History
  • No items yet
midpage
Nyman v. Lynde
93 Minn. 257
Minn.
1904
Check Treatment
DOUGLAS, J.

Appeal by defendant from an order overruling his motion for a new trial.

Plaintiff recovered a verdict in the sum of $500 for damages resulting from an assault upon and criminal abuse of his minor daughter. Upon the trial defendant moved to strike out certain evidence offered tending to show the illness of the minor subsequent to the assault complained of, on the ground that it did not appear such illness resulted therefrom (not that it was inadmissible under the pleadings). An examination of the record convinces us that some evidence was offered tending to show that her illness was caused thereby. While the evidence was meager, we are of the opinion it fairly presented an issue of fact for the jury. Plowever, independent of any competent proof of subsequent illness, the verdict cannot be deemed excessive; therefore, if error was committed by the trial court in refusing to strike out the evidence introduced, it was without prejudice.

*258We are also of the opinion the court did not err in excluding evidence involving the general character of said minor subsequent to the assault complained of Stoudt v. Shepherd, 73 Mich. 588, 597, 41 N. W. 696 Shewalter v. Bergman, 123 Ind. 155, 23 N. E. 686; McKern v. Calvert, 59 Mo. 243.

Other errors assigned are not prejudicial to the substantial rights of appellant, and do not constitute reversible error.

Following Gardner v. Kellogg, 23 Minn. 463, this form of action brought by the father of a minor child so assaulted will lie. Lavery v. Crooke, 52 Wis. 612, 9 N. W. 599; Dalman v. Koning, 54 Mich. 320, 20 N. W. 61; Kennedy v. Shea, 110 Mass. 147.

Order affirmed.

Case Details

Case Name: Nyman v. Lynde
Court Name: Supreme Court of Minnesota
Date Published: Nov 4, 1904
Citation: 93 Minn. 257
Docket Number: Nos. 14,067—(102)
Court Abbreviation: Minn.
AI-generated responses must be verified and are not legal advice.
Your Notebook is empty. To add cases, bookmark them from your search, or select Add Cases to extract citations from a PDF or a block of text.