Miller v. MenghiniMiller v. Menghini
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Seymour
Richard Miller, a pro se prisoner, brought this civil rights complaint under
Mr. Miller’s complaint is governed by
We addressed
Although in
Garrett
the plaintiff sought
only
money damages, we have applied its holding, albeit in unpublished dispositions, in eases where as here the plaintiff seeks both monetary and injunctive relief.
See Fever v. Booker,
No. 98-3239, 1999 WL 136922 (10th Cir. Mar.15, 1999);
Florence v. Booker,
No. 98-3153, 1998 WL 694521 (10th Cir. Oet.6,1998).
1
In those cases, we reversed the dismissal of the monetary claims. While unpublished cases do not constitute precedent,
see
10th Cir. R. 36.3, we find these cases persuasive. Although
Garrett, Fever
and
Florence
involved
Bivens
claims brought by federal prisoners in which federal administrative procedures are at issue, we see no reason why their analysis is not also applicable to state prisoners bringing civil rights claims under
Mr. Miller is not required to exhaust his claim against state prison officials for monetary damages because no available state administrative procedures provide that remedy. In dismissing the entire action, the district court did not distinguish between Mr. Miller’s monetary and injunctive claims and did not address the existence or adequacy of state procedures with respect to Mr. Miller’s monetary claims. Accordingly, dismissal of those claims was improper. Dismissal of Mr. Miller’s claims for injunctive relief, however, was appropriate. See Florence, 1998 WL 694521 at *2.
We REVERSE with respect to Mr. Miller’s claims for monetary relief and REMAND those claims for further consideration in light of this ruling. We AFFIRM the dismissal of Mr. Miller’s claim for in-junctive relief.
Notes
. The courts have varied widely in applying the exhaustion requirement of