Osborne v. RiceOsborne v. Rice
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Lumpkin
Unquestionably, a claimant may, by a motion to dismiss the-levy, take advantage of the fact that the judgment upon which the plaintiff in execution relies is a mere nullity, when this fact, appears on the face of the record of the proceedings upon which, such judgment was rendered. Hines v. Kimball, 47 Ga. 588 Krutina v. Culpepper, 75 Ga. 602; Gazan v. Royce, 78 Ga. 512;. Dixon v. Williams, 82 Ga. 108; County v. Thompson, 83 Ga. 270. Or, at his option, the claimant may urge his objection to the introduction in evidence of the record of such proceedings, or move to exclude the plaintiff’s execution, if offered by itself, whenever it appears that the same is for any reason; void, thus rendering it impossible for him to make out his case.. Phillips v. Hyde, 45 Ga. 220; Williams v. Atwood, 52 Ga. 585; Freeman v. Binswanger, 57 Ga. 160; Bosworth v. Clark, 62 Ga. 286; Morton v. Gahona, 70 Ga. 569; Gazan v. Royce, just cited.. As to whether or not one filing a claim is also at liberty to attack the entry of levy on the ground that it is void for uncer*283tainty, the decisions of this court do not seem to be altogether-harmonious. Cohen v. Broughton, 54 Ga. 296; Fambrough v. Amis, 58 Ga. 519; Oatis v. Brown, 59 Ga. 711; Scotty v. Butler, Ibid. 849; Zimmer v. Dansby, 65 Ga. 91; Crine v. Tifts, Ibid. 645; Gunn v. Jones, 67 Ga. 398; Pearce v. Renfroe, 68 Ga. 194; Hudspeth v. Scarborough, 69 Ga. 777; Smith v. Camp, 84 Ga. 117. Certain it is, however,that “A claimant has the right to show that the execution which is levied on the property claimed by him is void or inoperative as a valid process.” Smith v. Lockett, 73 Ga. 105, citing previous decisions. This, is so irrespective of the question whether he is estopped from asserting that no lawful levy has been made, as was distinctly recognized in Pearce v. Renfroe, supra, wherein the rule was announced that: “ The interposition of a claim commits the claimant to the fact of the making a levy, but not to the legality of the process under which it is made.”
Prior to the passage of the act of September 7, 1891 (Acts of 1890-1, p. 76), while an execution which did not follow the judgment upon which it was founded might be “ amended so as to conform” thereto, yet the law in terms provided that “if’ such fi. fa. be levied at the time of the amendment, such levy must fall.” Code of 1882, § 3495. That act expressly repealed the • clause last above quoted, and introduced in lieu thereof the provision that “such amendments shall in no manner affect the validity of the fieri facias, nor shall the levy of said fieri facias fall or be in any manner invalidated thereby.” Civil Code, § 5114. But it by no means follows from this change in the law that an execution which does not conform to the judgment upon which it was issued will, until duly amended, be admissible in evidence against a claimant who-makes timely and proper objection to its introduction. Jn the case at bar, it does not appear that even were the plaintiff’s execution amended so as to conform to the judgment of foreclosure, the obviously fatal defect in his execution would be cured. Presumably it followed the terms of the judgment-upon which it was issued. But however this may be, no offer to amend was in fact made, notwithstanding the execution was-upon its face void for uncertainty.
*284
In view of the foregoing, it is apparent that the trial judge committed grave error in directing a verdict for the plaintiff in execution.
Judgment reversed.
All the Justices concurring.