Moore v. DozierMoore v. Dozier
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Lumpkin
Cases of this character are becoming so common that there may be at times danger of losing sight of the fact that they involve principles which lie at the basis of society and of government. They include no less a question than the determination of where the right of the individual to his or her own children must yield to their good and that of society, of which they are members. Ordinarily a father, or if no father the mother, has a right to the custody of his or her children. Civil Code, §§ 2502, 2503. The mother may be poor, but poverty alone, save in extreme cases, furnishes no reason to deprive her of her children. The rich can not say to the lowly, “You are poor and have many children. I am rich and have none. You are unlearned and live in a cabin. I am learned and live in a mansion. Let the State take one of your *93children and give it a better home with me. I will rear it better than you can.” The hovel has its rights as well as the ‘palaceThe ties of motherhood too are not to be lightly disregarded. The Mosaic account of the creation completes but three short chapters when the fourth opens with the glad cry of motherhood, as Eve said, “I have gotten a man from the Lord P And from then till now the deepest, the tenderest, the most unswerving and unfaltering thing on earth is the love of a mother for her child. The love of a good mother is the holiest thing this side of heaven. The natural ties of motherhood are not to be destroyed or disregarded save for some sound reason. Even a sinning and erring woman still clings to the child of her shame, and, though bartering her own honor, will rarely fail to fight for that of her daughter. A mother who will wilfully sacrifice her daughter’s virtue is so rare as to be looked upon as a moral monstrosity. The law recognizes that although a woman may have made a misstep, this does not necessarily render her unfit to have the care of her child; for the Civil Code (§ 2509) declares that the mother of an illegitimate child is entitled to its custody.
While this is true, and the rights arising from nature are not to be lightly set aside, yet where people form- society and establish a government for their mutual welfare and protection, they must yield something of their individual rights for the common good. The children of the State to-day are to be the men and women of to-morrow — the citizens, the fathers and mothers. While the State will not usurp the place of the parents, it will look to the protection of the children from suffering or degradation. If the parent so far fails in his or her duty that the child is in destitution and suffering or is abandoned, or is being reared under immoral, indecent, or obscene influences, likely to degrade it and bring it to a life of vice, the State may interpose its protecting arm and guard the little life against the impending disaster. As was said in Hunter v. Dowdy, 100 Ga. 644, speaking of a female child in a similar case, “Any fate would be better for the child than the disgrace and ruin which would follow her prostitution. No place could be a worse one for her than the home of a wicked and shameless mother.” We deem it not amiss to thus mention the serious question which such eases raise — on the one hand the recognition of natural rights and duties, the importance of the relation of parent *94and child, and of the family, which is a factor in the upbuilding of the State; and, on the other hand, the right and power of the State to save the little ones from .ruin. The judge before whom such a case is brought has no more solemn duty to perform than the awarding of the custody of a child.
While general character is shown by general reputation in the community where a person resides or where he does business or frequents, a witness must state that he knows the general reputation, before he can swear to it. On cross-examination he may be asked touching the sources of his knowledge. But it is .not competent for him to testify that he does not know the general reputation of the person under consideration, and that he merely heard certain evidence on a former trial, and from it he thinks such reputation bad. It might be interesting, but not pertinent, to consider the origin and growth of the rule by which general reputation came to be treated as proof of or synonymous with general character. A discussion of this subject will be found in 3 Wigmore on Evidence, 81981 et seq.
It is contended that the judgment of the ordinary, approved by the judge of the superior court on writ of certiorari, was without evidence to support it. As the case must be again tried, we express no opinion upon this subject, further than to say, that upon the hearing of a writ of habeas corpus involving the custody of children, the presiding judge is vested with broad discretion; that he should consider the legal evidence before him, including that bearing upon the question as to whether or not there has been a reformation or a change of circumstances which would render it proper to restore the children to the mother’s custody (Kirkland v. Canty, 122 Ga. 261), or whether she is still an immoral and improper person to rear them, and whether it is necessary for the protection of such children from suffering or from degradation that their custody by others should be continued. The relation of parent and child is not to be overlooked or disregarded without sufficient cause, but the moral and physical safety and interest of the children must also not be forgotten. .Sehouler’s Domestic Relations (5th ed.), § 348; Haire v. McCardle, 107 Ga. 777. The proceeding under which the children were committed to the home was. taken under the Civil Code, § 3505. That section was not repealed by the act of 1904 (Acts 1904, p. 93).
Judgment reversed, with direction.
Fish, C. J., absent. The other Justices concur.