Norma J. Nesbit v. Gears Unlimited, IncNorma J. Nesbit v. Gears Unlimited, Inc
- Reporters:
- , , , ,
- Before:
- Ambro
OPINION OF THE COURT
AMBRO, Circuit Judge.
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits companies employing “fifteen or more” persons from discriminating on the basis of sex in hiring, discharge, compensation, or terms of employment.
I. FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
In 1973, Vaughn Winter, Sr. (“Vaughn Sr.”) founded Winters, which manufactures “rear ends” for high-performance automobiles. In 1990, he acquired Gears, a transmission parts manufacturer. Vaughn Sr. and his wife, Madeline Winter (“Madeline”), also formed Maverick Industries, Inc. (“Maverick”), which warehouses automotive parts, including parts produced at Winters. At the time of the events relating to this suit - December 1994 through August 1997 - Vaughn Sr. had a stake in three automotive companies: Gears, Winters, and Maverick.
The Winter family shares ownership and control of these three companies. Vaughn Sr. owns ten percent of Gears, with the remainder held in trust in equal shares for his children-Nina and Vaughn Jr. Vaughn Sr. is president of Gears and his children are corporate officers. He and Madeline own Winters and Maverick in equal shares. He is president of Winters and Maverick, and Madeline is the Secretary/Treasurer at Winters.
Gears and Winters occupy separate plants about one mile apart in York, Pennsylvania. In almost all respects, they operate independently. Their products are distinct-Gears produces transmissions and Winters produces automotive rear ends - and each company has its own equipment and production lines. Winters contracts to buy parts from Gears at market rates. The companies maintain separate financial records and payrolls, write separate checks, and file separate tax returns.
Vaughn Sr. monitors operations at both Gears and Winters. While he participates in day-to-day management at Winters, Gears is managed by Randy Lau. Vaughn Sr. testified that he visits the Gears facility only about twice a month, usually because a machine has broken down. Nesbit disputes this testimony, contending that Vaughn Sr. spends time at Gears “pretty much every day.”
The only area in which Gears and Winters cooperate considerably is in hiring. Typically, if either Gears or Winters has an opening, a Winters employee will place a “help wanted” sign on the street in front of the Winters building. Prospective employees obtain applications at the Winters front office and return them there as well. If Winters is hiring, either Vaughn Sr. or his wife will invite qualified applicants for an interview. If Gears has an opening, someone at Winters will communicate with the applicant on Lau’s behalf and then direct him or her to the Gears plant to interview with Lau. The hiring decision is then Lau’s “prerogative.” However, Vaughn Sr. (who, as noted above, normally does not participate in Gears management) can request that Gears hire a particular applicant and Gears will generally do so. Either Lau or the Winter children normally decide whether to terminate an employee, but Vaughn Sr. testified that he could ask Gears to fire an employee who engaged in significant misconduct.
On December 14, 1994, Nesbit submitted a standard employment application to Winters for a machine operator position. That day, either Vaughn Sr. or Madeline interviewed her.
1
The interviewer con-
Nesbit remained at Gears for two years and eight months. She perceived that Lau was her “boss” and was “more or less in charge” at Gears. Occasionally she also worked an extra shift at Winters following her regular shift at Gears. She would punch out on the time clock at Gears and then punch in at Winters. When working a Winters shift, she received a separate paycheck. Her hours at the two plants were not consolidated for overtime pay.
On August 19, 1997, Nesbit’s machine at Gears “crashed,” leaving it unusable without repairs. Nesbit became upset, which apparently caused her to develop a headache and neck pains. She informed the acting supervisor, Greg Pell, that she was leaving work to visit her chiropractor. When she returned the next day, Lau was on vacation, and Vaughn Sr. discharged her for insubordination.
After receiving permission from the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Nesbit filed suit in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania alleging that Gears discriminated against her because of gender. Gears moved to dismiss the complaint under
Nesbit then filed an amended complaint alleging that Gears and its “associate corporation” Winters Transmission, Inc. - a company different from Winters that Vaughn Sr. owned from 1955 to 1985 - were really a single employer with more than fifteen employees. Gears moved again for a dismissal, this time observing that the entity called ‘Winters Transmission, Inc.” had ceased operation long before Nesbit began working at Gears. Nesbit then filed a second amended complaint, alleging that Gears and Winters are associate corporations that together meet the fifteen-employee threshold. On the basis of that allegation, the District Court ordered discovery limited to the question whether Gears and Winters constitute a single employer under Title VII. Following discovery, the District Court issued a memorandum and order in which it concluded that Gears and Winters are separate entities and, because Gears unquestionably employs fewer than fifteen persons by itself, dismissed Nesbit’s complaint for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. This appeal followed.
II. DISCUSSION
A. Is the Number of Employees a Jurisdictional Requirement?
We first address whether Title VIPs fifteen-employee threshold is a jurisdictional prerequisite - as the District Court believed it was in dismissing Nesbit’s complaint pursuant to
1. Relevant Caselaw
The question whether Title VU’s fifteen-employee threshold is a jurisdictional prerequisite when a plaintiff brings a color-able Title VII claim has divided the courts of appeals. 3 The Second and Seventh Circuits conclude that it is a substantive element that the plaintiff must prove unless the claim that there are fifteen employees is so obviously unfounded that it fails to raise a genuine federal controversy. Da Silva, 229 F.3d at 364-65 (2d Cir.); Johnson v. Apna Char, Inc., 330 F.3d 999, 1001-02 (7th Cir.2003), petition for cert. filed, 72 U.S.L.W. 3171 (U.S. Sept. 2, 2003) (No. 03-354); Papa v. Katy Indus., Inc., 166 F.3d 937, 943 (7th Cir.1999); Sharpe v. Jefferson Distrib. Co., 148 F.3d 676, 677-678 (7th Cir.1998). Moreover, the D.C. Circuit has held the Americans with Disabilities Act’s (“ADA”) fifteen-employee threshold an element of the merits. EEOC v. St. Francis Xavier Parochial Sch., 117 F.3d 621, 623-25 (D.C.Cir.1997). In this context, the ADA’s fifteen-employee requirement is in all relevant respects indistinguishable from Title VII’s.
By contrast, the Fifth, Sixth,- Ninth, Tenth, and Eleventh Circuits have said that the fifteen-employee threshold is ju
The division is deeper than merely inter-circuit. Even within certain circuits that have held Title VII’s fifteen-employee threshold jurisdictional, there is conflict. While in Owens the Tenth Circuit assumed (without analysis) that the requirement is jurisdictional, in Wheeler v. Hurdman, 825 F.2d 257 (10th Cir.1987), that Court held that the fifteen-employee threshold is both jurisdictional and “intertwined with the merits of the case,” and therefore should have been resolved as if on the merits. Id. at 259.
The Eleventh Circuit is similarly conflicted. In Garcia v. Copenhaver, Bell & Associates, M.D.’s, P.A., 104 F.3d 1256 (11th Cir.1997), the Court opined that the Age Discrimination in Employment Act’s twenty-employee threshold “goes to the merits of an ADEA case.” Id. at 1258. It reasoned that “the section of the ADEA that provides the substantive relief’ - the section forbidding an employer from discriminating - “is intertwined and dependent on the section of the ADEA that defines the scope of the act” - the section defining “employer” as one who employs more than twenty employees. Id. at 1263. However, in a later case, Scarfo, 175 F.3d 957, the Eleventh Circuit dismissed a plaintiffs Title VII claim for lack of subject matter jurisdiction when the defendant fell short of fifteen employees. A third case, Morrison v. Amway Corp., 323 F.3d 920 (11th Cir.2003), recognized this intra-circuit conflict and essentially joined both camps. It stated that, in the FMLA context, a fifty-employee threshold “implicate[s] both jurisdiction and the underlying merits.” Id. at 929 (emphasis added). However, it held that Garcia correctly disposed of the issue as a matter of procedure: “the district court was required to find that jurisdiction exists and deal with the objection as a direct attack on the merits of plaintiffs case” because of the degree to which the jurisdictional and merits inquiries were intertwined. Id. at 929-30 (internal quotation marks omitted). 5
With this conflict in mind, we begin our determination by noting that subject matter jurisdiction is the “courts’ statutory or constitutional
power
to adjudicate” particular cases.
Steel Co. v. Citizens for a Better Env’t,
523 U.S. 83, 89, 118 S.Ct. 1003, 140 L.Ed.2d 210 (1998) (emphasis in original).
Steel Co.
requires that courts normally should not conflate subject matter jurisdiction with elements of an action’s merits. The Supreme Court held that the elements of another federal statute - the Emergency Planning and Community Right-To-Know Act of 1986 (“EPCRA”),
The District Court concluded that EP-CRA does not support suits for past violations and therefore dismissed the plaintiffs complaint under both
‘^Jurisdiction . . . is not defeated . . . by the possibility that the averments might fail to state a cause of action on which petitioners could actually recover.’ Rather, the district court has jurisdiction if ‘the right of the petitioners to recover under their complaint will be sustained if the Constitution and laws of the United States are given one construction and will be defeated if they are given another....’
Id. at 89, 118 S.Ct. 1003 (quoting Bell v. Hood, 327 U.S. 678, 685, 66 S.Ct. 773, 90 L.Ed. 939 (1946)).
We presaged
Steel Co.
in a case decided five years earlier. In
Growth Horizons, Inc. v. Delaware County,
983 F.2d 1277, 1280-81 (3d Cir.1993), the District Court dismissed a claim under the Fair Housing Act for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. The Fair Housing Act makes it unlawful,
inter alia,
“[t]o discriminate in the sale or rental, or to otherwise make unavailable or deny, a dwelling to any buyer or renter because of a handicap.”
Turning to Title VII, we note that those courts that have held the fifteen-employee requirement jurisdictional have provided no reasons for their holding; rather, they
3. Most Plausible Arguments for Making Fifteen-Employee Requirement Jurisdictional
a. Commerce Clause Argument
Perhaps the most plausible reason for finding that the fifteen-employee requirement is jurisdictional is that it concerns a “dispute! ] as to the existence of a fact that is essential to a constitutional exercise of Congress’s power to regulate.”
Da Silva,
229 F.3d at 363 (suggesting this as a situation “[l]ess clearly placed on one side of the jurisdiction/merits line”). As discussed, Title VII applies to “employers” and defines an “employer” (in relevant part) as “a person engaged in an industry affecting commerce who has fifteen or more employees.”
This argument, while well-made, nonetheless is unconvincing. First, the very wording of
Even assuming that Congress lacks authority to enact a statute does not mean that a federal court lacks jurisdiction to review actions brought under that statute. When disposing of a claim brought under an unconstitutional statute, courts ordinarily deny the claim on the merits, on the ground that the statute under which relief is sought is unconstitutional, rather than for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. Martin v. United Way of Erie County, 829 F.2d 445, 447 (3d Cir.1987); Kulick v. Pocono Downs Racing Ass’n, Inc., 816 F.2d 895 (3d Cir.1987) (noting the difference between congressional jurisdiction and federal courts’ Article III jurisdiction, and concluding that “[elements of a claim that are called jurisdictional because they relate to Congress’s jurisdiction remain questions of the merits”); see also Plaut v. Spendthrift Farm, Inc., 789 F.Supp. 231 (E.D.Ky.1992), aff‘d, 1 F.3d 1487 (6th Cir.1993), aff ‘d, 514 U.S. 211, 115 S.Ct. 1447, 131 L.Ed.2d 328 (1995).
b. Jurisdictional Statements in Other Supreme Court Cases
EEOC v. Arabian American Oil Co.,
499 U.S. 244, 111 S.Ct. 1227, 113 L.Ed.2d 274 (1991), can be read to suggest that the fifteen-employee requirement is jurisdictional. In that case, the Supreme Court decided whether Title VII “applies extra-territorially to regulate the employment practices of United States employers who employ United States citizens abroad.”
Id.
at 246, 111 S.Ct. 1227. The Court addressed the question not as whether Title VII granted plaintiffs a cause of action for extraterritorial violations, but rather whether Title VII granted extraterritorial jurisdiction,
see id.
at 250, 111 S.Ct. 1227, and affirmed the dismissal of the complaint for lack of jurisdiction.
Id.
at 259,
By analogy, some may find
EEOC v. Commercial Office Products Co.,
486 U.S. 107, 108 S.Ct. 1666, 100 L.Ed.2d 96 (1988), to counsel for finding jurisdictional the fifteen-employee requirement. In that case, the Supreme Court stated that “Title VII does not give the EEOC jurisdiction to enforce the Act against employers of fewer that 15 employees.”
Id.
at 119, 108 S.Ct. 1666 n.5. But this does not address the question before us. Title VII grants the EEOC power “to prevent any person from engaging in any unlawful employment practice.”
4. Judicial Administration Reasons for Fifteen-Employee Requirement Being an Element of a Title VII Claim rather than a Jurisdictional Requirement
As a policy matter - which is ultimately the gut of our inquiry - it also makes little sense to regard the fifteen-employee threshold as jurisdictional. Such a holding would require a federal court to determine whether a company had fifteen employees during the relevant period, even if the parties so stipulated. To require a federal court to engage in such a fact-intensive inquiry sua sponte - which might in some cases require a federal appellate court to dig through an extensive record, including pay stubs and time sheets - appears to be a waste of scarce judicial resources, and we doubt that Congress intended such a result. See Da Silva, 229 F.3d at 365 (“[Ijnstitutional requirements of a judicial system weigh in favor of narrowing the number of facts or circumstances that determine subject matter jurisdiction.”); Sharpe, 148 F.3d at 678 (“Surely the number of employees is not the sort of question a court (including appellate court) must raise on its own....”).
To hold the requirement jurisdictional also implies that a court would need to decide whether an entity employed more than fifteen individuals before reaching a Title VII action’s merits - even if the merits were more easily resolved than the “jurisdictional” question. Steel Co., 523 U.S. at 94-95, 118 S.Ct. 1003. This result too is undesirable.
* sjt & * * *
In this context, we hold that, while the matter is not free from doubt, the fifteen-employee threshold is a substantive element (whether an “employer” exists) of a Title VII claim and is not jurisdictional. Federal jurisdiction is implicated only when the Title VII claim “clearly appears to be immaterial and made solely for the purpose of obtaining jurisdiction or where such a claim is wholly insubstantial or frivolous,” Steel Co., 523 U.S. at 89, 118 S.Ct. 1003, neither of which is the case here.
As the District Court looked beyond Nesbit’s complaint and reviewed discovery on whether Gears employs more than fifteen people, it should have resolved the issue under the summary judgment standard rather than as a motion for judgment on the pleadings.
1. The National Labor Relations Board’s “Integrated Enterprise” Test
Several courts of appeals have borrowed a four-part test - commonly called the “integrated enterprise” test or the “single employer” test - from the National Labor Relations Board (“NLRB”) to determine when two nominally distinct companies should be treated as a single entity under Title VII. See Anderson v. Pacific Maritime Association, 336 F.3d 924, 929 (9th Cir.2003); RC Aluminum Industries, Inc. v. National Labor Relations Board, 326 F.3d 235, 239 (D.C.Cir.2003); Parker v. Columbia Pictures Indus., 204 F.3d 326, 341 (2d Cir.2000); Artis v. Francis Howell North Band Booster Ass’n, Inc., 161 F.3d 1178, 1184 (8th Cir.1998); Frank v. U.S. West, Inc., 3 F.3d 1357, 1362 (10th Cir.1993); McKenzie, 834 F.2d at 933; Childs, 719 F.2d at 1382-83; Armbruster, 711 F.2d at 1336-38; Trevino v. Celanese Corp., 701 F.2d 397, 403-04 (5th Cir.1983). The four factors of the NLRB test are “(1) interrelation of operations, (2) common management, (3) centralized control of labor relations, and (4) common ownership or financial control.” Artis, 161 F.3d at 1184 (citation omitted); see also NLRB v. Browning-Ferris Indus, of Pa., 691 F.2d 1117, 1122 (3d Cir.1982) (discussing the test in the labor context). Among these factors, “[n]o single factor is dispositive; rather, single employer status under this test ‘ultimately depends on all the circumstances of the case.’ ” Pearson v. Component Tech. Corp., 247 F.3d 471, 486 (3d Cir.2001) (describing but not adopting the test in a case applying the Worker Adjustment Retraining Notification Act) (citation omitted). “[T]he heart of the inquiry is whether there is an absence of an arm’s-length relationship among the companies.” Knowlton v. Teltrust Phones, Inc., 189 F.3d 1177, 1184 (10th Cir.1999) (citations omitted); Browning-Ferris, 691 F.2d at 1122. Moreover, “[cjourts applying this four-part standard in Title VII and related cases have focused on the second factor: centralized control of labor relations.” Trevino, 701 F.2d at 404.
The Seventh Circuit has rejected the NLRB’s four-factor test as unhelpful in the anti-discrimination context. Papa v. Katy Indus., Inc., 166 F.3d 937, 942-43 (7th Cir.1999). In addition, other courts have occasionally listed, but essentially ignored, the NLRB factors in Title VII cases, focusing instead on which entity actually made the allegedly discriminatory employment decision. See, e.g., Lusk v. Foxmeyer Health Corp., 129 F.3d 773, 777 (5th Cir.1997); see also Marc Crandley, Note, The Failure of the Integrated Enterprise Test: Why Courts Need to Find New Answers to the Multiple-Employer Puzzle in Federal Discrimination Cases, 75 Ind. L.J. 1041, 1059-71 (2000) (arguing against application of the NLRB test in the Title VII context and presenting alternative options).
Because the NLRA and Title VII ask whether entities are a single enterprise for different reasons, it does not follow that the NLRB’s test is any more relevant to Title VII cases than any of the other tests for determining whether two companies should be regarded as one. To the contrary, for purposes of determining whether two companies are a single employer, the NLRA’s policy goals point in a different direction than Title VU’s. As discussed, a significant purpose of the fifteen-employee minimum in the Title VII context is to spare small companies the considerable expense of complying with the statute’s many-nuanced requirements. See Papa, 166 F.3d at 940; Armbruster, 711 F.2d at 1337 n. 4 (reviewing the legislative history behind the fifteen-employee minimum). This goal suggests that the fifteen-employee minimum should be strictly construed. By contrast, the NLRB’s jurisdiction was intended to be expansive, suggesting a more lenient test for labor cases. See Crandley, supra, at 1065-66. Thus we deem there is little reason to refer to the NLRB’s test in deciding whether two entities should together be considered an “employer” for Title VII purposes. We instead adopt a different framework, tailored to Title VII’s policy goals.
2. Our Framework
In Papa, the Seventh Circuit developed its own test to determine whether two nominally distinct entities should be considered as one for Title VII purposes. The Court began with the “basic principle of affiliate liability[,] . . . that an affiliate forfeits its limited liability only if it acts to forfeit it.” Id. at 941 (emphasis in original). It proceeded to find three situations in the Title VII context when a company and its affiliates forfeit limited liability and thus are deemed a single employer: (1) where a company has split itself into entities with less than fifteen employees with the intent to evade Title VII’s reach; (2) when a parent company has directed the subsidiary’s discriminatory act of which the plaintiff is complaining; or (3) when a court would otherwise pierce the corporate veil (i.e., look behind the corporate form to hold a corporation’s shareholders personally liable). Id. at 940-41.
We too will consider a company and its affiliates a single employer under Title VII(l) when a company has split itself into entities with less than fifteen employees intending to evade Title VII’s
a.Splitting a Single Company into Two or More to Evade Title VII
When a plaintiff proves that a company has split itself into multiple entities to evade coverage under Title VII, we consider those entities a single company for purposes of meeting the fifteen-employee threshold. “The privilege of separate incorporation is not intended to allow enterprises to duck their statutory duties.” Id. at 941.
A plaintiff need not prove that evading Title VII was the only reason that a business split itself into multiple entities. Rather, it must make a prima facie case that this was a substantial motivating factor, after which the burden will shift to the defendant to produce evidence rebutting the plaintiffs proof. Relevant to a prima facie case are considerations such as (1) lack of a reasonable business justification, (2) whether the business split was one that, as an operational matter, would more sensibly be contained within a single business entity (e.g., the two companies make the same product or inputs for the same product), and (3) statements from those familiar with the industry suggesting that the company was split into multiple entities to evade Title VII.
b. Parent Directing Subsidiary’s Act
When the companies sought to be aggregated for Title VII purposes are in a parent-subsidiary relationship, we shall deem a parent and subsidiary a single employer when the parent has directed the subsidiary to perform the allegedly discriminatory act in question. By directing such an act, the parent disregards the separate corporate existence of the subsidiary and thus forfeits the right to be treated as a separate entity for Title VII purposes. Moreover, in such a situation the parent itself has committed the act in question and thus should share responsibility with the subsidiary. See Papa, 166 F.3d at 941.
c. Substantive Consolidation
Absent either of the first two situations, we shall look to the factors courts use in deciding whether substantively to consolidate two or more entities in the bankruptcy context. While these factors vary from circuit to circuit, the test at base seeks to determine whether two or more entities’ affairs are so interconnected that they collectively caused the alleged discriminatory employment practice. More colloquially, the question is whether the “eggs” - consisting of the ostensibly separate companies - are so scrambled that we decline to unscramble them. We note, however, that substantive consolidation is an equitable remedy and is difficult to achieve. 7
S. Application of Our Disjunctive Test
Under the standard just discussed, and viewing the facts in the light most favorable to Nesbit, we nonetheless hold that no reasonable jury would consider Gears and Winters a single employer under Title VII for purposes of the fifteen-employee requirement. First, there is no record evidence that Gears and Winters split themselves into separate entities to evade Title VII. Nor has Nesbit alleged that Gears and Winters hold themselves out as one entity or that they remain separate only to evade anti-discrimination laws. On the contrary, such a claim is implausible, as Vaughn Sr. assumed his ownership interests in Gears and Winters seventeen years apart, and the two companies produce different products.
Second, because Gears and Winters do not have a parent-subsidiary relationship, the second situation for combining employees (a direction from the parent to the subsidiary to discriminate) does not exist. In any event, there is no evidence that one corporation (Winters) ordered the other (Gears) to commit a Title VII discriminatory act.
Finally, Nesbit sets out no evidence - other than Gears’ and Winters’ common ownership - suggesting that substantive consolidation would make sense under the factors discussed. The two companies have different management. Nesbit described Randy Lau as “her boss” and conceded he was “more or less in charge” at Gears. While Vaughn Sr. fired Nesbit, we do not consider this a significant indication that Winters and Gears do not operate at arms length. Because Vaughn Sr. is president of Gears and a ten percent shareholder, it is unsurprising that he occasionally participated in Gears’ management.
11
He
That Gears and Winters coordinate in recruiting job applicants likewise does not make them a single entity under Title VII. Our outcome might be different if Gears had no say in hiring its own employees, if Gears and Winters held themselves out to job applicants as a single company, if the two companies’ human resources functions were entirely integrated, and/or if they did not maintain separate payrolls and finances. However, such a situation is not present here. Moreover, there is no record evidence that third parties dealt with Gears and Winters as one unit, that Gears and Winters covered the salaries of the other’s employees, or that Gears and Winters did business exclusively with each other.
In the absence of more significant operational entanglement, common ownership and
de minimis
coordination in hiring are insufficient bases to disregard the separate corporate forms of Gears and Winters. We therefore decline to view Gears and Winters as one entity for Title VII purposes. As Nesbit concedes that Gears alone employs fewer than fifteen employees, it is not an “employer” under
III. CONCLUSION
We hold that whether an entity employs fifteen or more workers is a merits question rather than a jurisdictional inquiry. Thus, because the District Court relied on materials external to the pleadings, it should have evaluated under the summary judgment standard Nesbit’s argument for viewing Gears and Winters collectively. Even under that standard, there is no basis to view Gears and Winters together as a single employer. Because Gears alone employs fewer than fifteen employees, we affirm the District Court’s dismissal of Nesbit’s complaint, albeit on the merits rather than for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.
Notes
. The parties dispute whether Vaughn Sr. or Madeline conducted the initial interview, though it is not important for our analysis.
. Nesbit is plaintiffs maiden name and the name she uses in this litigation. The name on her employment application and in Gears’ employment records is Norma J. Tran.
. In Walters v. Metropolitan Educational Enterprises, Inc., 519 U.S. 202, 117 S.Ct. 660, 136 L.Ed.2d 644 (1997), the Supreme Court granted certiorari to decide whether the Seventh Circuit erred in dismissing a Title VII suit for lack of subject matter jurisdiction because the defendant company lacked fifteen employees during the relevant period. The Court reversed and remanded, concluding that the Seventh Circuit had erred in determining the number of employees, but did not address whether the fifteen-employee requirement is jurisdictional or an element of the merits. Id. at 212, 117 S.Ct. 660.
Moreover, in
Hishon v. King & Spalding,
467 U.S. 69, 104 S.Ct. 2229, 81 L.Ed.2d 59 (1984), the Supreme Court found it “unnecessary to consider the District Court’s invocation of
. Likewise, in Trainor v. Apollo Metal Specialties, 318 F.3d 976, 978 n. 2 (10th Cir.2003), the Tenth Circuit held that whether an employer employs fifteen people is a jurisdictional question in a case brought under the ADA.
. Moreover, all the circuits that have held the fifteen-employee threshold jurisdictional have also stated - in the same case or in other cases - that “where the jurisdictional facts are intertwined with the facts central to the merits of the disputed] [i]t is the better view that . . . the entire factual dispute is appropriately resolved only by a proceeding on the merits.” Adams v. Bain, 697 F.2d 1213, 1219 (4th Cir.1982); see Clark v. Tarrant County, Texas, 798 F.2d 736, 741-42 (5th Cir.1986); Gould, Inc. v. Pechiney Ugine Kuhlmann, 853 F.2d 445, 451 (6th Cir.1988); Timberlane v. Bank of Am., 749 F.2d 1378, 1381 (9th Cir.1984), overruled on other grounds by Hartford Fire Ins. Co. v. California, 509 U.S. 764, 113 S.Ct. 2891, 125 L.Ed.2d 612 (1993); Wheeler v. Hurdman, 825 F.2d at 259; Morrison v. Amway Corp., 323 F.3d at 929. These cases highlight the unsettled nature of the merits/jurisdictional question.
. The Restatement (Second) of Judgments: Subject Matter Jurisdiction § 11 (1982) also addresses the question whether an issue affects subject matter jurisdiction or the merits, ultimately concluding that there is no principled way to distinguish between the two. It notes that “[t]here is a strong tendency in procedural law to treat various kinds of serious procedural errors as defects in subject matter jurisdiction . . . because characterizing a court’s departure in exercising authority as ‘jurisdictional’ permits an objection to the departure to be taken belatedly.” Restatement (Second) of Judgments: Subject Matter Jurisdiction § 11 cmt. e. Relevant to the question here, it goes on to note that
[t]he difficult problems are encountered when the issues on which the court‘s subject matter jurisdiction depends are not so clearcut. [For example,] if the court has jurisdiction of actions of more than a specified amount, there can be uncertainty in whether a particular claim exceeds that amount. The problem can be particularly difficult when the issue determining subject matter jurisdiction parallels an issue going to the merits.
Id. In those cases the Restatement concludes that “the matter in question can plausibly be characterized either as going to subject matter jurisdiction or as being one of merits or procedure.” Id.
. In addressing whether substantively to consolidate two entities in the bankruptcy context, courts have developed a number of different tests. Some have applied a seven-factor test, first set forth in In re Vecco Construction Industries, Inc., 4 B.R. 407 (Bankr. E.D.Va.1980). Those factors are: “(1) The presence or absence of consolidated finan cial statements; (2) The unity of interests and ownership between various corporate entities; (3) The existence of parent and in-tercorporate guarantees on loans; (4) The degree of difficulty in segregating and ascertaining individual assets and liabilities; (S) The existence of transfers of assets without formal observance of corporate formalities; (6) The commingling of assets and business functions; [and] (7) The profitability of consolidation at a single physical location.” Id. at 410; see also In re Mortgage Inv. Co., Ill B.R. 604, 610 (Bankr.W.D.Tex. 1990); Holy-well Corp. v. Bank of N.Y., 59 B.R. 340, 347 (S.D.Fla.1986); In re Donut Queen, Ltd., 41 B.R. 706, 709 (Bankr.E.D.N.Y.1984) (all applying the Vecco seven-factor test).
The First Circuit, in Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp. v. Ouimet Corp., 711 F.2d 1085 (1st Cir.1983), posed five nonexclusive factors a court should consider when contemplating substantive consolidation: whether (1) the parent owns a majority of the subsidiary’s stock; (2) the entities have common officers or directors; (3) the subsidiary is grossly un-dercapitalized; (4) the subsidiary transacts business solely with the parent; and (5) both entities disregard the legal requirements of the subsidiary as a separate corporation. Id. at 1093.
In In re Augie/Restivo Baking Co., 860 F.2d 515 (2d Cir.1988), the Second Circuit surveyed the caselaw and extracted two fundamental principles guiding the substantive consolidation inquiry: (1) “whether creditors dealt with the entities as a single economic unit and did not rely on their separate identity in extending credit” and (2) “whether the affairs [of the two companies] are so entangled” that consolidation will be beneficial. Id. at 518 (internal quotation marks omitted). The Ninth Circuit has also adopted this test. See In re Bonham, 229 F.3d 750, 766 (9th Cir.2000).
The Eighth Circuit considers three factors: (1) “the necessity of consolidation due to the interrelationship among the [entities]”; (2) “whether the benefits of consolidation outweigh the harm to creditors”; and (3) “prejudice resulting from not consolidating the debtors.” In re Giller, 962 F.2d 796, 799 (8th Cir.1992).
Finally, the D.C. and Eleventh Circuits have adopted a two-part test. First, the proponent of consolidation must make a prima facie case, demonstrating: (1) that “there is substantial identity between the entities to be consolidated; and (2) [that] consolidation is necessary to avoid some harm or to realize some benefit.” Eastgroup Props, v. S. Motel Assn, Ltd., 935 F.2d 245, 249 (11th Cir.1991); see also In re Auto-Train, 810 F.2d 270, 276 (D.C.Cir.1987). The Eastgroup Court noted that, in making this prima facie case, the proponent for consolidation may want to use the Vecco factors or the Ouimet factors discussed above. Eastgroup, 935 F.2d at 249. Once the proponent for consolidation has made this showing, “the burden shifts to an objecting creditor to show that (1) it has relied on the separate credit of one of the entities to be consolidated; and (2) it will be prejudiced by substantive consolidation.” Id.; see In re Auto-Train, 810 F.2d at 276.
. See generally Mary Elizabeth Kors, Altered Egos: Deciphering Substantive Consolidation, 49 U. Pitt. L.Rev. 381, 385 (1998) (“In cases where the disentanglement of the assets and liabilities of various entities is prohibitively expensive or even impossible, substantive consolidation may significantly increase creditor recoveries.”).
. Among them are (1) the degree of difficulty in segregating and ascertaining individual assets and liabilities, (2) the existence of transfers of assets without formal observance of corporate formalities, (3) the existence of parent and intercorporate loan guarantees, (4) whether the subsidiary is grossly undercapi-talized, and (5) the existence of consolidated financial statements.
. Employees or prospective employees are generally not sophisticated parties and typically do not have the opportunity to conduct extensive due diligence on employers to ascertain whether they will be protected by Title VII should they accept an offer of employment. This is in contrast to the arms-length commercial transactional process by which parties often become creditors in a bankruptcy case. In that context, the parties typically urging substantive consolidation are sophisticated and have had an opportunity to conduct due diligence on the debtor in question to determine its assets, liabilities, and corporate structure, and to bargain accordingly. Thus, absent exceptional circumstances, voluntary creditors should be able to recover only from the entity with which they have bargained. See Christopher W. Frost, Organizational Form, Misappropriation Risk, and the Substantive Consolidation of Corporate Groups, 44 Hastings L.J. 449, 453 (1993) (“[UJnlike voluntary creditors, tort claimants are unable to bargain for protection against, or compensation for, the increased risk limited liability imposes.”).
.While Vaughn Sr. is a director of both Gears and Winters, this fact does not aid Nesbit here. His directorships are likely inci dental to his stock ownership, as is often the case among closely held corporations. And as discussed, the overlapping ownership and management of Gears and Winters are insufficient, without more, to warrant substantive consolidation.