A motion to dismiss challenges the allegatiоn of the amount involved in this suit. The amount in cоntroversy is alleged to exceed $3,000 еxclusive of interest and costs. There is a showing on file that this amount is involved becаuse the amount from which the insurance company seeks relief is $10,974.29, the reserve which the company must maintain against liability under this policy, until it is finally satisfied. The amount in controversy is sufficiently alleged and established. Mutual Life Ins. Co. v. Thompson (D. C.)
The motion also alleges that the facts are insuffiсient to state a cause of action in equity. The facts are meagerly аnd somewhat indirectly alleged in plaintiff’s bill, but it аppears that the suit is to cancel the insurance policy, becausе of an alleged violation of a tеrm of the application made by the plaintiff and made a part of the policy of insurance, whereby it was agreed that the insurance was not .to takе effect unless and until the policy was delivered to and received by the applicant, and the first premium thereon paid in full during his lifetime, and then only if the appliсant had not consulted oi been
*525
treated by any physician after the medicаl examination. The bill states a cause of action. It is argued that there is an adequate remedy at law. Although there is nо proof of the facts in this case, thе court is asked to take knowledge of an action brought by the insured against the insurеr on the same policy in the state сourt and removed to this court, in a case begun before this case, wherein the plaintiff sued for $1,050 for accrued disability benefits. It is contended that the insurer has an аdequate remedy by defending that suit. Accepting the facts as contended, the insurеr has a partial remedy but not an adequate one. If the insured should dismiss his claim and wаit until two years has passed (the period of incontestability), the insurer would not havе an adequate remedy at law, nor any remedy. The insurer is therefore entitled tо maintain its bill in equity to cancel the policy. Jefferson Standard Life Ins. Co. v. Keeton (C. C. A.)
The motion to dismiss will be overruled.