Nashoalook v. StateNashoalook v. State
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Coats
OPINION
COATS, Judge.
Alva K. Nashoalook, Jr. was convicted, based upon his plea of no contest, of arson in the second degree, a class B felony.
At approximately two a.m. on June 24, 1986, Alva Nashoalook went to the apartment of North Slope Borough Department of Public Safety Officer Jeff Deutsch. Na-shoalook told Deutsch that his wife, Dorothy Nashoalook, had another man staying at her residence. Nashoalook wanted Deutsch to remove this man. Deutsch told Nashoalook that he did not consider this to be a police matter. He told Nashoalook that he should talk to his wife about these matters. Then, if he could not remedy the situation, he should get a divorce. Deutsch indicated that Nashoalook was very upset at the time that he had this conversation.
Later that morning, a fire started at the residence of Dorothy Nashoalook. Enoch Oktollik saw smoke coming from the house. He ran over to the house but was unable to get a response from the people inside. Oktollik broke in through the door and woke up Dorothy Nashoalook, her boyfriend, and a child who were in the house. Oktollik and several other people managed to control the fire. Enoch Oktollik indicated that if the fire had not been put out, that Dorothy Nashoalook’s residence would have burned down.
Following the fire, Officer Deutsch interviewed Alva Nashoalook. Nashoalook admitted that after talking to Deutsch he had gone over to his wife’s house, lit a roll of toilet paper, and threw it in the back arctic entryway. Nashoalook said that he saw the fire start. He then walked off. Na-shoalook stated that he knew Dorothy Na-shoalook was in the home, and that he believed that her boyfriend was also there. Nashoalook admitted that when he started the fire he knew it was possible for the whole house to burn down with the people in it.
In sentencing Nashoalook, Judge Jeffery found several aggravating factors.
1
Nashoalook challenges only one of these aggravating factors,
We discussed the application of this aggravating factor in Larson v. State, 688 P.2d 592, 597-98 (Alaska App. 1984). In Larson, the defendant argued that AS 12.-55.155(c)(8) could not be based on a single conviction. However, we did not have to resolve the issue because we found that Larson had two or more prior convictions for purposes of applying the aggravating factor.
In
Larson,
we pointed out that AS 12.55.-155(c)(8) originally provided for an aggravating factor when “the defendant has a criminal history consisting of prior convictions for offenses, including misdemeanors, that involve aggravated or repeated instances of assaultive behavior.” We concluded that current
It does not appear that the legislature intended modified
We have consistently held that: “[ajmbi-guities in criminal statutes must be narrowly read and construed strictly against the government.” We have also held that “[i]f a statute establishing a penalty is susceptible of more than one meaning, it should be construed so as to provide the most lenient penalty.”
State v. Andrews,
707 P.2d 900, 907 (Alaska App. 1985),
aff‘d
723 P.2d 85 (Alaska 1986).
See
3 C. Sands,
Sutherland Statutory Construction,
§§ 59.03, 59.04, 59.06 (4th ed. 1985). We conclude that it is questionable that the legislature intended for
The state argues that the sentence which Judge Jeffery imposed would not have been different even under Nashoa-look’s interpretation of
Nashoalook next contends that Judge Jeffery erred in not finding the mitigating factor that Nashoalook “committed the offense under some degree of duress, coercion, threat, or compulsion insufficient to constitute a complete defense, but which significantly affected the defendant’s conduct.”
In analyzing the mitigating factor set out in
The case is REMANDED.
Notes
. One of these aggravating factors appears to be particularly significant in justifying the sentence which Judge Jeffery imposed. Judge Jeffery found that “the conduct constituting the offense was among the most serious conduct included in the definition of the offense.” AS 12.55.-155(c)(10). In making this finding, Judge Jeffery pointed out that Nashoalook had been convicted of arson in the second degree, a class B felony.
. The following is from the 1980 Senate Journal Supp. No. 44 at 24:
AS 12.55.155(c)(8) . Modification of Aggravating Factor.
In response to a further suggestion by the Advisory Committee on Minority Judicial Sentencing Practices, this amendment more narrowly describes the aggravating factor that the defendant has a prior criminal history of assaultive behavior, including misdeameanor convictions.
The following is from the 1982 House Journal Supp. No. 64 at 22:
AS 12.55.155(c)(8) . Aggravating Factor.
This section eliminates the requirement that a presumptive term of imprisonment can only be aggravated in cases involving prior convictions for misdemeanors involving repeated instances of assaultive behavior. This change is consistent with existing case law allowing verified information of a defendant’s prior criminal history to be considered by a judge at sentencing, Nukapigak v. State, 562 P.2d 697 (Alaska 1977).