New Haven Clock Co. v. KocherspergerNew Haven Clock Co. v. Kochersperger
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Cartwright
delivered the opinion of the court:
Plaintiff in error filed its bill in the superior court of Cook county against defendants in error, as county treasurer and county clerk of Cook county and town collector of the town of South Chicago, in that county, praying for an injunction restraining the collection of the excess of taxes extended against it above the sum of $22.13, which would be the amount of its taxes on an assessment of $200. Demurrers to the original bill were sustained. The bill was amended and demurrers to the amended bill were overruled, and the defendants were ruled to plead or answer. Thereupon the defendant the collector of the tow‘ll of South Chicago filed his plea that there was no money due from complainant for taxes, and that he had not in his hands any warrant for the collection of a tax from it. The defendants the county clerk and county collector filed similar pleas. The abstract does not show any action on these pleas, but complainant, by leave of court, filed a supplemental bill reciting the previous proceedings, and alleging that afterwards, while the case was pending in court, the town collector, armed with his warrant, by means of threats to levy on and take possession of complainant’s property, which he was about to execute, made a compulsory collection of the entire tax, $553.20, which complainant paid under protest, and that this compulsory payment was the sole defense alleged by the pleas. The demurrers previously filed were ordered to stand to this supplemental bill, and the court sustained them. Complainant elected to stand by its bills, and the amended and supplemental bills were dismissed for want of equity.
The facts appearing by the amended and supplemental bills, to which the demurrers were sustained and which were thereby admitted, were in substance as follows: The entire personal credits and effects, including cash on hand
This case has been argued with five others, and counsel say that the six cases present substantially the same questions. We find, however, that there is an important difference between this case and the others, which renders a .considerable part of the argument entirely inapplicable. This difference is, that in the other cases the property was assessed at less than its fair cash value, and as to them it is urged that the only real complaint is. that the complainants therein were assessed at a higher rate than others. The argument that there is no just cause of complaint where the assessment does not exceed the fair cash value, although others are assessed at a less rate, cannot be applied to this case, since the fair cash value is $2000 and the assessment $5000. The question in this case is, whether complainant could have relief against an excessive assessment which was made .with full knowledge of the facts and from a wrongful and fraudulent motive..
Complainant presented its grievance to the county board, and that board undertook to divest itself of the duty imposed upon it by law by resolving that it was impossible to go into inequalities and injustice against individuals and to hear and decide the case as required by law. Its committee made no recommendation except that the complaint be placed on file without prejudice to complainant’s appeal to the courts. This report was adopted by the board and complainant was” ordered to take its departure from that forum without a decision. This was no more or less than a refusal of the board to do its duty, and the law would have compelled its performance on the application of complainant. It is said by Judge Cooley of the writ of mandamus: “A suitable case for the employment of the writ is where it is found necessary to compel county commissioners
It has always been held that equity would enjoin the collection of a tax upon property exempt from taxation, and the question as to what effect the failure to follow the statutory remedy will have as to such a tax has been before the court several times. Section 97 of the Revenue act provides for a hearing and determination by the county board of the question whether property is exempt from taxation, and for an appeal from such decision, when, the Auditor shall present the case to this court for fiual decision. In Preston v. Johnson, 104 Ill. 625, it was charged in a bill in equity that a tax was illegally levied upon property not subject to taxation. There had been an application to the county board, where it was claimed that complainants were denied a hearing, but it was held that there was an adequate remedy at law, and tha,t if complainants were aggrieved by any action whatever of the board, their plain remedy was by an appeal. It was there said that the remedy through the county board of review and by appeal is adequate and exclusive. In Peoria Fair Ass. v. People, 111 Ill. 559, the association petitioned the county board to strike its lands from the assessment roll, but the board refused the petition and no appeal was taken. It was held that on application for judgment the defense could be made, and that it was only in case the question had been brought before this court and this court had passed- upon it that-the party would
Where property is exempt from taxation the owner has a right -to assume that the law will be observed, and he is not required to take notice of its illegal assessment nor to appear before the local tribunal, but‘is protected by the law and may resort to a court of equity for an injunction. When complaint is made that the assessor has over-valued the property, whether as a mistake of judgment or from whatever motive, the situation is different. The property is subject to assessment, and it is the duty of the owner to take notice of the assessment. The valuation is not an act without jurisdiction or authority, and if it is excessive the law intends that application shall be made to the board. The statute embraces every kind of grievance in the assessment, and whatever its nature may be, the tax-payer may make his complaint known and have a hearing. (Felsenthal v. Johnson, 104 Ill. 21.) It was proper for complainant to appeal to the county board directly, as the assessment was made after the fourth Monday of June. This remedy afforded by the statute is intended to be sufficient for the relief of the tax-payer. The
In Spring Valley Coal Co. v. People, supra, where fraud was charged, the coal company applied to the town board of review and secured reductions in some of the values, and on appeal to the county board there was a hearing, where it obtained still further reductions in value. It was there said that, assuming the assessment to be fraudulent, the coal company availed itself of the remedy given by the statute and the decision made by the board of supervisors was final and conclusive, and it must be regarded that the fraud, if any, that there was in the original assessment was purged out of it. In that case the presumption that the owner had obtained full relief was indulged; but if he does not obtain relief as against a fraudulent assessment we do not think that the statute is the sole remedy. Fraud is a familiar ground of equity jurisdiction, and if an assessment is fraudulent, equity should relieve against it where the tax-payer has been diligent in seeking the remedy which the statute affords. In matters of revenue it is important that all questions should be speedily settled, and the tax-payer should first seek the remedy given by the statute, which it is presumed will be sufficient. If he fails to do so it is his own neglect or folly. The remedy against fraud is of an equitable nature, and should be applied where the injured party has been diligent for his own protection, but we think it should be withheld in a case of this kind, where the party has failed to insist upon a legal right which probably would have given full relief. The reports of the committee to the board plainly show that in its judgment assessments returned by some of the assessors, and complained of, were unequal and unjust. The board merely refused to do its duty and decide the cases. Although complainant was denied a hearing before the county board it had an adequate remedy to compel its performanee. It is said that this
The fact that the abstract does not show what-was done with the pleas of defendants is immaterial, in the view taken of the case. The bill was filed and the court had acquired jurisdiction of the subject matter and the parties. Complainant had prayed for an injunction, which had not been secured, but after the court had acquired jurisdiction, if the collector enforced payment of the tax that fact would not constitute any defense to the bill, but the money was collected subject to the power of the court to compel the collector to refund it or submit to such other decree concerning it as might be equitable. A party filing a bill for an injunction may fail to procure a preliminary injunction, but any act after the court has acquired jurisdiction will be subject to the power of the court to compel a restoration of the status or to enforce such other relief as may be proper. Pleas making such a defense would be insufficient as answers to the amended bill,, but the final decree of the court dismissing the amended and supplemental bills was correct, as we think, for the reason given, that complainant had not availed itself of the remedy secured to it by the statute to be relieved from the wrong complained of in the bill before seeking such relief in a court of equity.
The decree of the superior court will therefore be affirmed.
Decree affirmed.
Mr. Justice Magruder, dissenting.