133 A. 29 | Pa. | 1926
The question for determination is, Whether the funeral expenses of a deceased married woman, who leaves a surviving husband, are deductible in calculating the clear value of her estate for transfer inheritance tax purposes. The orphans' court determined that they are and from the decree dismissing its exceptions the Commonwealth appeals.
We think it not necessary to review the legislation on the subject of inheritance taxes prior to the Act of July 12, 1923, P. L. 1078, which is the statute under which the Commonwealth seeks to maintain a tax on the amount expended for funeral expenses. That act provides, "All taxes imposed by this act shall be at the rate of two per centum upon the clear value of the property subject to such tax passing to or for the use of father, mother, husband, wife, children, . . . . . . and at the rate of ten per centum upon the clear value of the property subject to such tax passing to or for the use of any other person or persons, bodies corporate or politic; to be paid for the use of the Commonwealth. In ascertaining the clear value of such estates, the only deductions to be allowed from the gross values of such estates shall be the debts of the decedent,reasonable and customary funeral expenses, bequests or devises in trust, in reasonable amounts, the entire interest or income from which is to be perpetually applied to the care and preservation of the family burial lot or lots, their enclosures and structures erected thereon, reasonable expenses for the erection of monuments or gravestones, grave and lot markers, and the expenses of the administration of such estates, . . . . . ." It will be seen that whatever may have been the language of prior enactments providing for the collection of taxes on decedent's estates and however they may have been judicially construed, the act now to be considered provides in express terms that, "in ascertaining the clear value . . . . . the . . . . . deductions to be allowed from the gross values . . . . . . shall be [among *152
others] reasonable and customary funeral expenses." The Commonwealth argues that the husband is primarily liable for his wife's funeral expenses and, this being so, we should read into the act a limitation of deductibility to such expenditures as the wife's estate would be primarily liable for, citing to us such cases as Waesch's Est.,
There is a direction in the will that all funeral expenses shall be paid out of the estate; it is our view, however, that the presence or absence of such a provision has no bearing on the question presented.
The judgment is affirmed.