O'Brien v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.O'Brien v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Benton
BENTON, J.
Keith O‘Brien appeals the judgment entered in favor of State Farm Fire & Casualty Co. (State Farm), which held that he had no uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage under his State Farm personal liability umbrella policy because he had rejected such coverage at the time he applied for the policy. Deciding cross motions for summary judgment, the trial court concluded that State Farm had complied with
I.
We review de novo a final summary judgment rejecting a claim of uninsured motorist coverage. See State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Shaw, 967 So.2d 1011, 1014 n. 2 (Fla. 1st DCA 2007) (citing State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Parrish, 873 So.2d 547, 549 (Fla. 5th DCA 2004)). The sole issue before us is the legal question whether appellant‘s rejection of uninsured motorist coverage under an umbrella policy in 1992 precluded recovery under the policy on account of his daughter‘s death in a 2004 automobile accident. See Smith v. Perry, 635 So.2d 1019, 1020 (Fla. 1st DCA 1994).
II.
The facts are not in dispute. When he purchased the umbrella policy in 1992, Mr. O‘Brien owned three automobiles, and the umbrella policy covered two members of his household.1 Between 1992 and 1997, the annual policy premium increased incrementally from $125 to $264. Effective December 16, 1997, the policy was changed from a Class I to a Class II umbrella policy because a youthful driver was added,2 increasing the annual premium from $264 to $538. In 1999, the premium decreased to $510 based on a decrease in the number of vehicles from three to two. In 2001, the premium increased to $690 as a result of the addition of a second youthful driver and of a third automobile. In 2003, with the addition of a fourth automobile, the premium increased to $1,265. At all times, the policy provided $1,000,000 in personal liability coverage.
When he purchased the umbrella policy from State Farm on October 16, 1992, Mr. O‘Brien signed a form application under the following language:
REJECTION OF UNINSURED/UNDERINSURED MOTOR VEHICLE COVERAGE
In keeping with the laws of my state, I have been offered the opportunity to purchase Uninsured/Underinsured Motor Vehicle Coverage, and I hereby reject the opportunity to purchase this option as part of this application. [X] I reject Uninsured/Underinsured Motor Vehicle Coverage on all vehicles.
[] I reject Uninsured/Underinsured Motor Vehicle Coverage on recreational vehicles only.
I understand and agree that this acknowledgement of rejection shall be applicable to the policy applied for, all future renewals of the policy and on all replacement policies, until I make written request to add this coverage.
He never sought to rescind this rejection of uninsured motorist coverage under the umbrella policy and never communicated with State Farm on the subject.
At no time after the initial application did State Farm raise or in any way revisit the question of uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage. In making uninsured motorist coverage available to Mr. O‘Brien at the time he applied for the umbrella policy in 1992, State Farm complied with one of its obligations under
On the date of his daughter‘s death, appellant was a named insured on four State Farm automobile policies, as well as on the umbrella policy. Within three months of the accident, State Farm tendered checks for $400,000, the full amount of uninsured motorist coverage under the (stacked) automobile policies. At issue on appeal is the availability of (up to $1,000,000) of excess coverage under the umbrella policy.
III.
Under
Subsection (2) explicitly provides that the requirements of subsection (1) do not apply to non-primary policies. See
Subsection (2) of
(2) The limits of uninsured motorist coverage shall be not less than the limits of bodily injury liability insurance purchased by the named insured, or such lower limit complying with the rating plan of the company as may be selected by the named insured. The limits set forth in this subsection, and the provisions of subsection (1) which require uninsured motorist coverage to be provided in every motor vehicle policy delivered or issued for delivery in this state,
do not apply to any policy which does not provide primary liability insurance that includes coverage for liabilities arising from the maintenance, operation, or use of a specifically insured motor vehicle. However, an insurer issuing such a policy shall make available as a part of the application for such policy, and at the written request of an insured, limits up to the bodily injury liability limits contained in such policy or $1 million, whichever is less.
Section 627.727(1) mandates that a primary policy include UM coverage unless an informed, knowing, written rejection of such coverage is made by the insured on the proper form. The purpose of this is “to assure that an insured appreciates the availability of UM coverage and makes a knowledgeable and deliberate decision to accept or reject it.” Travelers Ins. Co. v. Quirk, 583 So.2d 1026, 1029 (Fla.1991).On the other hand,
section 627.727(2) does not contain the same requirements. Basically it only requires an issuer of a non-primary policy to notify an applicant of the availability of UM coverage. [Id.].
Tres, 705 So.2d at 645 (footnote omitted). Here State Farm notified Mr. O‘Brien that uninsured motorist coverage was available under the umbrella policy. Acknowledging in writing that he had been offered an opportunity to purchase this coverage, Mr. O‘Brien rejected the opportunity in writing.
IV.
But he argues that he is entitled to uninsured motorist coverage under the umbrella policy because changes were made to the policy from time to time, including the addition of new “exposures” on account of newly registered or garaged vehicles. He relies particularly on Strochak v. Federal Insurance Co., 717 So.2d 453 (Fla.1998), for the proposition that State Farm was required to renotify him that he could purchase uninsured motorist coverage when, in 2003, he acquired two new vehicles that had not previously been registered in Florida.6
In Strochak, a three-justice plurality opinion of the Supreme Court of Florida answered the following certified question from the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit (as restated by the plurality) in the affirmative:
Whether an excess carrier has a duty to make available the uninsured motorists (UM) coverage required by
section 627.727(2), Florida Statutes (Supp.1990) , to an insured under an existing policy on vehicles which had never been registered or principally garaged in Florida when any vehicle, covered or subsequently added, first becomes registered or principally garaged in Florida and when the policy is delivered or issued for delivery in Florida.
717 So.2d at 454. A concurring justice (while joining the plurality on the choice of law question7) made clear that, the insured
The plurality‘s affirmative answer to the certified question was thus qualified by limiting it to situations where (as in Strochak) the policy was initially “delivered or issued for delivery in Florida.” 717 So.2d at 454. The plurality opinion itself said that “[t]he duty to offer excess UM coverage was created in June 1990, when the excess motor vehicle liability policy was first delivered in Florida and included coverage for the 1984 Lincoln.” Id. at 455. Although the certified question in Strochak referred, moreover, to an insurer‘s duty under an existing excess policy, the plurality concluded that “the 1990 Masterpiece policy that provided excess liability coverage for the 1984 Lincoln was not the same policy that was issued and delivered in New Jersey in 1985,” noting that the 1990 policy had been issued to a different named insured, contained a different policy number, and provided different coverage than the 1985 policy.8 Id. at 455 (emphasis supplied, footnote omitted).
Here we are concerned with the same umbrella policy initially issued in Florida in 1992 to the same named insured, bearing the same policy number and providing
V.
Relying on statutory changes to
In 1984, the legislature for the first time explicitly exempted policies which do not provide primary liability insurance for specifically insured motor vehicles from the requirements set forth in subsection (1). The legislature amended subsection (2), in relevant part, as follows:
(2) (a) The limits of uninsured motorist coverage shall be not less than the limits of bodily injury liability insurance purchased by the named insured, or such lower limit complying with the rating plan of the company as may be selected by the named insured. The limits set forth in this subsection and the provisions of subsection (1) requiring uninsured motorist coverage to be provided in every motor vehicle policy delivered or issued for delivery in this state, shall not apply to any policy which does not provide primary liability insurance which includes coverage for liabilities arising from the maintenance, operation, or use of a specifically insured motor vehicle. However, the insurer issuing such policies shall make available
as a part of the application, and at the written request of the insured, limits up to the bodily injury liability limits contained in such policies....
Ch. 84-41, § 1, at 95-96, Laws of Fla. The House of Representatives’ Final Staff Analysis explains that, as amended, subsection (2) exempts “excess or umbrella-type policies” from the “written rejection” requirements of subsection (1):
The bill limits the applicability of the uninsured motorist requirements to liability policies covering specifically insured or identified motor vehicles.... The bill also limits the applicability of the written rejection and minimum limit requirements to policies providing primary liability coverage for a motor vehicle. Therefore, such requirements would not apply to excess or umbrella-type policies which may cover specific vehicles, but which provide excess coverage over a layer of primary coverage. However, the insurer issuing such excess policies must make available as part of the application and at the written request of the insured, UM limits up to the bodily injury liability limits contained in such policies.
Hooper v. Zurich Ins. Co., 789 So.2d 368, 369-70 (Fla. 2d DCA 2001) (quoting Fla. H.R., CS/HB 319 (1984) Staff Analysis (final June 21, 1984)).
The language in
VI.
Appellant also relies on Fireman‘s Fund Ins. Co. v. Pohlman, 485 So.2d 418, 420 (Fla.1986), where our supreme court held that an insured entered a “separate and severable contract of insurance” when an automobile policy endorsement added coverage for an additional vehicle after
But, as Pohlman itself and as other courts have noted, Pohlman is inapplicable in the context of determining whether the addition of a new vehicle to an existing policy creates a new policy requiring the insurer to offer the insured a new opportunity to reject uninsured motorist coverage pursuant to
VII.
Finally, appellant argues that he is entitled to receive uninsured motorist coverage under the umbrella policy because the written rejection of coverage he signed in 1992 was ambiguous. The form rejection applies to “the policy applied for, all future renewals of the policy[,] and ... all replacement policies,” but does not mention policies which “extend[ ], change[ ], [or] supersede[ ]” an existing policy.
By making uninsured motorist coverage available to appellant when he initially applied for the umbrella policy in 1992, State Farm fulfilled its first — and what proved to be its only — obligation under
VIII.
We accept the premise that precise compliance with statutory requirements is necessary
Affirmed.
WOLF and BROWNING, JJ., concur.
Notes
We actually have four classes for our umbrella line. The first class is our preferred, Class 1 and that‘s where there‘s no youthful operators, no accidents or charges and all the underlying coverage is with State Farm. And then our Class 2 is the same as our Class 1 expect [sic] for the existence of a youthful operator.
(1) No motor vehicle liability insurance policy which provides bodily injury liability coverage shall be delivered or issued for delivery in this state with respect to any specifically insured or identified motor vehicle registered or principally garaged in this state unless uninsured motor vehicle coverage is provided therein or supplemental thereto for the protection of persons insured thereunder who are legally entitled to recover damages from owners or operators of uninsured motor vehicles because of bodily injury, sickness, or disease, including death, resulting therefrom. However, the coverage required under this section is not applicable when, or to the extent that, an insured named in the policy makes a written rejection of the coverage on behalf of all insureds under the policy.... Unless an insured ... requests such coverage or requests higher uninsured motorist limits in writing, the coverage or such higher uninsured motorist limits need not be provided in or supplemental to any other policy which renews, extends, changes, supersedes, or replaces an existing policy with the same bodily injury liability limits when an insured ... had rejected the coverage.
The rejection or selection of lower limits shall be made on a form approved by the office. The form shall fully advise the applicant of the nature of the coverage and shall state that the coverage is equal to bodily injury liability limits unless lower limits are requested or the coverage is rejected. The heading of the form shall be in 12-point bold type and shall state: “You are electing not to purchase certain valuable coverage which protects you and your family or you are purchasing uninsured motorist limits less than your bodily injury liability limits when you sign this form. Please read carefully.”
Unlike the excess policy in Strochak, which, when it was issued and delivered in Florida in 1990, was issued to a different named insured than that issued in 1985, had a different policy number from the original 1985 excess policy, and contained different terms from the 1985 policy, the policy at issue here was issued to the same insured and retained the same policy number from 1992 forward. The only changes to the umbrella policy from 1992 through 2004 were the number of underaged drivers covered (and the resulting change from Class I to Class II), the number of automobile exposures, and the annual premiums.
While the facts of Strochak led the supreme court to conclude that the policy issued to Donald Strochak in New Jersey in 1985 was a different policy from the one issued to Rita Strochak in Florida in 1990, the facts here indicate that, despite alterations in the policy, appellant held the same policy from 1992 through 2004. Unlike the excess policy at issue in Strochak, which, at the time of application, issued in New Jersey and covered no vehicles registered or principally garaged in Florida, appellant applied for the umbrella at issue here in Florida, the policy was issued and delivered in Florida in 1992, and all renewal notices were mailed to appellant at his Florida address.
An earlier version of subsection (1) provided only that the insurer need not provide uninsured motorist coverage previously rejected “in or supplemental to a renewal policy” but did not mention policies which extend, change, supersede, or replace existing policies,