not be expressed in the title, such act shall be void only as to so much thereof as shall not be so expressed.” The Validating Act is an amendment to section 36 of the Civil Administrative Code. The title of the Validating Act of 1947 is “An Act to amend section 36 of ‘An Act in relation to the civil administration of the State government, and to repeal certain acts therein named,’ approved March 7, 1917, as amended.” Paragraph 14 of section 36 is inserted in the Validating Act and the subsequent paragraphs are renumbered. In other respects, section 36 remains the same as before the amendment. The applicable rule is that if a provision of a statute tends legitimately to accomplish the general objects of the act, the provision does not violate the constitutional requirement that no act shall embrace more than one subject and that such subject shall be embraced in the title. (People v. Chicago Transit Authority, 392 Ill. 77; People ex rel. Greening v. Green, 382 Ill. 577.) Again, “If by fair intendment the provisions in the body of the act have a necessary or proper connection with the title the act is not open to this constitutional objection.” (State of Illinois v. Milauskas, 318 Ill. 198.) The Validating Act of 1947 does not offend section 13 of article IV of the constitution.
Plaintiffs also contend that the Validating Act violates
Plaintiffs claim that the Validating Act violates section 22 of article IV prohibiting the General Assembly from passing local or special laws “Granting to any corporation, association or individual any special or exclusive privilege, immunity or franchise whatever.” The same privilege applies to any corporation or person. An examination of the act discloses that no individual or corporation is given any special privileges. The Validating Act does not mention the Chicago Title and Trust Company by name. The Department of Finance, or its Director, is granted discretion to employ any trust company or corporation. Whether a law is general, local or special, does not depend upon the number of things within the scope of its operation. A law may be general, irrespective of the fact that it operates only in a single place or upon a particular class of persons or things, provided there is a reasonable basis for the classification and every person or place brought within the relations or circumstances described is affected by
Section 22 of article IV, as plaintiffs point out, also provides, “In all other cases where a general law can be made applicable, no special laws shall be enacted.” This provision is addressed only to the General Assembly, and the legislature’s reaction to it is not subject to judicial inquiry. As observed in People ex rel. Brady v. LaSalle Street Trust and Savings Bank, 269 Ill. 518, “This general provision of the constitution is addressed to the judgment and discretion of the legislature, which are not reviewable by the courts.” See: People v. Dunn, 255 Ill. 289.
An additional attack is made against the1 Validating Act upon the ground that it contravenes section 19 of article IV of the constitution which provides, “The general assembly shall never grant or authorize extra compensation, fee or allowance to any public officer, agent, servant or contractor, after service has been rendered or a contract made, nor authorize the payment of any claim, or part thereof, hereafter created against the state under any agreement or contract made without express authority of law; and all such unauthorized agreement or contracts shall be null and void.” Plaintiffs’ pleadings do not contain any allegation of any extra compensation, fee or allowance to the defendant Chicago Title and Trust Company, as trustee. We are of the opinion that plaintiffs’ pleading fails to adequately allege a violation of the constitutional provision invoked.
Under another Validating Act (Laws of 1947, p. 1682,) entitled, “An Act to amend Section 1 of ‘An Act in relation
• The motion of- three defendants for leave to file an answer to plaintiff’s reply brief instcmter has been taken with the case. In their reply brief, plaintiffs raised for the first time the question, among others, of the constitutional validity of the two validating acts of 1947. Both of these acts became effective subsequent to the entry of the decree on June 9, 1947. Defendants have placed reliance upon these statutes to sustain the decree. Answering, plaintiffs attacked the constitutionality of the statutes. In fairness, defendants should be granted an opportunity to answer the points properly made by plaintiffs for the first time in their reply brief. To accomplish this one purpose, defendants’ motion is allowed.
Plaintiffs, in their reply brief, make the following concession with respect to the validating acts of 1947, “If they are valid, and sufficiently comprehensive to validate the transaction, then it is immaterial whether the original transaction was valid or invalid.” The curative acts, are not subject to the charges of unconstitutionality made against them.
For the first time, in their reply brief, plaintiffs challenge the constitutionality of “An Act to add Section 6h to
Finally, plaintiffs contend, as they charged in their pleading, that the Director of Finance failed and neglected to obtain from the Governor an approval in writing for the expenditure of $6,000,000 for the purchase of the Burnhame Building and that the Governor did not, at any time, in writing approve the purpose or amount of the expenditure, as he was required to do by section 14 of the Appropriation Act referred to as Senate Bill No. 417. The Governor has joined in a motion to dismiss the complaint and, from this, it would appear that he approved the expenditure of the money for the purchase of the Burnham Building. Even if the allegation be conceded to be true, the Validating Act of 1947 is a sufficient answer to this final contention of plaintiffs. The General Assembly could have enacted the Appropriation Act without the provision requiring approval of expenditures by the Governor. Since the legislature can, by a curative act, approve what it could have approved in the first place, it follows that the Validating Act of 1947 cures any possible defect existing by failure of the Governor to approve any of the expenditures incident to the purchase of the Burnham Building.
We are not unmindful of the motion made by the defendant State officers who have consistently contended throughout the litigation that this action is, in substance, one against the State of Illinois, contrary to section 26 of article IV of the constitution: “The state of Illinois shall never be made defendant in any court of law or equity.” Where
The decree of the circuit court of Cook County is affirmed.
Decree affirmed.