Merrick v. JenningsMerrick v. Jennings
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Roberts
Opinion by
Mr. Justice Roberts,Appellant John R. Merrick, a resident and assistant públie defender of Chester County, filed a complaint in equity “on behalf of present and future indigent defendants” seeking to enjoin the county sheriff and warden from applying and enforcing three Pennsylvania statutes which permit imprisonment for nonpayment of fines. * Appellant alleged that application of these statutes to indigents would violate the United States Supreme Court’s holding in Tate v. Short, 401 U.S. 395, 398, 91 S. Ct. 668, 671 (1971), that: “ ‘[Tjhe Constitution prohibits the State from imposing a fine as a sentence and then automatically converting it into a jail term solely because the defendant is indigent and cannot forthwith pay the fine in full.’ ”
Appellant’s complaint was dismissed by the Chester County Common Pleas Court on the grounds that (1) a
We need not reach the merits of appellant’s complaint, for we agree fully with the court below that the indigent defendants appellant seeks to protect have a full, complete and adequate remedy at law, and thus appellant’s complaint is not cognizable in equity. See Cooper v. McDermott, 399 Pa. 160, 159 A. 2d 486 (1960); Lapaglia Contractors, Inc. v. Baldwin Borough, 382 Pa. 475, 115 A. 2d 236, affirming 2 Pa. D. & C. 2d 736 (1955). Indigent defendants who are threatened with imprisonment for nonpayment of fines may raise the holding of Tate v. Short at trial, and at that time fully pursue their constitutional rights under that decision.
Appellant contends, however, that the indigent defendants he seeks to protect have no adequate remedy at law since the courts of Chester County have not and will not enforce the principles announced by the United States Supreme Court in
Tate.
This contention must be categorically rejected. All that appellant can point to is a decision by the late president judge of the Chester County Common Pleas Court which refused to release a defendant whose term of imprisonment was extended because of his inability to pay certain court costs that had been imposed upon him.
Commonwealth ex rel. Supulski v. Jennings,
No. 149 October Term,
Accordingly thé decree is affirmed. Appellant to bear costs.
Notes
The statutes wliose enforcement appellant seeks to’ enjoin are: Act of July 12, 1842, P.-L. 339, §1,