Morgan's Estate
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Bean
Lead Opinion
delivered the. opinion of the court.
There are three questions presented for our consideration: (1) Whether, under Section 1161, B. & C. Comp., the county court, sitting in the transaction of probate business, has jurisdiction to adjudicate and allow a claim for more than $500 against an estate; (2) whether the notes upon which the claim of the bank is based were in fact the obligations of the partnership of Morgan & Stowell; and (3) whether they are barred by the statute of limitations.
The claim in this case was presented for allowance in April, Í897. It was not then barred by the statute of limitations. Until it was disallowed by the executrix, or until she had retained.it a reasonable time without acting on it, no action could have been commenced by the claimant to recover thereon. Dining the time it was properly pending before the executrix, the cause of action was stayed by. the statute, and therefore is not a part of the time limited by the general statute of limitations for the commencement of an action on the claim. An executor or administrator is entitled to a reasonable time after the presentation of a claim in which to examine it to ascertain whether he will allow or disallow it, but, unless he takes some action thereon within such time, the claimant, at his option, may treat the claim as disallowed, and act accordingly: Goltra v. Penland, 45 Or. 254 (77 *239Pac. 129). This right, however, is believed to be personal to the claimant, who may waive it, and permit the claim to remain in the hands of the executor for further consideration. If he does so, and it is afterwards rejected, the right to commence an action will date from the time of rejection, and not from the time the claimant might have elected to treat the claim as disallowed and commenced an action if he had so desired. The claim in suit was indorsed “disallowed,” but the time when such indorsement was made is not stated. The notation is not dated, and there is no proof whatever on the subject. The statute provides that whenever a claim is disallowed by an executor or administrator he shall indorse thereon the words “Examined and rejected,” with the date thereof, and sign the same officially (B. & C. Comp. § 1161), but whether, in such case, the claimant should be notified thereof, either personally or constructively, by the executor or administrator filing a proper report with the county court, as required by the statute, is not clear.
But however that may be, and whatever may be the rule in this regard in ordinary oases, we are of the opinion that under the facts of this particular case the executrix can not be permitted to insist that ‘the claim was rejected by her prior to the time the bank or its assignee was advised of her action. When the claim was presented, the bank was advised in writing that it would be notified of the action of the executrix thereon as soon as had. Some seven or eight months later it was assured that the estate “would undoubtedly pay every dollar it owes,” but it would be necessary to sell some of the real estate, which the executrix was endeavoring to do, but could not rush the matter without such a sacrifice as would be injurious not alone to the estate but to the creditors, and they were therefore requested, “in their own interests, to be patient.” By these statements and promises and the conversations with the attorney of the estate the bank was lulled into security, and did not press the payment of its claim. Belying upon such promises and statements, and in view of the general condition of the estate, and its desire that the largest amount possible should be realized from the assets, it was indulgent, and the executrix ought not now be permitted to insist that its rights have been injuriously affected by some *240secret action of hers in rejecting the claim. If it was to be rejected because not an obligation of the estate, the proper indorsement should have been made thereon, the bank advised by the return of the claim, or in some other manner, of the action of the executrix, so that it could have taken such steps as it might deem proper to protect its interests. This was not done, nor did the. executrix file with the county court, as required by law, a report of the claims presented against the estate. On the contrary, the claim remained either in her possession or her attorney’s, and it was not until the statute of limitations had run that the bank’s assignee was advised that the claim had been rejected. We are of the opinion, therefore, that the time during which the claim was in the hands of the executrix for examination, without notifying the bank that it had been rejected, should not be taken as a part of the time limited by the statute for the commencement of the action thereon.
It follows that the judgment of the court below should be reversed, and it is so ordered. Reversed.
Rehearing
Decided 3 January, 1905.
On Motion eor Rehearing.
Mr. Justice Beandelivered the opinion of the court.
We think we have made our position clear on the statute of limitations, and do not deem it necessary to elaborate further. The petition is denied. Reversed : Rehearing Denied.