Neal v. BoykinNeal v. Boykin
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Beck
(After stating the facts.)
Mr. Schouler in his work on Executors and Administrators (3d ed.), §25, says, “Local jurisdiction [to appoint an administrator on the estate of a non-resident decedent] is upheld on the ground that bona notabilia exist when letters are applied for, notwithstanding the goods were brought into the county, or the debtor removed thither subsequently to the death of the owner or creditor; and this seems the better opinion, unless such bringing in or removal was in bad faith, and with the intention of conferring improperly *681■a colorable probate jurisdiction.” And so we hold in the present ease, that if *tlie note was brought into DeKalb county, as alleged in the petition, as a part of a fraudulent scheme for the purpose of giving falsely a colorable and pretended jurisdiction to the ■court- of ordinary of that count}‘, it would not be bona notabilia within the county of DeKalb for the purpose of founding administration. But irrespective of the question of bad faith in bringing the note into DeKalb county, the mere existence of such promissory note in that county payable to the decedent, when the maker of the mote resides in Talbot county, would not confer jurisdiction on the probate court of DeKalb county to grant letters of administration on the estate of the deceased non-resident payee. In the case of Arnold v. Arnold, 62 Ga. 627, it was held, that, for the‘purpose of granting letters of administration on the estate of a non-resident decedent, “debts by simple contract are bona notabilia in the county where the debtor resides.” And in the ease of Wyman v. Halstead, 109 U. S. 654, Mr. Justice Gray said, “The general rule of law is well settled, that, for the purpose of founding administration, all simple contract debts are assets at the domicil of the debtor; and that the locality of such a debt for this purpose is not affected by a bill of exchange or promissory note having been given for it, because the bill or note does not alter the nature of the debt, but is merely evidence of it, and therefore the debt is assets where the debtoF lives, without regard to the place where the instrument is found or payable.” The doctrine here stated is an enunciation of the common law upon the subject dealt with, and’ is in harmony with the rule deducible from our Civil Code, §§3393, 4234, which are an adoption and codification of the common law upon the subject of the grant of administration on the estate of a non-resident. See also 11 Am. & Eng. Enc. L. (2d ed.) 764; 18 Cyc. 73. If, therefore, the allegations of the petition are true (and they must be so considered in passing upon the general demurrer), the court of ordinary of DeKalb county had no jurisdiction to grant letters of administration upon the estate of McCormick Neal, deceased, and the rendition of the judgment appointing such administrator was procured by fraudulent representations, upon the part of the defendant in this case, as to the facts necessary to give the court jurisdiction.
An action to set aside or vacate the judgment of the court of ordinary, appointing a permanent administrator, is not a suit concerning personal property, nor was it instituted “for the purpose of collecting and taking care of the effects of the deceased.” And we do not think that the temporary administrator has any power or authority to institute and maintain a suit for the purpose of setting; aside, or vacating such judgment.
The petitioners in the present case were heirs and creditors of the decedent. They were‘interested in the assets of the estate, and their distribution. They would, therefore, have been heard as caveators when the application for letters of administration was pending. Towner v. Griffin, 115 Ga. 966. And it is quite clear *683that they are the proper parties plaintiff to the proceeding to vacate or set aside the judgment appointing the administrator. See Jones v. Smith, 120 Ga. 642. The fact that citation was‘published would not prevent the plaintiffs, who had no knowledge of the application for letters of administration, from moving in due time to have the, judgment, appointing the administrator, set aside. Demis v. Albritton, 127 Ga. 517.
Judgment reversed.
- All the Justices concur, except Holden, J who did not preside.